Polycysticovarysyndrome(PCOS)isadisorderofmetabolic as well as reproductive function; common (although not universal) comorbidities include insulin resistance, hyperinsulinemia,hypoadiponectinemia,dyslipidemia,hepatic steatosis, carotid intimal medial thickening, impaired glucose tolerance, and a predisposition to type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease (1, 2). Studies in monozygotic and dizygotic twins (3) suggest that PCOS emerges from the interaction of genetic and environmental factors; the latter may include intrauterine as well as nutritional determinants (1). High-risk groups include low birth weight girls who develop precocious adrenarche and children with family histories of PCOS (4). Sixty percent of patients with PCOS are overweight or obese, and even “normal-weight” subjects have relative visceral adiposity and heightened production of inflammatory adipocytokines (5, 6). Obesity itself causes insulin resistance and may promote free testosterone excess and oligomenorrhea/anovulation throughup-regulationofovarian and adipose tissue 17-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase 5 expression and down-regulation of hepatic SHBG (1, 7); thus, it is not entirely clear which, and to what extent, the clinical features of PCOS derive from excess adiposity (1, 7–9). Some studies find that insulin resistance and metabolic dysfunction are more severe in adolescents and women with PCOS than in body mass index (BMI)-matched subjects without hirsutism and menstrual irregularity (1, 9). Yet the hyperandrogenism and metabolic defects of PCOS are clearly aggravated by excess weight gain and visceral fat accumulation (1, 5–9). Thus, control of body weight and white adipose storage remains a primary goal in the management of all patients with PCOS. What is the best way to achieve reductions in total body and visceral fat while countering androgen excess, restoring menstrual function, and preventing or reversing the metabolic comorbidities of PCOS? Studies in adults with PCOS show that loss of 5–10% of body weight through diet and exercise counseling can reduce androgen levels and improve menstrual function in approximately 50% of cases (1, 10). Thus, lifestyle intervention is considered by many to be the first line of treatment for PCOS in adults. However, simple weight loss may fail to normalize insulin secretion, glucose tolerance, or dyslipidemia in adults with PCOS and does not always restore menstrual cyclicity or reduce hirsutism scores. Are lifestyle approaches effective for the treatment of PCOS in adolescence? The study by Lass et al. (11) in this issue of JCEM suggests that a lifestyle program consisting of nutrition education (using a generic “traffic light” diet that focused on reducing caloric density), exercise training, and behavior therapy can provide reproductive and metabolic benefits in some obese teenage girls with PCOS. Among 59 patients who completed the 12-month program, the 26 who lost weight (minimum BMI change, 0.2 SD; mean BMI, 3.9 kg/m; mean BMI z-score, 0.63) had significant reductions in blood pressure ( 9 mm Hg systolic, 8 mm Hg diastolic), plasma insulin ( 6 U/ml), and serum triglycerides ( 26 mg%); an 8 mg% rise in high-density lipoprotein levels; and an 18% reduction in carotid intimal medial thickness (CIMT). Testosterone levels fell, SHBG levels rose, and menstrual cycles normalized in 61% of the weight responders. In contrast, there was no recovery of menstrual function and no change in metabolic comorbidities in subjects who failed to lose (or gained) weight. These findings are similar to those of Hoeger et al. (12), who showed that modest weight loss (BMI, 1.1 kg/m) can reduce free androgen index by 59% and increase SHBG by 122% in teenage
Read full abstract