Idiosyncratic Drug-induced Liver Injury In Humans Research Articles

Liver Injury Caused by Green Tea Extract in PD-1-/- Mice: An Impaired Immune Tolerance Model for Idiosyncratic Drug-Induced Liver Injury.

Idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) is an idiosyncratic drug reaction that is specific to an individual and can lead to liver failure and even death. The mechanism of IDILI remains poorly understood, but most IDILI appears to be immune-mediated. We have developed the first validated animal model by using a PD-1-/- mouse model in combination with anti-CTLA-4 to block immune checkpoints and impair immune tolerance. Treatment of these mice with drugs that cause IDILI in humans led to delayed-onset liver injury with characteristics similar to IDILI in humans. The current study investigates the effects of green tea extract, a weight-loss dietary supplement that has been reported to cause IDILI in humans. Green tea extracts contain a highly variable content of catechins including (-)-epigallocatechin gallate, the major catechin in green tea formulations. If the liver injury caused by green tea extract in humans is immune-mediated, it may occur in our impaired immune tolerance model. Female PD-1-/- mice treated with anti-CTLA-4 antibody and green tea extract (500 mg/kg), a dose that is considered a no-observed-adverse-effect level for liver in rodents, produced a delayed onset increase in serum alanine transaminase levels and an increase in hepatic CD8+ T cells. In contrast, the response in male PD-1-/- mice was less pronounced, and there was no evidence of liver injury in wild-type mice. These findings are consistent with the hypothesis that the IDILI caused by green tea extract is immune-mediated and is similar to IDILI caused by medications that are associated with IDILI.

Models of Idiosyncratic Drug-Induced Liver Injury.

Drug-induced liver injury (DILI) is a leading cause of attrition during the early and late stages of drug development and after a drug is marketed. DILI is generally classified as either intrinsic or idiosyncratic. Intrinsic DILI is dose dependent and predictable (e.g., acetaminophen toxicity). However, predicting the occurrence of idiosyncratic DILI, which has a very low incidence and is associated with severe liver damage, is difficult because of its complex nature and the poor understanding of its mechanism. Considering drug metabolism and pharmacokinetics, we established experimental animal models of DILI for 14 clinical drugs that cause idiosyncratic DILI in humans, which is characterized by the formation of reactive metabolites and the involvement of both innate and adaptive immunity. On the basis of the biomarker data obtained from the animal models, we developed a cell-based assay system that predicts the potential risks of drugs for inducing DILI. These findings increase our understanding of the mechanisms of DILI and may help predict and prevent idiosyncratic DILI due to certain drugs.

Mechanisms of idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury.

Idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) is a significant problem. Little is known with certainty about the mechanisms of IDILI. However, there is growing evidence that most IDILI is immune mediated and caused by reactive metabolites. The two major and complementary hypotheses that link reactive metabolite formation with the induction of an immune response that can lead to IDILI are the hapten and danger hypotheses. Specifically, a reactive metabolite can bind to proteins and make them foreign; however, without activation of antigen presenting cells (APCs), the immune response will be immune tolerance. Not all reactive metabolites are associated with the same risk of causing IDILI. If the reactive metabolite can also cause some cell damage, this can lead to the release of danger-associated molecular pattern molecules (DAMPs) that activate APCs. Other hypotheses for the mechanism of IDILI include mitochondrial injury, inhibition of the bile salt export pump, and endoplasmic reticulum stress. These mechanisms may be complementary to the danger hypothesis in that they may cause the release of DAMPs. None of these hypotheses has been adequately tested. Previous animal models have had characteristics very different from IDILI in humans and are unlikely to involve the same mechanism. However, impairment of immune tolerance has led to a model with characteristics very similar to IDILI in humans. This will make it possible to rigorously test hypotheses. A better mechanistic understanding of IDILI should lead to better methods to screen drug candidates for IDILI risk and treat IDILI when it occurs.

Involvement of CCL2/CCR2 macrophage recruitment in amodiaquine-induced liver injury

Evidence suggests that macrophages may play a role in the development of idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI). However, there has yet to be a clear link between macrophage activation and the inflammatory infiltrate that is characteristic of IDILI. A major chemokine involved in the recruitment of macrophages into the liver is C-C motif chemokine ligand 2 (CCL2)/monocyte chemoattractant protein 1 (MCP1). Therefore, we tested the effect of this chemokine in an animal model of IDILI. Specifically, amodiaquine (AQ), which is known to cause IDILI in humans, causes mild liver injury in wild-type C57BL/6 mice that resolves despite continued AQ treatment, but it causes more severe liver injury that does not resolve in PD-1−/− mice co-treated with anti-CTLA-4 to impair immune tolerance. CCR2−/− mice treated with AQ were not protected from the expected AQ-induced liver injury seen in wild-type C57BL/6 mice. In contrast, anti-CCL2 antibodies attenuated the liver injury caused by AQ in the impaired immune tolerance model. The difference in response of the two models is likely due to a difference in the IDILI mechanism; the mild injury in wild-type animals is mediated by NK cells, while the more serious injury in the impaired immune tolerance model requires CD8 T-cells. The results from these experiments provide evidence that macrophage infiltration into the liver may not be involved in mild IDILI mediated by the innate immune system, but it does appear necessary in more severe IDILI involving cytotoxic T-cells.

Use of an animal model to test whether non-alcoholic fatty liver disease increases the risk of idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury

Clinical evidence suggests that most idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) is immune-mediated. The danger hypothesis suggests that liver injury and inflammation would increase the risk of an immune response leading to IDILI. Therefore, a reasonable hypothesis would be that an underlying chronic liver disease such as non-alcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH) would increase the risk of developing IDILI due to inflammation and release of danger signals from damaged cells. In order to test this hypothesis, mice were fed a methionine-/choline-deficient (MCD) diet that produces a consistent NASH phenotype, along with amodiaquine (AQ) – a drug known to cause IDILI in humans. This study employed both wild-type C57BL/6 mice and PD-1−/− mice co-treated with anti-CTLA-4 antibodies. The PD-1−/− + anti-CTLA-4 model produces an immune-mediated liver injury very similar to the idiosyncratic liver injury observed in humans. The liver injury observed in the present experiment was dominated by the injury caused by the MCD diet; there was no significant difference between mice treated with the MCD diet alone and those also treated with AQ, whether in wild-type mice of the PD-1−/− model. Therefore, the MCD diet, which results in a state that mimics NASH, did not appear to increase the liver injury associated with AQ treatment. Ultimately, an animal model is just that – only a model, and cannot provide a definitive answer to clinical questions. However, given the difficulty of performing clinical studies with appropriate control populations, the present results provide important evidence to support a general clinical finding that underlying liver injury does not usually increase the risk of IDILI.

Synergistic Cytotoxicity from Drugs and Cytokines In Vitro as an Approach to Classify Drugs According to Their Potential to Cause Idiosyncratic Hepatotoxicity: A Proof-of-Concept Study.

Idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) typically occurs in a small fraction of patients and has resulted in removal of otherwise efficacious drugs from the market. Current preclinical testing methods are ineffective in predicting which drug candidates have IDILI liability. Recent results suggest that immune mediators such as tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF) and interferon-γ (IFN) interact with drugs that cause IDILI to kill hepatocytes. This proof-of-concept study was designed to test the hypothesis that drugs can be classified according to their ability to cause IDILI in humans using classification modeling with covariates derived from concentration-response relationships that describe cytotoxic interaction with cytokines. Human hepatoma (HepG2) cells were treated with drugs associated with IDILI or with drugs lacking IDILI liability and cotreated with TNF and/or IFN. Detailed concentration-response relationships were determined for calculation of parameters such as the maximal cytotoxic effect, slope, and EC50 for use as covariates for classification modeling using logistic regression. These parameters were incorporated into multiple classification models to identify combinations of covariates that most accurately classified the drugs according to their association with human IDILI. Of 14 drugs associated with IDILI, almost all synergized with TNF to kill HepG2 cells and were successfully classified by statistical modeling. IFN enhanced the toxicity mediated by some IDILI-associated drugs in the presence of TNF. In contrast, of 10 drugs with little or no IDILI liability, none synergized with inflammatory cytokines to kill HepG2 cells and were classified accordingly. The resulting optimal model classified the drugs with extraordinary selectivity and specificity.

The Combination of Anti-CTLA-4 and PD1-/- Mice Unmasks the Potential of Isoniazid and Nevirapine To Cause Liver Injury.

Our laboratory recently reported what we believe is the first valid animal model of idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) by treating PD1-/- mice with an anti-CTLA-4 antibody and amodiaquine (AQ). PD1 and CTLA-4 are important immune checkpoint receptors that are involved in inducing immune tolerance. This model was able to produce significant liver injury that looks very similar to the liver injury seen in humans. Although this model was shown to work with AQ, the question becomes whether blocking immune tolerance would unmask the potential of other drugs to cause IDILI. In this study, we tested isoniazid and nevirapine, both drugs with significant histories of causing IDILI in humans even though they do not cause significant injury in animals with doses that result in therapeutic blood levels. Both drugs in combination with these immune checkpoint inhibitors caused mild but significant delayed onset liver injury, which is similar to the mild injury that they can cause in humans. INH-induced liver injury in this model was associated with an increase in NK cells, while NVP-induced liver injury was associated with a greater increase in CD8 T cells. Although the liver injury caused by these drugs in this model was mild, these results suggest that impairing immune tolerance may be a general method for unmasking the potential of drugs to cause IDILI and therefore provide a screening tool for drug development.

The Role of CD8 T Cells in Amodiaquine-Induced Liver Injury in PD1-/- Mice Cotreated with Anti-CTLA-4.

The mechanism of idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) remains poorly understood, in part due to the lack of a valid animal model. Clinical evidence suggests that most IDILI is immune mediated, and the major factor preventing liver injury in most patients is immune tolerance. Many attempts have been made in the past to develop an animal model of IDILI, but none had characteristics similar to those of IDILI in humans, and presumably they involved a different mechanism. Recently our laboratory reported a model of amodiaquine (AQ)-induced IDILI using PD1-/- mice and an anti-CTLA4 antibody. This may be the first valid animal model of IDILI because it mimics the characteristics of IDILI in humans. The current study extended the duration of AQ treatment to see if this model would lead to liver failure and to further characterize the associated immune response. Although AQ treatment was extended to 10 weeks and total bilirubin levels were significantly elevated compared to control, there was no further increase from weeks 7 to 10, and the animals did not develop overt liver failure. Mice treated with AQ and anti-CTLA4 had a significant increase in percentage of hepatic CD4, CD8, Th17, and Treg cells after 10 weeks of AQ treatment, as well as significantly decreased NK cells. CD8 T cells have been implicated in several serious idiosyncratic drug reactions, and we used an anti-CD8 antibody to deplete CD8 T cells to study their involvement in this liver injury. We found that depletion of CD8 T cells protected mice from AQ-induced liver injury in this model, which strongly suggests that they are responsible for the liver damage. This is consistent with the finding of CD8 T cells in liver biopsies of human IDILI and may lead the way to an effective treatment for serious IDILI.

Drugs associated with idiosyncratic hepatotoxicity synergize with cytokines to kill hepatocytes in vitro

Idiosyncratic drug‐induced liver injury (IDILI) occurs in a small fraction of patients and often results in removal of otherwise efficacious drugs from the market. The mechanisms of IDILI are unknown; however, in studies using animal models the inflammatory mediators tumor necrosis factor‐alpha (TNFα) and interferon‐gamma (IFNγ) are essential to the pathogenesis of liver injury. The purpose of this study was to test the hypothesis that a drug's ability to synergize with inflammatory cytokines to kill hepatocytes in vitro can classify dugs according to their potential to cause idiosyncratic hepatotoxicity in humans. Human hepatoma (HepG2) cells were treated with drugs associated with IDILI or with drugs lacking IDILI liability and cotreated with TNFα and/or IFNγ.Of 13 drugs associated with IDILI, 12 synergized with TNFα to kill HepG2 cells.IFNγ enhanced the toxicity mediated by 8 IDILI‐positive drugs in the presence of TNFα. Of 10 drugs with little/no IDILI potential, none synergized with inflammatory cytokines to kill HepG2 cells. These findings indicate that drugs associated with IDILI in humans synergize with TNFα and IFNγ in vitro to cause cell death and raise the possibility that drug‐cytokine synergy underlies hepatocellular killing in some IDILI reactions. These results suggest an in vitro approach that could be used during preclinical safety evaluation to identify drug candidates with the potential to cause IDILI.

Establishment of animal models of drug-induced liver injury and analysis of possible mechanisms

Drug-induced liver injury (DILI) is one of leading causes of attrition during both early and late stages of drug development and postmarketing. DILI is generally classified into the intrinsic and idiosyncratic types. Intrinsic DILI is dose dependent and predictable as exemplified by acetaminophen toxicity. However, the occurrence of idiosyncratic DILI with very low incidence and severe liver damage is difficult to predict because of the complex nature of DILI and poor understanding of its mechanism. In this review, we summarize current knowledge and our accumulated experimental findings on the pathogenic mechanisms of DILI focusing on the reactive metabolites of drugs formed by drug-metabolizing enzymes and immune- and inflammation-related responses. Considering drug metabolism and pharmacokinetics, we have established nonclinical animal models of DILI for 10 types of clinical drug known to cause idiosyncratic DILI in humans. Using animal models, it has been shown that the formation of reactive metabolites and both innate and adaptive immunity are involved in the pathogenesis of drug hepatotoxicity. Based on information on biomarkers obtained from animal models, we developed a cell-based system that predicts the potential DILI risks of drugs. The results of these studies increased our understanding of the mechanisms of DILI and help to predict and prevent idiosyncratic DILI caused by drug candidates.

Development of a novel mouse model of amodiaquine-induced liver injury with a delayed onset

Amodiaquine (AQ) treatment is associated with a high incidence of idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) and agranulocytosis. Evidence suggests that AQ-induced IDILI is immune mediated. A significant impediment to mechanistic studies of IDILI is the lack of valid animal models. This study reports the first animal model of IDILI with characteristics similar to mild IDILI in humans. Treatment of female C57BL/6 mice with AQ led to liver injury with delayed onset, which resolved despite continued treatment. Covalent binding of AQ was detected in the liver, which was greater in female than in male mice, and higher in the liver than in other organs. Covalent binding in the liver was maximal by Day 3, which did not explain the delayed onset of alanine aminotransferase (ALT) elevation. However, coincident with the elevated serum ALT, infiltration of liver and splenic mononuclear cells and activation of CD8 T-cells within the liver were identified. By Week 7, when ALT levels had returned close to normal, down-regulation of several inflammatory cytokines and up-regulation of PD-1 on T-cells suggested induction of immune tolerance. Treatment of Rag1−/− mice with AQ resulted in higher ALT activities than C57BL/6 mice, which suggested that the adaptive immune response was responsible for immune tolerance. In contrast, depletion of NK cells significantly attenuated the increase in ALT, which implied a role for NK cells in mild AQ-induced IDILI. This is the first example of a delayed-onset animal model of IDILI that appears to be immune-mediated.

Trovafloxacin enhances lipopolysaccharide-stimulated production of tumor necrosis factor-α by macrophages: role of the DNA damage response.

Trovafloxacin (TVX) is a drug that has caused idiosyncratic, drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) in humans. In a murine model of IDILI, otherwise nontoxic doses of TVX and the inflammagen lipopolysaccharide (LPS) interacted to produce pronounced hepatocellular injury. The liver injury depended on a TVX-induced, small but significant prolongation of tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF) appearance in the plasma. The enhancement of TNF expression by TVX was reproduced in vitro in RAW 264.7 murine macrophages (RAW cells) stimulated with LPS. The current study was designed to identify the molecular target of TVX responsible for this response in RAW cells. An in silico analysis suggested a favorable binding profile of TVX to eukaryotic topoisomerase II-α (TopIIα), and a cell-free assay revealed that TVX inhibited eukaryotic TopIIα activity. Topoisomerase inhibition is known to lead to DNA damage, and TVX increased the DNA damage marker phosphorylated histone 2A.X in RAW cells. Moreover, TVX induced activation of the DNA damage sensor kinases, ataxia telangiectasia mutated (ATM) and Rad3-related (ATR). The ATR inhibitor NU6027 [6-(cyclohexylmethoxy)-5-nitrosopyrimidine-2,4-diamine] prevented the TVX-mediated increases in LPS-induced TNF mRNA and protein release, whereas a selective ATM inhibitor [2-(4-morpholinyl)-6-(1-thianthrenyl)-4H-pyran-4-one (KU55933)] was without effect. TVX prolonged TNF mRNA stability, and this effect was largely attenuated by NU6027. These results suggest that TVX can inhibit eukaryotic topoisomerase, leading to activation of ATR and potentiation of TNF release by macrophages, at least in part through increased mRNA stability. This off-target effect might contribute to the ability of TVX to precipitate IDILI in humans.

Molecular Mechanisms of Hepatocellular Apoptosis Induced by Trovafloxacin-Tumor Necrosis Factor-alpha Interaction

Idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) continues to be a significant human health problem. IDILI is characterized as occurring in a minority of individuals exposed to a drug, yet it accounts for as much as 17% of all cases of acute liver failure. Despite these concerns, the mechanisms underlying IDILI remain unknown. Trovafloxacin (TVX), which causes IDILI in humans, also causes hepatocellular death in vitro when combined with tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF) treatment. However, the molecular mechanisms involved in this toxicity are not fully characterized. The purpose of this study was to identify mechanisms by which TVX and TNF interact to cause hepatocellular death, with a focus on a human hepatocyte cell line. TVX and TNF interacted to cause cytotoxicity in HepG2 cells at drug concentrations similar to those in people undergoing TVX therapy. TVX/TNF treatment caused apoptosis and DNA damage in HepG2 cells that depended on caspase activation. Prolonged activation of JNK occurred in TVX/TNF-induced cytotoxicity, and treatment with the JNK selective inhibitor SP600125 attenuated cytotoxicity. TVX/TNF cotreatment also caused cytotoxicity in isolated primary murine hepatocytes that was dependent on caspase activation. These results increase understanding of molecular signaling pathways involved in hepatocellular death caused by a drug with idiosyncratic liability in the presence of TNF.

Human Precision-Cut Liver Slices as an ex Vivo Model to Study Idiosyncratic Drug-Induced Liver Injury

Idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) is a major problem during drug development and has caused drug withdrawal and black-box warnings. Because of the low concordance of the hepatotoxicity of drugs in animals and humans, robust screening methods using human tissue are needed to predict IDILI in humans. According to the inflammatory stress hypothesis, the effects of inflammation interact with the effects of a drug or its reactive metabolite, precipitating toxic reactions in the liver. As a follow-up to our recently published mouse precision-cut liver slices model, an ex vivo model involving human precision-cut liver slices (hPCLS), co-incubated for 24 h with IDILI-related drugs and lipopolysaccharide (LPS), was developed to study IDILI mechanisms related to inflammatory stress in humans and to detect potential biomarkers. LPS exacerbated the effects of ketoconazole and clozapine toxicity but not those of their non-IDILI-related comparators, voriconazole and olanzapine. However, the IDILI-related drugs diclofenac, carbamazepine, and troglitazone did not show synergistic toxicity with LPS after incubation for 24 h. Co-incubation of ketoconazole and clozapine with LPS decreased the levels of glutathione in hPCLS, but this was not seen for the other drugs. All drugs affected LPS-induced cytokine release, but interestingly, only ketoconazole and clozapine increased the level of LPS-induced TNF release. Decreased levels of glutathione and cysteine conjugates of clozapine were detected in IDILI-responding livers following cotreatment with LPS. In conclusion, we identified ketoconazole and clozapine as drugs that exhibited synergistic toxicity with LPS, while glutathione and TNF were found to be potential biomarkers for IDILI-inducing drugs mediated by inflammatory stress. hPCLS appear to be suitable for further unraveling the mechanisms of inflammatory stress-associated IDILI.

The Liver Toxicity Biomarker Study Phase I: Markers for the Effects of Tolcapone or Entacapone

The Liver Toxicity Biomarker Study is a systems toxicology approach to discover biomarkers that are indicative of a drug's potential to cause human idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury. In phase I, the molecular effects in rat liver and blood plasma induced by tolcapone (a "toxic" drug) were compared with the molecular effects in the same tissues by dosing with entacapone (a "clean" drug, similar to tolcapone in chemical structure and primary pharmacological mechanism). Two durations of drug exposure, 3 and 28 days, were employed. Comprehensive molecular analysis of rat liver and plasma samples yielded marker analytes for various drug-vehicle or drug-drug comparisons. An important finding was that the marker analytes associated with tolcapone only partially overlapped with marker analytes associated with entacapone, despite the fact that both drugs have similar chemical structures and the same primary pharmacological mechanism of action. This result indicates that the molecular analyses employed in the study are detecting substantial "off-target" markers for the two drugs. An additional interesting finding was the modest overlap of the marker data sets for 3-day exposure and 28-day exposure, indicating that the molecular changes in liver and plasma caused by short- and long-term drug treatments do not share common characteristics.

Idiosyncratic Drug-Induced Liver Injury and the Role of Inflammatory Stress with an Emphasis on an Animal Model of Trovafloxacin Hepatotoxicity

Idiosyncratic adverse drug reactions (IADRs) occur in a minority of patients yet account for the majority of postmarketing use restrictions by the Food and Drug Administration. Despite the impact of these toxicities, the underlying mechanisms are still poorly understood. Animal models of IADRs would be beneficial in understanding mechanisms and in developing assays with predictive potential. Recent work exploring the interactions between inflammatory stress and drugs associated with human idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) has led to the development of the first animal models that apply to a range of drugs. Here, we discuss hypotheses for the mechanisms of IDILI and focus on a murine model of trovafloxacin-induced hepatotoxicity as an example related to the inflammatory stress hypothesis.

Medicine as a Planned Economy

Idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) typically occurs in a small fraction of patients and has resulted in removal of otherwise efficacious drugs from the market. Current preclinical testing methods are ineffective in predicting which drug candidates have IDILI liability. Recent results suggest that immune mediators such as tumor necrosis factor-<i>α</i> (TNF) and interferon-<i>γ</i> (IFN) interact with drugs that cause IDILI to kill hepatocytes. This proof-of-concept study was designed to test the hypothesis that drugs can be classified according to their ability to cause IDILI in humans using classification modeling with covariates derived from concentration-response relationships that describe cytotoxic interaction with cytokines. Human hepatoma (HepG2) cells were treated with drugs associated with IDILI or with drugs lacking IDILI liability and cotreated with TNF and/or IFN. Detailed concentration-response relationships were determined for calculation of parameters such as the maximal cytotoxic effect, slope, and EC₅₀ for use as covariates for classification modeling using logistic regression. These parameters were incorporated into multiple classification models to identify combinations of covariates that most accurately classified the drugs according to their association with human IDILI. Of 14 drugs associated with IDILI, almost all synergized with TNF to kill HepG2 cells and were successfully classified by statistical modeling. IFN enhanced the toxicity mediated by some IDILI-associated drugs in the presence of TNF. In contrast, of 10 drugs with little or no IDILI liability, none synergized with inflammatory cytokines to kill HepG2 cells and were classified accordingly. The resulting optimal model classified the drugs with extraordinary selectivity and specificity.