Learning Context-free Grammars Research Articles

Learning of Structurally Unambiguous Probabilistic Grammars

The problem of identifying a probabilistic context free grammar has two aspects: the first is determining the grammar's topology (the rules of the grammar) and the second is estimating probabilistic weights for each rule. Given the hardness results for learning context-free grammars in general, and probabilistic grammars in particular, most of the literature has concentrated on the second problem. In this work we address the first problem. We restrict attention to structurally unambiguous weighted context-free grammars (SUWCFG) and provide a query learning algorithm for \structurally unambiguous probabilistic context-free grammars (SUPCFG). We show that SUWCFG can be represented using \emph{co-linear multiplicity tree automata} (CMTA), and provide a polynomial learning algorithm that learns CMTAs. We show that the learned CMTA can be converted into a probabilistic grammar, thus providing a complete algorithm for learning a structurally unambiguous probabilistic context free grammar (both the grammar topology and the probabilistic weights) using structured membership queries and structured equivalence queries. A summarized version of this work was published at AAAI 21.

Learning of Structurally Unambiguous Probabilistic Grammars

The problem of identifying a probabilistic context free grammar has two aspects: the first is determining the grammar's topology (the rules of the grammar) and the second is estimating probabilistic weights for each rule. Given the hardness results for learning context-free grammars in general, and probabilistic grammars in particular, most of the literature has concentrated on the second problem. In this work we address the first problem. We restrict attention to structurally unambiguous weighted context-free grammars (SUWCFG) and provide a query learning algorithm for strucuturally unambiguous probabilistic context-free grammars (SUPCFG). We show that SUWCFG can be represented using co-linear multiplicity tree automata (CMTA), and provide a polynomial learning algorithm that learns CMTAs. We show that the learned CMTA can be converted into a probabilistic grammar, thus providing a complete algorithm for learning a strucutrally unambiguous probabilistic context free grammar (both the grammar topology and the probabilistic weights) using structured membership queries and structured equivalence queries. We demonstrate the usefulness of our algorithm in learning PCFGs over genomic data.

Search for Minimal and Semi-Minimal Rule Sets in Incremental Learning of Context-Free and Definite Clause Grammars

This paper describes recent improvements to Synapse system for incremental learning of general context-free grammars (CFGs) and definite clause grammars (DCGs) from positive and negative sample strings. An important feature of our approach is incremental learning, which is realized by a rule generation mechanism called “bridging” based on bottom-up parsing for positive samples and the search for rule sets. The sizes of rule sets and the computation time depend on the search strategies. In addition to the global search for synthesizing minimal rule sets and serial search, another method for synthesizing semi-optimum rule sets, we incorporate beam search to the system for synthesizing semi-minimal rule sets. The paper shows several experimental results on learning CFGs and DCGs, and we analyze the sizes of rule sets and the computation time.

Learning context-free grammar using improved tabular representation

This paper describes an improved version of TBL algorithm [Y. Sakakibara, Learning context-free grammars using tabular representations, Pattern Recognition 38(2005) 1372–1383; Y. Sakakibara, M. Kondo, GA-based learning of context-free grammars using tabular representations, in: Proceedings of 16th International Conference in Machine Learning (ICML-99), Morgan-Kaufmann, Los Altos, CA, 1999] for inference of context-free grammars in Chomsky Normal Form. The TBL algorithm is a novel approach to overcome the hardness of learning context-free grammars from examples without structural information available. The algorithm represents the grammars by parsing tables and thanks to this tabular representation the problem of grammar learning is reduced to the problem of partitioning the set of nonterminals. Genetic algorithm is used to solve NP-hard partitioning problem. In the improved version modified fitness function and new delete specialized operator is applied. Computer simulations have been performed to determine improved a tabular representation efficiency. The set of experiments has been divided into 2 groups: in the first one learning the unknown context-free grammar proceeds without any extra information about grammatical structure, in the second one learning is supported by a partial knowledge of the structure. In each of the performed experiments the influence of partition block size in an initial population and the size of population at grammar induction has been tested. The new version of TBL algorithm has been experimentally proved to be not so much vulnerable to block size and population size, and is able to find the solutions faster than standard one.

Learning context-free grammars using tabular representations

We present a novel algorithm using new hypothesis representations for learning context-free grammars from a finite set of positive and negative examples. We propose an efficient hypothesis representation method which consists of a table-like data structure similar to the parse table used in efficient parsing algorithms for context-free grammars such as Cocke–Younger–Kasami algorithm. By employing this representation method, the problem of learning context-free grammars from examples can be reduced to the problem of partitioning the set of nonterminals. We use genetic algorithms for solving this partitioning problem. Further, we incorporate partially structured examples to improve the efficiency of our learning algorithm, where a structured example is represented by a string with some parentheses inserted to indicate the shape of the derivation tree of the unknown grammar. We demonstrate some experimental results using these algorithms and theoretically analyse the completeness of the search space using the tabular method for context-free grammars.

Efficient learning of context-free grammars from positive structural examples

In this paper, we introduce a new normal form for context-free grammars, called reversible context-free grammars , for the problem of learning context-free grammars from positive-only examples. A context-free grammar G = ( N , Σ, P , S ) is said to be reversible if (1) A → α and B → α in P implies A = B and (2) A → αBβ and A → αCβ in P implies B = C . We show that the class of reversible context-free grammars can be identified in the limit from positive samples of structural descriptions and there exists an efficient algorithm to identify them from positive samples of structural descriptions, where a structural description of a context-free grammar is an unlabelled derivation tree of the grammar. This implies that if positive structural examples of a reversible context-free grammar for the target language are available to the learning algorithm, the full class of context-free languages can be learned efficiently from positive samples.

Learning context-free grammars from structural data in polynomial time

We consider the problem of learning a context-free grammar from its structural descriptions. Structural descriptions of a context-free grammar are unlabelled derivation trees of the grammar. We present an efficient algorithm for learning context-free grammars using two types of queries: structural equivalence queries and structural membership queries. The learning protocol is based on what is called “minimally adequate teacher”, and it is shown that a grammar learned by the algorithm is not only a correct grammar, i.e. equivalent to the unknown grammar but also structurally equivalent to it. Furthermore, the algorithm runs in time polynomial in the number of states of the minimum frontier-to-root tree automaton for the set of structural descriptions of the unknown grammar and the maximum size of any counter-example returned by a structural equivalence query.

A version space approach to learning context-free grammars

A version space approach to learning context-free grammars