Intra-night Optical Variability Research Articles

Intra-night optical variability of peculiar narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies with enigmatic jet behaviour

ABSTRACT Variability studies of active galactic nuclei are a powerful diagnostic tool in understanding the physical processes occurring in disc-jet regions, unresolved by direct imaging with currently available techniques. Here, we report the first attempt to systematically characterize intra-night optical variability (INOV) for a sample of seven apparently radio-quiet narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies (RQNLSy1s) that had shown recurring flaring at 37 GHz in the radio observations at Metsähovi Radio Observatory, indicating the presence of relativistic jets in them, but no evidence for relativistic jets in the recent radio observations of Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array at 1.6, 5.2, and 9.0 GHz. We have conducted a total of 28 intra-night sessions, each lasting ≥3 h for this sample, resulting in an INOV duty cycle ($\overline{\mathrm{ DC}} ~\sim$ 20 per cent) similar to that reported for γ-ray-NLSy1s (DC ∼ 25 per cent–30 per cent), that display blazar-like INOV. This in turn infers the presence of relativistic jet in our sample sources. Thus, it appears that even lower mass (MBH ∼ 106 M⊙) RQNLSy1 galaxies can maintain blazar-like activities. However, we note that the magnetic reconnection in the magnetosphere of the black hole can also be a viable mechanism to give rise to the INOV from these sources.

Intra-night optical flux and polarization variability of BL Lacertae during its 2020–2021 high state

ABSTRACT In this work, we report the presence of rapid intra-night optical variations in both flux and polarization of the blazar BL Lacertae during its unprecedented 2020–2021 high state of brightness. The object showed significant flux variability and some colour changes, but no firmly detectable time delays between the optical bands. The linear polarization was also highly variable in both polarization degree and angle (electric vector polarization angle). The object was observed from several observatories throughout the world, covering a total of almost 300 h during 66 nights. Based on our results, we suggest that the changing Doppler factor of an ensemble of independent emitting regions, travelling along a curved jet that at some point happens to be closely aligned with the line of sight, can successfully reproduce our observations during this outburst. This is one of the most extensive variability studies of the optical polarization of a blazar on intra-night time-scales.

Intra-night optical variability monitoring of $$\gamma $$-ray emitting blazars

We present the results obtained from our campaign to characterize the intra-night optical variability properties of blazars detected by the Fermi large area telescope. This involves R-band monitoring observations of a sample of 18 blazars, which includes five flat spectrum radio quasars (FSRQs) and thirteen BL Lac objects (BL Lacs) covering the redshift range $$z = 0.085-1.184$$ . Our observations carried out using the 1.3m J. C. Bhattacharya telescope cover a total of 40 nights ( $$\sim $$ 200 h) between the period December 2016 and March 2020. We characterized variability using the power enhanced F-test. We found duty cycle (DC) variability of about 11% for FSRQs and 12% for BL Lacs. Dividing the sample into different sub-classes based on the position of the synchrotron peak in their broadband spectral energy distribution (SED), we found DC of $$\sim $$ 16%, $$\sim $$ 10% and $$\sim $$ 7% for low synchrotron peaked (LSP), intermediate synchrotron peaked (ISP) and high synchrotron peaked (HSP) blazars. Such high DC of variability in LSP blazars could be understood in the context of the R-band tracing the falling part (contributed by high energy electrons) of the synchrotron component of the broadband SED. Also, the R-band tracing the rising synchrotron part (produced by low energy electrons) in the case of ISP and HSP blazars, could cause lesser variability in them. Thus, the observed high DC of variability in LSP blazars relative to ISP and HSP blazars is in accordance with the leptonic model of emission from blazar jets.

Evidence of jet-induced optical microvariability in radio-loud narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies

ABSTRACT To quantify the role of radio jets for Intra-Night Optical Variability (INOV) in radio-loud narrow-line Seyfert 1 (RLNLSy1) galaxies, we report the first systematic comparative INOV study of 23 RLNLSy1 galaxies, with 15 RLNLSy1s having confirmed detection of jets (jetted) and the remaining 8 RLNLSy1s having no detection of jets (non-jetted) based on their Very Long Baseline Array observations. We have monitored these two samples, respectively, in 37 and 16 sessions of a minimum 3-h duration each. Based upon Fη-test at 99 per cent confidence level with a typical INOV amplitude (ψ) detection threshold of >3 per cent, we find the INOV duty cycles (DC) of 12 per cent for the sample of jetted RLNLSy1s, however, none of the sources showed INOV in the sample of non-jetted RLNLSy1s. Among the jetted RLNLSy1s, we find that the DC for jetted γ-ray detected (γ-ray) RLNLSy1s is found to be 34 per cent in contrast to null INOV detection in the case of non-γ-ray RLNLSy1s. It suggests that instead of the mere presence of a jet, relativistic beaming plays a significant role for INOV in the case of low-luminous high accreting AGNs, such as NLSy1s, in which dilution of the AGN’s non-thermal optical emission by the (much steadier) optical emission contributed by the nuclear accretion disc is quite likely. Our study of jetted γ-ray RLNLSy1s shows more frequent INOV detection for sources with higher apparent jet speed. Further, our results also suggest that among the NLSy1s, only jetted γ-ray RNLSy1 galaxies DC approach blazar-like DC.

Intra-night optical variability study of a non-jetted narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxy: SDSS J163401.94+480940.1

SDSS J163401.94$+$480940.2 is a non-jetted radio-loud narrow-line Seyfert 1 (NLSy1) galaxy. Optical monitoring of this object was carried out in two intra-night sessions each $\geq$ 3 hrs with 3.6m DOT. Intra-night optical variability (INOV) characterization is presented for the first time for this source. We have detected an unexpected remarkable flare in one of two monitoring sessions of SDSS J163401.94$+$480940.2, whose rapid brightening phase implied a minute like doubling time of $\sim$ 22 minutes, thereby approaching to the extremely fast minute like variability, observed from FSRQ PKS 1222$+$21 at 400 GeV. The detection of a minute-like variability suggests the existence of relativistic jets with a small viewing angle. We briefly discuss the possible mechanisms for the non-detection of relativistic jets in its Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA) observations.

OUP accepted manuscript

Our recently reported lack of Intra-Night Optical Variability (INOV) among Broad-Absorption-Line (BAL) quasars exhibiting some blazar-like radio properties, either questions polar ejection of BAL clouds, and/or hints at a physical state of the relativistic jet modified due to interaction with the thermal BAL wind on the innermost sub-parsec scale. As a robust check on this unexpected finding for the BAL_blazar candidates, we report here the INOV study of a new and much more rigorously defined comparison sample consisting of 9 normal (non-BAL) blazars, matched in both magnitude and redshift to the aforementioned sample of BAL_blazar candidates. The present campaign spanning 27 sessions yields an INOV duty cycle of ~23% for the comparison sample of normal blazars, employing the enhanced F-test. However, even this more sensitive test does not detect INOV for the sample of BAL_blazar candidates. This stark INOV contrast found here between the BAL_blazar candidates and normal blazars can probably be traced to a physical interaction of the relativistic jet with the thermal wind, within sub-parsec range from the nucleus. The consequent enfeebling of the jet would additionally explain the striking deficiency among BAL quasars of powerful FR II radio lobes on the much larger scale of 10-100 kpc.

Intra-night optical variability of γ −ray detected narrow-line Seyfert1 galaxies

Abstract We report the first attempt to systematically characterise intra-night optical variability (INOV) of the rare and enigmatic subset of Narrow-Line Seyfert1 galaxies (NLSy1s), which is marked by detection in the γ-ray band and is therefore endowed with Doppler boosted relativistic jets, like blazars. However, the central engines in these two types of AGN are thought to operate in different regimes of accretion rate. Our INOV search in a fairly large and unbiased sample of 15 γ-ray NLSy1s was conducted in 36 monitoring sessions, each lasting ≥ 3 hrs. In our analysis, special care has been taken to address the possible effect on the differential light curves, of any variation in the seeing disc during the session, since that might lead to spurious claims of INOV from such AGN due to the possibility of a significant contribution from the host galaxy to the total optical emission. From our observations, a duty cycle (DC) of INOV detection in the γ-ray NLSy1s is estimated to be around 25% - 30%, which is comparable to that known for blazars. This estimate of DC will probably need an upward revision, once it becomes possible to correct for the dilution of the AGN’s nonthermal optical emission by the (much steadier) optical emission contributed not only by the host galaxy but also the nuclear accretion disc in these high Eddington rate accretors. Finally, we also draw attention to the possibility that sharp optical flux changes on sub-hour time scale are less rare for γ-ray NLSy1s, in comparison to blazars.

Comparative intranight optical variability of X-ray and γ-ray-detected narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies

ABSTRACT In a systematic program to characterize the intranight optical variability (INOV) of different classes of narrow-line Seyfert 1 (NLSy1s) galaxies, we report here the first comparative INOV study of NLSy1 sets detected in the X-ray and γ-ray bands. Our sample consists of 18 sources detected in X-rays but not in γ-rays (hereafter x_NLSy1s) and seven sources detected in γ-rays (hereafter g_NLSy1s), out of which five are detected also in X-rays. We have monitored these two sets of NLSy1s, respectively, in 24 and 21 sessions of a minimum of 3-h duration each. The INOV duty cycles for these two sets are found to be 12 per cent and 53 per cent, respectively (at a 99 per cent confidence level). In the set of 18 x_NLSy1s, INOV duty cycle is found to be zero for the 13 radio-quiet members (monitored in 14 sessions) and 43 per cent for the five radio-loud members (10 sessions). The latter is very similar to the aforementioned duty cycle of 53 per cent found here for the set of g_NLSy1s (all of which are radio-loud). Thus, it appears that the radio-loudness level is the prime factor behind the INOV detection and the pattern of the high-energy radiation plays only a minor role.

Are there broad absorption-line blazars?

Abstract We report the first systematic search for blazars among broad-absorption-line (BAL) quasars. This is based on our intranight optical monitoring of a well-defined sample of 10 candidates selected on the criteria of a flat spectrum and an abnormally high linear polarization at radio wavelengths. A small population of BAL blazars can be expected in the ‘polar model’ of BAL quasars. However, no such case is found, since none of our 30 monitoring sessions devoted to the 10 candidates yielded a positive detection of intra-night optical variability (INOV), which is uncharacteristic of blazars. This lack of INOV detection contrasts with the high duty cycle of INOV observed for a comparison sample of 15 ‘normal’ (i.e., non-BAL) blazars. Some possible implications of this are pointed out.

Intra-night optical variability of misaligned active galaxies

The majority of the γ-ray sources detected by the Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope belong to the blazar class of active galactic nuclei (AGNs). In addition to blazars, a minority of non-blazar AGNs is also found to be γ-ray emitters. A class of AGNs with large jet to line-of-sight angle are termed as misaligned AGNs (MAGNs). A significant fraction of γ-ray emitting non-blazar AGNs belong to this class. The detection of these sources in γ-rays suggests that most of their emission originate in the jet. Considering jet origin of intra-night optical variability (INOV), one thus can expect to observe strong presence of INOV in these γ-ray detected MAGN. However, no observations exist on their INOV nature. We therefore, have carried out a first search for INOV on a sample of six MAGN, that comprises three FR I, two Steep Spectrum Radio Quasars (SSRQs)/Compact Steep Spectrum (CSS) and one FR II galaxy. Our observations carried out on a total of eight nights for a duration of ∼29 h, reveal that MAGNs show large amplitude (between 2 and 10 per cent) INOV with a duty cycle of about 50 per cent, including both variable and probably variable sources, which is similar to that shown by blazars. Though INOV has been detected in MAGNs, differences if any between the INOV characteristics of FR I, SSRQs/CSS, and FR II types of MAGNs could not be unambiguously established owing to limited observations. Nevertheless, the first detection of INOV in MAGNs points to their jet based origin.

Intra-night optical monitoring of three γ-ray detected narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies

For 3 radio-loud $\gamma$-ray detected Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 ($\gamma$-ray NLSy1) galaxies, we report optical variability on intra-night and/or week-like time scales, based on five $\geq$ 3 hours long monitoring sessions for each galaxy. The radio-loudness factors (R$_{1.4 GHz}$) for these galaxies, namely 1H 0323$+$342 (z = 0.0629), PKS J1222$+$0413 (z = 0.966) and PKS J1505$+$0326 (z = 0.408) are $\sim$318, $\sim$1534 and $\sim$3364 at 1.4 GHz, respectively. For the most distant $\gamma$-ray NLSy1, PKS J1222$+$0413, Intra-Night Optical Variability (INOV) characterisation is presented for the first time. The blazar-like behaviour of the nearest $\gamma$-ray NLSy1 1H 0323$+$342, which showed strong INOV on 4 of the 5 nights, was unexpected in view of its recent reclassification as `radio intermediate' (R$_{5 GHz}$ $\lesssim$ 25). Its particularly violent INOV is manifested by two optical outbursts lasting $\sim$ 1 hour, whose rapid brightening phase is shown to imply a doubling time of $\sim$ 1 hour for the optical synchrotron flux, after (conservatively) deducting the thermal optical emission contributed by the host galaxy and the Seyfert nucleus. A more realistic `decontamination' could well reduce substantially the flux doubling time, bringing it still closer in rapidity to the ultra-fast VHE ($>$ 100 GeV) flares reported for the blazars PKS 1222$+$216 and PKS 2155$-$304. A large contamination by thermal optical emission may, in fact, be common for NLSy1s as they are high Eddington rate accretors. The present study further suggests that superluminal motion in the radio jet could be a robust diagnostic of INOV.

Intra-night optical variability properties of X-ray bright Narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies

We present Intra Night Optical Variability (INOV) study of the 9 Narrow-line Seyfert 1 (NLSy 1) galaxies which are detected in X-ray at more than 3σ level. Our observations cover a total of 9 nights (~ 36 hr) with each NLSy 1 monitored for ≥ 3.5 hr in each night. After applying F-test to assess variability status of these sources, we found none of these sources to be variable. Such non-variability nature of X-ray detected NLSy 1 galaxies suggests the lack of jet dominance as far as X-ray emission is concerned. Higher photometric accuracy for these faint sources, achievable with the newly installed ARIES 3.6m DOT will be helpful.

Intra-night Optical Variability Monitoring of Fermi Blazars: First Results from 1.3 m J. C. Bhattacharya Telescope

Abstract We report the first results obtained from our campaign to characterize the intra-night-optical variability (INOV) properties of Fermi detected blazars, using the observations from the recently commissioned 1.3 m J. C. Bhattacharya telescope (JCBT). During the first run, we were able to observe 17 blazars in the Bessel R filter for ∼137 hr. Using C- and scaled F-statistics, we quantify the extent of INOV and derive the duty cycle (DC), which is the fraction of time during which a source exhibits a substantial flux variability. We find a high DC of 40% for BL Lac objects and the flat spectrum radio quasars are relatively less variable (DC ∼ 15%). However, when estimated for blazars sub-classes, a high DC of ∼59% is found in low synchrotron peaked (LSP) blazars, whereas, intermediate and high synchrotron peaked objects have a low DC of ∼11% and 13%, respectively. We find evidence of the association of the high amplitude INOV with the γ-ray flaring state. We also notice a high polarization during the elevated INOV states (for the sources that have polarimetric data available), thus supporting the jet based origin of the observed variability. We plan to enlarge the sample and utilize the time availability from the small telescopes, such as 1.3 m JCBT, to strengthen/verify the results obtained in this work and those existing in the literature.

Flux and Polarization Variability of OJ 287 during the Early 2016 Outburst

Abstract The gamma-ray blazar OJ 287 was in a high activity state during 2015 December–2016 February. Coinciding with this high brightness state, we observed this source for photometry on 40 nights in R-band and for polarimetry on nine epochs in UBV RI bands. During the period of our observations, the source brightness varied from 13.20 ± 0.04 mag to 14.98 ± 0.04 mag and the degree of polarization (P) fluctuated between 6.0% ± 0.3% and 28.3% ± 0.8% in R-band. Focusing on intranight optical variability (INOV), we find a duty cycle of about 71% using χ 2-statistics, similar to that known for blazars. From INOV data, the shortest variability timescale is estimated to be 142 ± 38 minutes, yielding a lower limit of the observed Doppler factor δ 0 = 1.17, the magnetic field strength B ≤ 3.8 G, and the size of the emitting region R s < 2.28 × 1014 cm. On internight timescales, a significant anticorrelation between R-band flux and P is found. The observed P at U-band is generally larger than that observed at longer-wavelength bands, suggesting a wavelength-dependent polarization. Using V-band photometric and polarimetric data from Steward Observatory obtained during our monitoring period, we find a varied correlation between P and V-band brightness. While an anticorrelation is sometimes seen between P and V-band magnitude, no correlation is seen at other times, thereby suggesting the presence of more than one short-lived shock component in the jet of OJ 287.

Intra-night optical variability characteristics of different classes of narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies

In a first systematic effort to characterize the intra-night optical variability (INOV) of different classes of narrow line Seyfert 1 (NLSy1) galaxies, we have carried out observations on a sample of radio-loud (RL) and radio-quiet (RQ) NLSy1 galaxies. The RL-NLSy1 galaxies are further divided into {\gamma}-ray loud (GL) and {\gamma}-ray quiet (GQ) NLSy1 galaxies. Our sample consists of four sets, each set consisting of a RQ-NLSy1, a GQ-NLSy1 and a GL-NLSy1 galaxy, closely matched in redshift and optical luminosity. Our observations on both RQ and GQ-NLSy1 galaxies consist of a total of 19 nights, whereas the data for GL-NLSy1 galaxies (18 nights) were taken from literature published earlier by us. This enabled us to do a comparison of the duty cycle (DC) of different classes of NLSy1 galaxies. Using power-enhanced F-test, with a variability threshold of 1%, we find DCs of about 55%, 39% and 0% for GL, GQ and RQ-NLSy1 galaxies respectively. The high DC and large amplitude of INOV (24.0 +/- 13.7%) shown by GL-NLSy1 galaxies relative to the other two classes might be due to their inner aligned relativistic jets having large bulk Lorentz factors. The null DC of RQ-NLSy1 galaxies could mean the presence of low power and/or largely misaligned jets in them. However, dividing RL-NLSy1 galaxies into low and high optical polarization sources, we find that sources with large polarization show somewhat higher DCs (69%) and amplitudes (29%) compared to those with low polarization. This points to a possible link between INOV and optical polarization.

Intranight optical variability of radio-quiet weak emission line quasars – IV

We report an extension of our program to search for radio-quiet BL Lac candidates using intra-night optical variability (INOV) as a probe. The present INOV observations cover a well-defined representative set of 10 `radio-quiet weak-emission-line quasars' (RQWLQs), selected from a newly published sample of 46 such sources, derived from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (Data release 7). Intra-night CCD monitoring of the 10 RQWLQs was carried out in 18 sessions lasting at least 3.5 hours. For each session, differential light curves (DLCs) of the target RQWLQ were derived relative to two steady comparison stars monitored simultaneously. Combining these new data with those already published by us for 15 RQWLQs monitored in 30 sessions, we estimate an INOV duty cycle of $\sim 3\%$ for the RQWLQs, which appears inconsistent with BL Lacs. However, the observed INOV events (which occurred in just two of the sessions) are strong (with a fractional variability amplitude $\psi >$ 10\%), hence blazar-like. We briefly point out the prospects of an appreciable rise in the estimated INOV duty cycle for RQWLQs with a relatively modest increase in sensitivity for monitoring these rather faint objects.

BROADBAND OBSERVATIONS OF THE GAMMA-RAY EMITTING NARROW LINE SEYFERT 1 GALAXY SBS 0846+513

ABSTRACT We present the results of our broadband study of the γ-ray emitting narrow line Seyfert 1 (NLSy1) galaxy SBS 0846+513 (z = 0.585). This includes multiband flux variations, γ-ray spectral analysis, broadband spectral energy distribution (SED) modeling, and intranight optical variability (INOV) observations carried out over six nights between 2012 November and 2013 March using the 2 m Himalayan Chandra Telescope and the 1.3 m telescope at Devasthal, India. Multiple episodes of flaring activity are seen in the γ-ray light curve of the source which are also reflected in the observations at lower frequencies. A statistically significant curvature is noticed in the seven years averaged γ-ray spectrum, thus indicating its similarity with powerful flat spectrum radio quasars (FSRQs). Modeling the SEDs with a one-zone leptonic emission model hints that the optical UV spectrum is dominated by synchrotron radiation, whereas inverse Compton scattering of broad line region photons reproduces the γ-ray part of the SEDs. The source was found to be variable on all the six nights of optical observations with a variation of ∼0.3 mag within a single night, coinciding with a high γ-ray activity state. The observed large amplitude INOV clearly indicates the presence of a closely aligned beamed relativistic jet in SBS 0846+513. Our broadband study supports the recent claims in literature that γ-ray emitting NLSy1 galaxies are similar to blazars and constitute the low black hole mass counterparts to FSRQs.

Optical monitoring observations of two γ-ray narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies

1H 0323+342 is a rather radio-loud narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxy (NLS1) with γ-ray emission. Optical observations were carried out in B and R bands which covered 6 nights in 2011 to obtain light curves of 1H 0323+342. The difference image subtraction method was used to deal with the data of 1H 0323+342 because of the existence of extended host galaxy. Optical variability on day timescale was reported here. We also monitored the first γ-ray NLS1 SDSS J094857.3+002225 and confirmed the existence of intranight optical variability (INOV). These indicated the existence of a relativistic jet in these NLS1s.

Violent intranight optical variability of the blazar S4 0954+65 during its unprecedented 2015 February outburst

Abstract In this letter, we present results from intranight monitoring in three colours (BRI) of the blazar S4 0954+65 during its recent (2015 February) unprecedented high state. We find violent variations on very short time-scales, reaching magnitude change levels of 0.1–0.2 mag h−1. On some occasions, changes of ∼0.1 mag are observed even within ∼10 min. During the night of 2015 February 14, an exponential drop of ∼0.7 mag is detected for about 5 h. Cross-correlation between the light curves does not reveal any detectable wavelength-dependent time delays, larger than ∼5 min. Colour changes ‘bluer-when-brighter’ are observed on longer time-scales. Possible variability mechanisms to explain the observations are discussed and a preference to the geometrical one is given.

Intranight optical variability of radio-quiet weak emission line quasars – III

This is continuation of our programme to search for the elusive radio-quiet BL Lacs, by carrying out a systematic search for intranight optical variability (INOV) in a subset of `weak-line quasars' which are already designated as `high-confidence BL Lac candidate' and are also known to be radio-quiet. For 6 such radio-quiet weak-line quasars (RQWLQs), we present here new INOV observations taken in 11 sessions of duration >3 hours each. Combining these data with our previously published INOV monitoring of RQWLQs in 19 sessions yields INOV observations for a set of 15 RQWLQs monitored in 30 sessions, each lasting more than 3 hours. The 30 differential light curves, thus obtained for the 15 RQWLQs, were subjected to a statistical analysis using the F-test, and the deduced INOV characteristics of the RQWLQs then compared with those published recently for several prominent AGN classes, also applying the F-test. From our existing INOV observations, there is a hint that RQWLQs in our sample show a significantly higher INOV duty cycle than radio-quiet quasars and radio lobe-dominated quasars. Two sessions when we have detected strong (blazar-like) INOV for RQWLQs are pointed out, and these two RQWLQs are therefore the best known candidates for radio-quiet BL Lacs, deserving to be pursued. For a proper comparison with the INOV properties already established for (brighter) members of several prominent classes of AGN, a factor of 2-3 improvement in the INOV detection threshold for the RQWLQs is needed and it would be very interesting to check if that would yield a significantly higher estimate for INOV duty cycle than is found here.