Jean-Baptiste Greuze's Italian Sojourn 1755-57 HEATHER McPHERSON After his triumph at the Salon of 1755, Jean-Baptiste Greuze set off for Rome in the company of the abbe Gougenot and remained in Italy until April 1757. A trip to Italy was still practically de rigueur for a young artist who wished to succeed, and Greuze did not lack ambi tion. However, most scholars from Mariette to Brookner have dis counted the importance of Greuze's Italian sojourn. In the words of the noted connoisseur Mariette, "Il a fait le voyage d'Italie en 1756, voyage qui lui etait assez inutile, et ou la vanite dut avoir la principale part."1 Brookner's denial of the utility of Greuze's Italian trip is even more categorical. It is generally recognized that the journey to Italy, which took place in 1755-57, did nothing for Greuze's art. It might almost be true to say that it wasted two years which he might otherwise have em ployed in following up the Dutch models which he had set himself and to which he returned in the late 1750s.2 Only Sauerlander, in his 1965 article entitled "Pathosfiguren im Oeuvre des Jean-Baptiste Greuze," recognized an early and lasting Italian in fluence on Greuze's art.3 Edgar Munhall, in his 1976 exhibition cata logue, Jean-Baptiste Greuze 1725-1805, emphasized the importance of the four paintings in Italian costume which Greuze exhibited at the 1757 Salon.4 In this author's view, Greuze's Italian sojourn was more significant 93 94 / MCPHERSON in the development of his unique moralizing genre than has generally been realized. The impact of the Italian trip was both immediate and lasting. Italian influence surfaced in the paintings shown in 1757 and continued to affect Greuze's art during the rest of his career. This paper will focus on the four Italian paintings which figured at the 1757 Salon: La Paresseuse italienne, Un Oiseleur, Les Oeufs casses, and Le Geste napolitain.5 In addition, Greuze exhibited the following works: Le Matelot napolitain, Un Ecolier qui etudie sa legon, two portraits, two heads, and a sketch representing Des Italiens qui jouent a la More.6 The four Italian paintings draw upon different aspects of the Italian heritage from antique statuary to contemporary genre painting. Greuze's early and continuing appreciation of Italian art sheds light upon his subsequent artistic development, his history painting am bitions, and his precocious neoclassical tendencies. In addition, the Italian link contributes to our understanding of the evolution of genre painting in France. The ascendancy of Netherlandish painting has long been recognized, but Italian influence has received little atten tion from scholars. However, it was in Italy that many young French artists came of age and began experimenting with genre subjects. French artists, like Greuze, who travelled to eighteenth-century Rome encountered a sort of "moveable feast" where antiquity coex isted with Renaissance and baroque art and the picturesqueness of Roman street life. The genre tradition was alive and well in Italy, es pecially outside Rome. Eighteenth-century Italian genre artists such as Crespi, Ceruti, and Longhi enjoyed considerable reknown at mid century. Two parallel genre painting currents existed: the costume study and the anecdotal realistic scene or bambochade. Greuze's Italian works drew upon both these currents, but were also indebted to Ren aissance and Baroque history painting and classical antiquity. This is hardly surprising for an ambitious artist like Greuze who aspired to the title of history painter. On the way to Rome, Greuze visited the major Italian cities and copied diverse works ranging from the Dying Gladiator to the paint ings of Michelangelo and Titian. In 1755, he designed a series of cos tume studies for Gougenot's Album de voyage en Italie which were en graved by the Moitte family in 1768. These illustrations fall within the tradition of picturesque costume studies which were in vogue in eighteenth-century France. Relatively little is known about Greuze's Italian sojourn.7 We do know the itinerary Greuze and Gougenot followed but frustratingly little about Greuze's social and artistic contacts, especially in Rome. Greuze and Gougenot passed through Turin, Genoa...
Read full abstract