HeII Reionization Research Articles

A MEASUREMENT OF SMALL-SCALE STRUCTURE IN THE 2.2 ⩽z⩽ 4.2 Lyα FOREST

The amplitude of fluctuations in the Ly-a forest on small spatial scales is sensitive to the temperature of the IGM and its spatial fluctuations. The temperature of the IGM and its spatial variations contain important information about hydrogen and helium reionization. We present a new measurement of the small-scale structure in the Ly-a forest from 40 high resolution, high signal-to-noise, VLT spectra at z=2.2-4.2. We convolve each Ly-a forest spectrum with a suitably chosen wavelet filter, which allows us to extract the amount of small-scale structure in the forest as a function of position across each spectrum. We compare these measurements with high resolution hydrodynamic simulations of the Ly-a forest which track more than 2 billion particles. This comparison suggests that the IGM temperature close to the cosmic mean density (T_0) peaks near z=3.4, at which point it is greater than 20,000 K at 2-sigma confidence. The temperature at lower redshift is consistent with the fall-off expected from adiabatic cooling ($T_0 \propto (1+z)^2$), after the peak temperature is reached near z=3.4. At z=4.2 our results favor a temperature of T_0 = 15-20,000 K. However, owing mostly to uncertainties in the mean transmitted flux at this redshift, a cooler IGM model with T_0 = 10,000 K is only disfavored at the 2-sigma level here, although such cool IGM models are strongly discrepant with the z ~ 3-3.4 measurement. We do not detect large spatial fluctuations in the IGM temperature at any redshift covered by our data set. The simplest interpretation of our measurements is that HeII reionization completes sometime near z ~ 3.4, although statistical uncertainties are still large [Abridged].

LARGE-SCALE FLUCTUATIONS IN THE He II Lyα FOREST AND He II REIONIZATION

We examine large-scale fluctuations in the HeII Lyman-alpha forest transmission during and after HeII reionization. We use a simple Monte Carlo model to distribute quasars throughout a large volume and compute the resulting radiation field along one-dimensional skewers. In agreement with previous studies, we find that the rarity of these sources induces order unity fluctuations in the mean optical depth after reionization, even when averaged over large segments (~10-100 Mpc across). We compare our models to existing data along five HeII Lyman-alpha forest lines of sight spanning z~2-3.2. The large cosmic variance contained in our model plausibly explains many of the observed fluctuations at z<2.5. But our models cannot accommodate the large fluctuations toward high optical depths on ~30 Mpc scales observed at z~2.7-2.9, and the measured optical depths (tau>4) at z>2.9 are difficult to explain with a smoothly-evolving mean radiation field. In order to better understand this data, we construct a toy model of HeII reionization, in which we assume that regions with the smallest radiation fields in a post-reionization Universe (or farthest from strong ionizing sources) are completely dark during reionization. The observed fluctuations fit much more comfortably into this model, and we therefore argue that, according to present data, HeII reionization does not complete until z<2.9.

PARTICLE MESH SIMULATIONS OF THE Lyα FOREST AND THE SIGNATURE OF BARYON ACOUSTIC OSCILLATIONS IN THE INTERGALACTIC MEDIUM

We present a set of ultra-large particle-mesh simulations of the LyA forest targeted at understanding the imprint of baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) in the inter-galactic medium. We use 9 dark matter only simulations which can, for the first time, simultaneously resolve the Jeans scale of the intergalactic gas while covering the large volumes required to adequately sample the acoustic feature. Mock absorption spectra are generated using the fluctuating Gunn-Peterson approximation which have approximately correct flux probability density functions (PDFs) and small-scale power spectra. On larger scales there is clear evidence in the redshift space correlation function for an acoustic feature, which matches a linear theory template with constant bias. These spectra, which we make publicly available, can be used to test pipelines, plan future experiments and model various physical effects. As an illustration we discuss the basic properties of the acoustic signal in the forest, the scaling of errors with noise and source number density, modified statistics to treat mean flux evolution and misestimation, and non-gravitational sources such as fluctuations in the photo-ionizing background and temperature fluctuations due to HeII reionization.

TEN MORE NEW SIGHTLINES FOR THE STUDY OF INTERGALACTIC HELIUM, AND HUNDREDS OF FAR-ULTRAVIOLET-BRIGHT QUASARS, FROM THE SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY, GALAXY EVOLUTION EXPLORER , AND HUBBLE SPACE TELESCOPE

Absorption along quasar sightlines remains among the most sensitive direct measures of HeII reionization in much of the intergalactic medium (IGM). Until recently, fewer than a half-dozen unobscured quasar sightlines suitable for the HeII Gunn-Peterson test were known; although these handful demonstrated great promise, the small sample size limited confidence in cosmological inferences. We have recently added nine more such clean HeII quasars, exploiting SDSS quasar samples, broadband UV imaging from GALEX, and high-yield UV spectroscopic confirmations from HST. Here we markedly expand this approach by cross-correlating SDSS DR7 and GALEX GR4+5 to catalog 428 SDSS and 165 other quasars with z>2.78 having likely (~70%) GALEX detections, suggesting they are bright into the far-UV. Reconnaissance HST Cycle 16 Supplemental prism data for 29 of these new quasar-GALEX matches spectroscopically confirm 17 as indeed far-UV bright. At least 10 of these confirmations have clean sightlines all the way down to HeII Lyman-alpha, substantially expanding the number of known clean HeII quasars, and reaffirming the order of magnitude enhanced efficiency of our selection technique. Combined confirmations from this and our past programs yield more than twenty HeII quasars, quintupling the sample. These provide substantial progress toward a sample of HeII quasar sightlines large enough, and spanning a sufficient redshift range, to enable statistical IGM studies that may avoid individual object peculiarity and sightline variance. Our expanded catalog of hundreds of high-likelihood far-UV-bright QSOs additionally will be useful for understanding the extreme-UV properties of the quasars themselves.

$\ion{Ar}{i}$ as a tracer of ionization evolution

We present a study of Ar abundances in 15 damped Ly alpha systems (DLAs) in the redshift interval from 2.3 to 3.4. The sample includes 4 new UVES/VLT measurements of Ar I column densities. The majority of DLAs show significant underabundances of Ar relative to other alpha-capture elements with common nucleosynthetic origin. We show that neither dust depletion nor intervening HII regions inside DLAs offer a viable justification to these underabundances. A natural explanation is found in the framework of photoionization models of HI regions embedded in an ionizing continuum with varying spectral distribution. At z ~ 2.5 the observed Ar deficiencies are large, [Ar/alpha] ~ -0.6/-0.8 dex, suggestive of a hard, QSO-dominated spectrum. At z >~ 3 the deficiencies are instead small, suggestive of a soft, stellar-type spectrum, though more data are needed to generalize this high-z result. We argue that the change of Ar abundances is induced by the evolution of the UV metagalactic continuum, in which case the UV emission internal to DLAs must be small (i.e. DLAs should have modest star formation rates) and the external background must become softer at z > 3. The former requirement is consistent with the modest evolution of DLAs abundances and the lack of Ly_alpha and H_alpha emissions associated with DLAs. The latter requirement is consistent with the observed evolution of SiIV/CIV ratios in the IGM, the claims of high escape fraction of UV photons from Ly-break galaxies at z >~ 3, and the recent finding that the HeII re-ionization seems to occur between z ~ 3.4 and z ~ 3. From the comparison with local interstellar studies, we predict a rise of Ar abundances in the redshift range from z ~ 2.3 to z=0, at the epoch at which the metagalactic field of galaxies overcomes that of quasars.

The evolution of the physical state of the IGM

Using a new, increased dataset of 7 QSOs from VLT/UVES observations combined with one QSO from the literature, the minimum Doppler parameters as a function of neutral hydrogen column density N(HI), b_c(N), of the Lyman-alpha forest has been derived at three redshifts z = 2.1, 3.3 and 3.8. When incompleteness of the number of the observed lines towards lower N(HI) is accounted for, the derived slopes of b_c(N), (Gamma-1), are consistent with no-redshift evolution with an indication of lower value at z = 3.3, while b_c(N) at a fixed column density N(HI) = 10^(13.6) cm^(-2), b_c(13.6), increases as z decreases. Assuming a QSO-dominated UV background, the slope of the equation of state (gamma-1) shows no z-evolution within large uncertainties and the temperature at the mean density, T_0, decreases as z decreases at three redshift ranges. There is a large fluctuation of (Gamma-1) and b_c(13.6) even at the similar redshifts, in particular at z = 3.3 and 3.8. The lower (Gamma-1) and higher b_c(13.6) values at z ~ 3.1 and 3.6 compared to ones at z ~ 3.4 and 3.9 are caused by a lack of lower-N(HI) and lower-b lines, probably due to the HeII reionization. This result suggests that an impact from the HeII reionization on the forest might be mainly on the lower-N(HI) forest. We find some forest clouds with a high ratio of SiIV column density to CIV column density at z < 2.5, although the bulk of the forest clouds shows lower N(SiIV)/N(CIV). This high N(SiIV)/N(CIV) at z < 2.5 suggests that some forest clouds are exposed to a soft UV background.

Reionization of the Inhomogeneous Universe

A model of the density distribution in the intergalactic medium, motivated by that found in numerical simulations, is used to demonstrate the effect of a clumpy IGM and discrete sources on the reionization of the universe. In an inhomogeneous universe reionization occurs outside-in, starting in voids and gradually penetrating into overdense regions. Reionization should not be sudden but gradual, with a continuous rise of the photon mean free path over a fair fraction of the Hubble time as the emissivity increases. We show that a hydrogen Gunn-Peterson trough should be present at $z\simeq 6$ unless the emissivity increases with redshift at $z>4$. However, the epoch of overlap of cosmological \hii regions could have occurred at a higher redshift if sources of low luminosity reionized the IGM; the Gunn-Peterson trough at $z\sim 6$ would then appear because even the most underdense voids have a large enough neutral fraction in ionization equilibrium to be optically thick to \lya photons. Cosmological \hii regions near the epoch of overlap can produce gaps of transmitted flux only if luminous quasars contributed to the reionization. Despite the clumpiness of the matter distribution, recombinations are not very important during the reionization of hydrogen because the high density gas is not ionized until a late time. We show that the \heii reionization was most likely delayed relative to the hydrogen reionization, but should be completed by $z\sim 3$, the redshift where observations are available. The reported large optical depth fluctuations of \heii are probably not due to an incomplete \heii reionization, but arise from a combination of density fluctuations and the variations in the intensity of the ionizing background due to luminous QSO's.