Sir: Rhinoplasty in Asians requires augmentation, lengthening, and increased tip projection.1 Grafts commonly used in the tip such as extended spreader grafts, caudal septal extension grafts, and columellar struts require long, straight, flat segments of cartilage. With smaller, potentially weaker quadrangular cartilages,1 harvesting sufficient cartilage for tip work is particularly difficult in Asians. The authors present a new graft design for tip surgery that offers excellent stability and minimizes cartilage use. Open rhinoplasty is performed, the lower lateral cartilages are fully mobilized and separated in the midline, and septal harvest is performed, leaving a generous 1.5-cm caudal and dorsal strut. The upper lateral cartilage is separated from the dorsal septum unilaterally. An extended spreader graft is sutured between the septum and lower lateral cartilage using 5-0 polydioxanone. The extended spreader graft can be positioned diagonally to project above the dorsum of the nose for greater tip projection. A modified caudal septal extension graft is sutured onto the contralateral caudal inferior septum, projecting superoanteriorly to meet the extended spreader graft in the midline. The two grafts are sutured together (Figs. 1 and 2). The membranous septum is opposed to the construct.Fig. 1.: Schematic illustration of the procedure.Fig. 2.: Intraoperative photograph.The new construct is tested for stability. The lower lateral cartilages are pinned temporarily to the X-graft using a 26-gauge needle after determining appropriate tip projection, rotation, and dorsal lengthening. The lower lateral cartilages are then sutured to the X-graft. Interdomal sutures can be applied to narrow a bulbous tip. The caudal septal extension graft is sutured to the inferiormost portion of the caudal septum, and the angle between the grafts should be as close to 90 degrees as possible to maximize stability. Conchal cartilages can be used with their concave surfaces facing each other so that opposing warping forces allow the X-graft to lie in the midline. There are many advantages of the X-graft, including the following: economy and flexibility in the use of cartilage grafts; only two shorter, separate pieces of cartilage are required; conventional caudal septal extension grafts requires a larger contiguous piece of cartilage; and the combination of extended spreader graft and an extended columella strut requires longer cartilage. Curved conchal cartilage can be used. The bilateral graft design allows curved cartilage to be used to achieve a final straight construct. The X-graft provides a strong construct for tip surgery. The extended spreader graft and caudal septal extension graft of the X-graft emulate a pillar-and-beam construct. The caudal septal extension graft is anchored firmly to the caudal septum, lowering the chance of postoperative shortening. Deviations of the caudal septum must be addressed before the X-graft can be used. The caudal septal extension graft can be extended to the nasal floor/maxillary crest, and a columella strut can reinforce the X-graft if the caudal septum is weak. Severely deviated caudal septa will not be suitable candidates for the X-graft. The X-graft is an excellent choice for the Asian rhinoplasty patient in whom cartilage is scarce. It gives a strong construct for tip surgery and with economical use of cartilage. To date, the authors have used the X-graft for both primary and revision rhinoplasties, with excellent clinical results in over 115 patients. Dong Hak Jung, M.D., Ph.D. Ian Loh, M.B.B.S., M.Med. Shimmian Rhinoplasty Clinic Seoul, South Korea DISCLOSURE The authors have no financial interest to declare in relation to the content of this article. No outside funding was received.
Read full abstract