e11596 Background: Tubular carcinoma of the breast (TC) is a rare histologic subtype of breast cancer considered to have a favorable prognosis relative to other histologies. TC is by definition low grade. TC is described to have clinical behavior similar to low grade ductal and lobular breast cancers, but due to its infrequent presentation, long-term follow-up studies of TC are lacking. Methods: The Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Results database was queried to include the years 1988-2009, selecting for patients with either grade 1 TC or grade 1 ductal and lobular breast cancer (G1BC). Data collected included age at diagnosis, race, stage, receptor status, overall survival, and surgery type. Two Cox proportional hazard models were assessed for differences between TC and G1BC, adjusting for age at diagnosis. Results: In SEER 18, 115,945 cases of TC+G1BC breast cancer are found, with 6.1% classified as TC. Of TC cases, 91% are stage 1, while 71% of GIBC are stage 1. Presenting stage 3 or 4 disease occurred in only 4.7% of G1BC versus 0.68% of TC cases. Due to the rarity of advanced disease, we analyzed early stage disease. For early Stage (1-2) breast cancer, mean age was 61.5 years for TC and 63.5 years for G1BC. The TC cases were 92% white, 4% black, 97% Estrogen Receptor (ER) positive, 82% Progesterone Receptor (PR) positive. Of G1BC cases, 88% were white, 5% black, 96% ER positive, 84% PR positive. Treatment differed with 76% of TC patients receiving lumpectomy versus G1BC where 65% received lumpectomy (p<0.001). There was no significant difference in overall survival between Stage I TC and G1BC (p=0.98), or between Stage II TC and G1BC (p=0.075), with the survival estimate higher for TC. Conclusions: In this large-scale analysis, TC was limited to early stage disease and there was no difference in overall survival between patients with early stage TC and early stage GIBC. There were similar receptor statuses and baseline characteristics, but more conservative surgical treatment in TC. Because no survival difference exists for early stage disease, the finding of tubular histology to guide treatment decisions may not be warranted.
Read full abstract