This paper investigates non-closure properties of the classes of sets accepted by space-bounded two-dimensional alternating Turing machines and three-way two-dimensional alternating Turing machines. Let 2-ATM( L( m, n)) (resp., TR2-ATM( L( m, n))) be the class of sets accepted by L( m, n) space-bounded two-dimensional alternating Turing machines (resp., L( m, n) space-bounded three-way two-dimensional alternating Turing machines), where L( m, n): N 2→ N∪{0} ( N denotes the set of all the positive integers) is a function with two variables m (=the number of rows of input tapes) and n (=the number of columns of input tapes). We show that (i) for any function g( n)=o(log n) (resp., g(n)= o( logn/ log logn) ) and any monotonic non-decreasing function f( m) which can be constructed by some one-dimensional deterministic Turing machine, 2-ATM( L( m, n)) and TR2-ATM( L( m, n)) are not closed under column catenation, column +, and projection, and (ii) for any function f( m)=o(log m) (resp., f(m)=o( logm/ log logm) ) and any monotonic non-decreasing function g( n) which can be constructed by some one-dimensional deterministic Turing machine, 2-ATM( L( m, n)) and TR2-ATM( L( m, n)) are not closed under row catenation, row +, and projection, where L( m, n)= f( m)+ g( n) (resp., L( m, n)= f( m)× g( n)).
Read full abstract