DEBRA J. PEPLER, KIRSTEN C. MADSEN, CHRISTOPHER D. WEBSTER, and KATHRYN S. LEVENE (Eds.) The Development and Treatment of Girlhood Aggression Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2005, 336 pages (ISBN 0-8058-4039-7, CDN$87.96 Cloth) Reviewed by ISABELA GRANIC This edited volume represents a compilation of papers that were presented at a 1999 symposium on girls' aggression and includes all the presenters in that symposium as well as several additional authors who contributed chapters or commentaries. It includes the pioneering work of a prestigious set of international scholars who have recently turned their research lens towards the burgeoning field of girls' aggressive behaviour. The general objectives of the book are to 1) provide up-to-date information about what is known about aggressive girls, 2) discuss prevention and intervention implications, and 3) raise new questions for future research. The collective authors meet these goals admirably. It is an ambitious volume covering a wide array of issues, disciplines and developmental phases. Each of the chapters is well written and thoughtful, highlighting current research knowledge and the large number of questions still to be answered through future studies. After each of the five sections of the book, a commentary is provided by some of the most prominent researchers in the field. On the whole, these commentaries are extremely useful in contextualizing each chapter and highlighting the key strengths, limitations, controversies, and implications associated with the papers. Aggressive girls have long been overlooked in the research literature and this set of papers makes a compelling case for why this should be, and is, no longer the case. The book provides a comprehensive sweep of what is currently known about the development and treatment of girls' aggression and, thus, it would make an excellent graduate text for students studying developmental psychopathology and clinical psychology, particularly those interested in childhood aggression and sex differences. Throughout the various chapters, a number of related themes emerge. Although these themes may be important for understanding aggression in boys as well, the authors argue convincingly that these issues are particularly salient and provide stronger predictive power for girls' aggression. First, it is clear to most of the volume's contributors that girls' aggressive behaviour should be understood and studied as a relationship problem. As highlighted in the chapters by Pepler and Madsen, Pepler and Craig, Miller-Johnson, and colleagues, Xie and colleagues, Artz, and Levene and colleagues, the most important factors that promote, maintain, and amplify aggression in girls all point to difficulties in core relationships. These relationships include those with parents, siblings, friends, peer groups, and romantic partners. A second theme that re-emerges throughout the various chapters is the importance of understanding the developmental context within which girls' aggression is embedded. The risks, long-term outcomes, and treatment implications differ substantially for 2-3-year-old girls who are physically aggressive (discussed by Baillargeon, Tremblay, & Wilms), adolescent girls who engage in fierce forms of social aggression (examined by Xie, Cairns, & Cairns as well as Artz), and antisocial women who become mothers to at-risk children (discussed by Zoccolillo and colleagues and Stack and colleagues). A third theme that is highlighted by several authors is the transactional, interactional nature of girls' aggression. That is, aggressive behaviour in these troubled girls' lives develops through a confluence of intraindividual factors, including hyperactivity/inattention, early pubertal development and social cognitions, which reciprocally and iteratively interact with risky environmental contexts such as poor parenting practices, sexual abuse, aggressive siblings, and antisocial peer contexts. The chapter by Pepler and Craig makes this point most explicitly, but the interactional framework is evident in the majority of the contributions. …
Read full abstract