Reviewed by: The Violence of the Biblical God: Canonical Narrative and Christian Faith by L. Daniel Hawk Eric A. Seibert l. daniel hawk, The Violence of the Biblical God: Canonical Narrative and Christian Faith (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2019). Pp. xviii + 222. Paper $35. In his newest book, Dan Hawk addresses one of the most challenging theological issues in the Hebrew Bible: divine violence. H. is well positioned to write on this subject given his extensive scholarship on the Book of Joshua throughout his career. The Violence of the Biblical God consists of nine chapters, a bibliography, and indexes (author, subject, and Scripture). In chap. 1, H. acknowledges the difficulties many readers have with the violence of God in the OT. He then reviews a number of approaches (e.g., allegorical, historical-critical) that have been taken to remove, or resolve, the problems these texts ostensibly create. H. finds these approaches unsatisfactory and proposes an alternate way forward. He believes we should read the Bible “with a focus on how it narrates [End Page 482] God’s experience of and work in a violent world” (p. 17; emphasis mine). Therefore, H. focuses exclusively on the world of the text. With this approach, the majority of the book, chaps. 2–7, is devoted to a close reading of selected OT narratives. H. attempts to explain Yhwh’s relationship to the violence narrated in the text, and he offers various explanations for why God gets entangled in warfare and killing. H. sees God learning, growing, changing, and adapting to events and people along the way. In chap. 2, H. explores Genesis 1–11, emphasizing that human violence was not God’s original intention for the world but rather results from “humanity’s determination to make the world in its own image and likeness” (p. 23). H. challenges the notion that God responds angrily to Adam and Eve’s disobedience, Cain’s murder, the violent antediluvian population, or the tower builders. Rather than seeing God’s actions as primarily punitive, H. believes God reacts to the world and engages it for the purpose of restoration. In chap. 3, H. describes the way Yhwh binds himself to Abraham in a move that will necessarily embroil Yhwh in further acts of violence. Yhwh will be faithful to Abraham even if that means behaving violently toward those, like Pharaoh, who inadvertently “wrong” Abraham (see Gen 12:10–20). H. also regards the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah, like the flood, as “an acceleration of a process of ruination” rather than an act of divine judgment (p. 60). In chap. 4, H. discusses how Yhwh must deliver the Hebrew people from Egyptian oppression in order to honor the divine promise made to the patriarchs. Yet sending plagues, hardening Pharaoh’s heart, and decimating Egypt’s army do more than liberate Hebrew slaves; they demonstrate Yhwh’s absolute supremacy. The destruction of chaotic human powers and structures makes way for Yhwh to reorder the world and to make space for a new creation in and through the people of Israel. Chapter 5 deals with the second part of Exodus, briefly noting the covenant made between Yhwh and Israel and mostly concentrating on the golden calf debacle, which represents the covenant being broken. H. emphasizes how this represents the first time divine anger is connected to divine violence (p. 104). In chap. 6, H. explores Yhwh’s deepening involvement in violence through Yhwh’s allowance of a king in Israel. Because of this decision, H. believes “Yahweh is drawn into the contests of power and violence that define the ends and means of monarchies” (p. 117). In chap. 7, H. turns his attention to the conquest narrative in the Book of Joshua. He disputes the commonly held assumption that the slaughter of the Canaanites was an act of divine judgment. Instead, he argues it is a necessary step Yhwh must take to clear the land so that an alternative kind of community can be formed. Yet, for all this effort and the massive amount of violence it required, H. says, “Yahweh’s grand plan, to heal the world by identifying with a people, ends in disaster” (p. 169). In light...
Read full abstract