Fluorescent Substances Research Articles

Less interference fluorescence analytical strategy: Bridging substance-triggered ratiometric sensor with convenient preparation and application

High interference and narrow application range are key of bottleneck of recent fluorescence analysis methods, which limit their wide application in the sensing field. Therefore, to overcome these disadvantages, a ratiometric fluorescence sensing system utilizing berberine (BER) and silver nanoclusters protected by dihydrolipoic acid (DHLA-AgNCs) was constructed for the first time in this work, to achieve determination of BER and daunorubicin (Dau). BER aqueous solution (non-planar conformation) has no fluorescence emission. When it was mixed with DHLA-AgNCs, the conformation of BER became planar, producing fluorescence emission at 515 nm besides the fluorescence emission peak of DHLA-AgNCs at 653 nm. With the increase of BER concentration added in system, the fluorescence intensity of BER (planar conformation) at 515 nm increased obviously and the fluorescence intensity of DHLA-AgNCs decreased slightly. Therefore, the dual emission fluorescence sensing system was constructed based on a fluorescence substance and non fluorescence substance, to achieve determination of BER. Meanwhile, based on the bridging effect of BER and fluorescence resonance energy transfer effect from Dau, the altering of two peaks intensity was utilized to achieve determination of Dau. Thus, this dual emission sensing system can not only be used for fluorescence analysis of BER and its analogues, but also based on the bridging effect of BER, allowing the determination of Dau and its analogues that could not be directly measured with silver nanoclusters, expanding the application range of traditional dual emission detection systems. Meanwhile, this system has strong anti-interference ability and low toxicity to the human body and less pollution to the sample and environment. This provides a new direction and universal research strategy for the construction of new fluorescence sensing systems in the future for the analysis of target substances that cannot be directly detected with conventional fluorescence analysis methods.

Photocatalytic peroxydisulfate activation for dissolved organic matter degradation in eutrophic lake water using S-scheme BiVO4/g-C3N4 3D/2D heterojunction under visible light

Large amounts of carbon are stored primarily in dissolved organic matter (DOM), which plays an important indicator of lake eutrophication. However, removing DOM from eutrophic lakes remains a major challenge. Herein, a novel S-scheme flower-like microsphere BiVO4/nanosheet g-C3N4 3D/2D heterojunction was successfully constructed using a two-step method for DOM degradation of real eutrophic lake water in the presence of peroxydisulfate (PDS). 1.0-BiVO4/g-C3N4/PDS exhibited highly efficient photocatalytic performance with an 87.8 % removal rate of DOM for 60 min, which was 5.3 and 8.9 times higher than BiVO4/PDS and g-C3N4/PDS, respectively. Sulfate radical (·SO4−), hydroxyl radical (·OH) and singlet oxygen (1O2) were mainly responsible for DOM degradation in the 1.0-BiVO4/g-C3N4/PDS system, and the transformation pathway of 1O2 was emphatically analyzed. In addition, the changes of fluorescence components in DOM were detected using synchronous fluorescence spectra, second derivative spectra, and two-dimensional correlated spectroscopy analysis. Humic-like fluorescence, fulvic-like fluorescence, and protein-like substances were removed higher than 85.30 %, 73.02 %, and 67.23 % by the 1.0-BiVO4/g-C3N4 catalyst activating the PDS under visible light (VL), respectively. When the toxicity of catalytically treated eutrophic lake water was estimated by growth inhibition of Escherichia coli, the biotoxicity of DOM decreased continuously in the BiVO4/g-C3N4/PDS/VL coupling process. Theoretical calculations and photoelectrochemical tests suggested that the BiVO4/g-C3N4/PDS catalytic activity enhancement was attributed to the S-scheme mechanism and hybrid advanced oxidation process. It is expected that this work can provide new insight into DOM degradation in eutrophic lake water by the heterogeneous photocatalysis combined with the PDS activation system.

Browning mechanism of sorbitol-glycine system in the presence of glycerol: Regulating conversion of sorbitol to reducing sugars and water status

Unexpected browning was observed in sorbitol and amino acid system under high-temperature process and long-term storage. The effect of glycerol on the browning reaction of sorbitol-glycine model system under different heat treatment time was explored. The results confirmed that partial sorbitol was converted to glucose and fructose, which underwent a Maillard reaction with glycine to produce the melanoidins. Glycerol concentration and the heating time were positively correlated with the course of the reaction, which reflected in the increase of browning index, the rise of uncolored intermediate products and fluorescent substance accumulation. Compared with the system without glycerol, the browning index increased by about 100 times and the accumulation of uncolored intermediate products increased by 65 times with the presence of 4 mol/L glycerol. Furthermore, the content of α-dicarbonyl compounds (glyoxal, methylglyoxal and 2, 3-butanedione) in the system was changed by glycerol, which showed a trend of first increasing and then decreasing with the accumulation of melanoidins, and reached a peak value of 190.6 mg/L after heating for 2 h. The glycerol-dependent browning was related to the water activity of the system at a high level (>0.80) and the migration rate of free water to immobilized water ranging from 0.60% to 8.59%. It indicated that glycerol could promote the reaction by influencing the substrate concentration, weakening the inhibition of product and promoting the conversion of sorbitol to reducing sugar.

Aggregation-Induced Emission Luminogens: A New Possibility for Efficient Visualization of RNA in Plants.

RNAs play important roles in regulating biological growth and development. Advancements in RNA-imaging techniques are expanding our understanding of their function. Several common RNA-labeling methods in plants have pros and cons. Simultaneously, plants' spontaneously fluorescent substances interfere with the effectiveness of RNA bioimaging. New technologies need to be introduced into plant RNA luminescence. Aggregation-induced emission luminogens (AIEgens), due to their luminescent properties, tunable molecular size, high fluorescence intensity, good photostability, and low cell toxicity, have been widely applied in the animal and medical fields. The application of this technology in plants is still at an early stage. The development of AIEgens provides more options for RNA labeling. Click chemistry provides ideas for modifying AIEgens into RNA molecules. The CRISPR/Cas13a-mediated targeting system provides a guarantee of precise RNA modification. The liquid-liquid phase separation in plant cells creates conditions for the enrichment and luminescence of AIEgens. The only thing that needs to be looked for is a specific enzyme that uses AIEgens as a substrate and modifies AIEgens onto target RNA via a click chemical reaction. With the development and progress of artificial intelligence and synthetic biology, it may soon be possible to artificially synthesize or discover such an enzyme.

Purification, characterization and study of blue fluorescent substance in caffeine

AbstractBackgroundCaffeine, a xanthine alkaloid compound, is a stimulant of the central nervous system and is mainly used in the pharmaceutical and food industries. Because caffeine is directly absorbed into the body, Chinese pharmacopeia has high requirements on the quality of caffeine products, and fluorescence has always been an important indicator to measure the quality of caffeine. In this study, a major fluorescent impurity affecting the appearance and purity of caffeine products was isolated for the first time, and the solubility, thermodynamic properties and dissociation constants of this impurity were studied.Results(i) The fluorescent impurity affecting the appearance and purity of the product was successfully isolated from crude caffeine and theophylline sodium salt, and named as a blue fluorescent substance. The mass purity of the substance was 96.27%, and its structure was determined based on a comprehensive analysis of high‐resolution mass spectrometry and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy [hydrogen 1 (1H) NMR, carbon‐13 (13C) NMR, COSY, NOESY, HSQC, HMBC]. (ii) The solubility of blue fluorescent substance in four pure solvents was determined and the thermodynamic properties were calculated. (iii) The dissociation constants of the blue fluorescent substance in water at 298.15 K were determined by UV spectrophotometry.ConclusionThe results provide a theoretical basis for the crystallization separation of the blue fluorescent substance during the industrial production of caffeine, as well as basic data for the green synthesis process of caffeine. © 2024 Society of Chemical Industry (SCI).

Characterization of microplastic-derived dissolved organic matter in freshwater: Effects of light irradiation and polymer types

This study investigated the impacts of light irradiation and polymer types on the leaching behavior of dissolved organic matter (DOM) from microplastics (MPs) in freshwater. Polypropylene had the highest leaching capacity of DOM after photoaging, followed by polystyrene (PS), polyamide (PA) and polyethylene terephthalate (PET). While similarly low levels of DOM were observed in the remaining 5 MP suspensions under UV irradiation and in almost all MP suspensions (except PA) under darkness. These suggest that the photooxidation of some buoyant plastics may influence the carbon cycling of nature waters. Among 9 MP-derived leachates, PET leachates had the highest chromophoric DOM concentration and aromaticity, probably owing to the special benzene rings and carbonyl groups in PET structures and its fast degradation rate. Protein-like substances were the primary fluorescent DOM in MP suspensions (except PS), especially in darkness no other fluorescent substances were found. Considering the bio-labile properties of proteins together, MPs regardless of floating or suspended in an aquatic environment may have prevalent long-term effects on microbial activities. Besides, from monomers to hexamers with newly formed chemical bonds were identified in UV-irradiated MP suspensions. These results will contribute to a deep insight into the potential ecological effects related to MP degradation.

A Self-Accelerating Naphthalimide-Based Probe Coupled with Upconversion Nanoparticles for Ultra-Accurate Tri-Mode Visualization of Hydrogen Peroxide.

The design and development of ultra-accurate probe is of great significance to chemical sensing in complex practical scenarios. Here, a self-accelerating naphthalimide-based probe with fast response and high sensitivity toward hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) is designed. By coupling with the specially selected upconversion nanoparticles (UCNPs), an ultra-accurate colorimetric-fluorescent-upconversion luminescence (UCL) tri-mode platform is constructed. Owing to the promoted reaction process, this platform demonstrates rapid response (< 1s), an ultra-low detection limit (4.34nM), and superb anti-interferent ability even in presence of > 21 types of oxidants, explosives, metallic salts, daily compounds, colorful or fluorescent substances. In addition, the effectiveness of this design is further verified by a sponge-based sensing chip loaded with the UCNPs/probe in recognizing trace H2O2 vapor from interferents with the three characteristic colors existing simultaneously. The proposed design of probe and tri-mode visualization detection platform is expected to open up a brand-new methodology for ultra-accurate sensing.

Combining fluorescent quantum dots with transition metal oxide shell as core-shell nanocomposite for turn-on sensing of ascorbic acid

Ascorbic acid (AA) is an essential vitamin in humans, and numerous AA detection studies have been conducted. Most quantum dots (QDs)-based approaches depend on redox reactions involving AA, and they require the introduction of an intermediate (e.g., metal ions, OPD, TMB) or the assembly of fluorescent substances with nanosheets (such as MnO2) that can be degraded by AA. These methods are complex, unstable, and are susceptible to interferences. To address these problems, a core-shell fluorescence probe was developed for turn-on sensing of AA. The transition metal oxide shell FeOOH was generated around the surface of CuInZnS QDs to quench the fluorescence. In the presence of AA, the FeOOH shell was decomposed into Fe2+ and the fluorescence of QDs was recovered. Using a physical shell, the obtained nanocomposite realized direct AA detection, avoiding the effects of interfering substances caused by QDs exposure. Moreover, our probe showed great potential in point-of-care tests and was readily adapted for use as a smartphone-assisted paper sensor.

Real-time laser speckle contrast imaging for intraoperative neurovascular blood flow assessment: animal experimental study.

The use of various blood flow control methods in neurovascular interventions is crucial for reducing postoperative complications. Neurosurgeons worldwide use different methods, such as contact Dopplerography, intraoperative indocyanine videoangiography (ICG) video angiography, fluorescein angiography, flowmetry, intraoperative angiography, and direct angiography. However, there is no noninvasive method that can assess the presence of blood flow in the vessels of the brain without the introduction of fluorescent substances throughout the intervention. The real-time laser-speckle contrast imaging (LSCI) method was studied for its effectiveness in controlling blood flow in standard cerebrovascular surgery cases in rat common carotid arteries, such as proximal occlusion, trapping, reperfusion, anastomosis, and intraoperative vessel thrombosis. The real-time LSCI method is a promising method for use in neurosurgical practice. This approach allows timely diagnosis of intraoperative disturbance of blood flow in vessels in cases of clip occlusion or thrombosis. Additionally, LSCI allows us to reliably confirm the functioning of the anastomosis and reperfusion after removal of the clips and thrombolysis in real time. An unresolved limitation of the method is noise from movements, but this does not reduce the value of the method. Additional research is required to improve the quality of the data obtained.

Theoretical Design and Synthesis of Caged Compounds Using X-Ray-Triggered Azo Bond Cleavage.

Caged compounds are frequently used in life science research. However, the light used to activate them is commonly absorbed and scattered by biological materials, limiting their use to basic research in cells or small animals. In contrast, hard X-rays exhibit high bio-permeability due to the difficulty of interacting with biological molecules. With the main goal of developing X-ray activatable caged compounds, azo compounds are designed and synthesized with a positive charge and long π-conjugated system to increase the reaction efficiency with hydrated electrons. The azo bonds in the designed compounds are selectively cleaved by X-ray, and the fluorescent substance Diethyl Rhodamine is released. Based on the results of experiments and quantum chemical calculations, azo bond cleavage is assumed to occur via a two-step process: a two-electron reduction of the azo bond followed by N─N bond cleavage. Cellular experiments also demonstrate that the azo bonds can be cleaved intracellularly. Thus, caged compounds that can be activated by an azo bond cleavage reaction promoted by X-ray are successfully generated.

Horizontal and vertical microchamber platforms for evaluation of the paracellular permeability of an epithelial cell monolayer.

Epithelial cells serve as a barrier by tightly adhering to each other and contribute to the homeostasis of living organisms by controlling substance permeation. Therefore, evaluation of the barrier function is important in pharmaceutical development processes. However, the widely used Transwell-based assays require the development of the defect-free epithelial cell monolayer above several tens of mm2, often resulting in low reproducibility and requiring a long incubation time. In addition, the culture surface of cells is far from the bottom of the well plate, making it difficult to observe the cell morphology using an optical microscope. Herein, we propose simple polydimethylsiloxane microfluidic devices for evaluating the barrier function of an epithelial monolayer using a microchamber array. After the formation of the epithelial monolayer over microchambers, the permeation of the marker molecules introduced above resulted in increased fluorescence intensity in microchambers, which was monitored using confocal laser scanning microscopy. We show that using this technique, alteration of the paracellular permeability induced by sodium caprate (C10) and cytochalasin-D, permeation enhancing factors, can be elucidated. Furthermore, by tilting the microchamber device 90 degrees, the vertical cell section and microchambers were imaged in the same focal plane, allowing for live visualization of the passage of fluorescent substances across the cell monolayer. This technique is expected to be useful for investigating the relationship between paracellular permeability and cell morphology, which is unattainable through conventional methods.

The preparation and dual-mode detection of ascorbic acid based on poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) nanogel with oxidase-like activity.

Nanozymes have recently become a research hotspot because of the advantages of good stability, excellent catalytic performance and easy storage in comparison to natural enzymes. Nanozymes with oxidase-like activity get special attention because they needn't the participation of hydrogen peroxide. In this paper, poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) nanogel with oxidase-like activity was synthesized for the first time. The catalytic mechanism was explored by EPR and UV spectroscopy after adding specific trapping agents of ROS, and the results showed that PNIPAM NG can catalyze O2 to 1O2. In the presence of PNIPAM NG, o-phenylenediamine (OPD) and ascorbic acid (AA) can be oxidized to 2,3-diaminophenazine (oxOPD) and dehydroascorbic acid (DHA), and DHA can further react with OPD to produce a fluorescence substance. The colorimetric and fluorescence detection platforms for AA were constructed based on the above principles. Both platforms have satisfactory results in real samples. The fluorescence platform has better sensitivity and selectivity than the colorimetric platform.

Different responses of Sinorhizobium sp. upon Pb and Zn exposure: Mineralization versus complexation

Lead (Pb) and zinc (Zn) have been discharged into environment and may negatively impact ecological security. Rhizobia has gained attention due to their involvement in the restoration of metal polluted soils. However, little is known about the responses of rhizobia under Pb and Zn stress, especially the roles played by extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) in the resistance of these two metals. Here, Sinorhizobium sp. C10 was isolated from soil around a mining area and was exposed to a series of Pb/Zn treatments. The cell morphology and surface mineral crystals, EPS content and fluorescent substances were determined. In addition, the extracellular polysaccharides and proteins were characterized by attenuated total reflection infrared spectroscopy (ATR-IR) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The results showed that Zn stress induced the synthesis of EPS by C10 cells. Functional groups of polysaccharides (CO) and proteins (C–O/C–N) were involved in complexation with Zn. In contrast, C10 resisted Pb stress by forming lead phosphate (Pb3(PO4)2) on the cell surface. Galactose (Gal) and tyrosine played key roles in resistance to the Zn toxicity, whereas glucosamine (N-Glc) was converted to glucose in large amounts during extracellular Pb precipitation. Together, this study demonstrated that C10 possessed different strategies to detoxify the two metals, and could provide basis for bioremediation of Pb and Zn polluted sites.

Rapid detection and identification of microplastics from nonchemically treated soil with CARS microspectroscopy

In conventional microplastic (MP) analysis, acid or alkaline digestion is a necessary pretreatment step to remove residual organic matter from environmental samples. However, such a digestion process is not only cumbersome and time-consuming, but also possibly cause severe chemical damage to the MP itself, often making accurate MP characterization difficult. This study demonstrates that broadband coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering (CARS) microspectroscopy is useful for rapidly detecting and identifying MPs in natural soil without any digestion process. A feasibility test is performed with soil samples, which are known to require the most complicated chemical pretreatment for MP analysis, deliberately mixed with various MP particles. The C–H bond-specific CARS imaging and spectral analysis allow rapid MP particle search and chemical identification even in the presence of other residual particles and strongly fluorescent substances from the soil. It is anticipated that this nondestructive, chemical pretreatment-free CARS approach will be a beneficial tool for studying the ecological impacts of MPs absorbed by terrestrial life, such as plants and soil organisms, as well as for complementary analysis of MPs subject to chemical degradation by digestion in investigating the environmental contamination of the MPs.

Rapid determination of histamine in cheese by employing fluorescence enhancement of quantum dots-molecularly imprinted polymer

A fluorescent surface imprinted polymer was prepared by grafting Cadmium Telluride (CdTe) quantum dots into the methacrylic acid polymerization on the surface of silica. And a rapid turn-on fluorescence biosensor based on fluorescence enhancement effect was developed for the rapid and sensitive detection of histamine, which only took 8 min with a sensitive detection limit of 14.3 μmol/L. The cheese samples were tested by employing the fluorescent imprinted polymer, and the recovery was obtained in the range of 92.1–102%. The proposed histamine biosensing method shows great advantages, including no need for derivatization and reduced consumption of organic reagents. This has an important guiding role in the rapid detection of biological amines and other fluorescent responsive substances in complex systems.

Applications of Supramolecular Polymers Generated from Pillar[n]arene-Based Molecules.

Supramolecular chemistry enables the manipulation of functional components on a molecular scale, facilitating a "bottom-up" approach to govern the sizes and structures of supramolecular materials. Using dynamic non-covalent interactions, supramolecular polymers can create materials with reversible and degradable characteristics and the abilities to self-heal and respond to external stimuli. Pillar[n]arene represents a novel class of macrocyclic hosts, emerging after cyclodextrins, crown ethers, calixarenes, and cucurbiturils. Its significance lies in its distinctive structure, comparing an electron-rich cavity and two finely adjustable rims, which has sparked considerable interest. Furthermore, the straightforward synthesis, uncomplicated functionalization, and remarkable properties of pillar[n]arene based on supramolecular interactions make it an excellent candidate for material construction, particularly in generating interpenetrating supramolecular polymers. Polymers resulting from supramolecular interactions involving pillar[n]arene find potential in various applications, including fluorescence sensors, substance adsorption and separation, catalysis, light-harvesting systems, artificial nanochannels, and drug delivery. In this context, we provide an overview of these recent frontier research fields in the use of pillar[n]arene-based supramolecular polymers, which serves as a source of inspiration for the creation of innovative functional polymer materials derived from pillar[n]arene derivatives.

Novel Fluorometric Assay of Antiglycation Activity Based on Methylglyoxal-Induced Protein Carbonylation.

Advanced glycation end products (AGEs), which can have multiple structures, are formed at the sites where the carbonyl groups of reducing sugars bind to the free amino groups of proteins through the Maillard reaction. Some AGE structures exhibit fluorescence, and this fluorescence has been used to measure the formation and quantitative changes in carbonylated proteins. Recently, fluorescent AGEs have also been used as an index for the evaluation of compounds that inhibit protein glycation. However, the systems used to generate fluorescent AGEs from the reaction of reducing sugars and proteins used for the evaluation of antiglycation activity have not been determined through appropriate research; thus, problems remain regarding sensitivity, quantification, and precision. In the present study, using methylglyoxal (MGO), a reactive carbonyl compound to induce glycation, a comparative analysis of the mechanisms of formation of fluorescent substances from several types of proteins was conducted. The analysis identified hen egg lysozyme (HEL) as a protein that produces stronger fluorescent AGEs faster in the Maillard reaction with MGO. It was also found that the AGE structure produced in MGO-induced in HEL was argpyrimidine. By optimizing the reaction system, we developed a new evaluation method for compounds with antiglycation activity and established an efficient evaluation method (HEL-MGO assay) with greater sensitivity and accuracy than the conventional method, which requires high concentrations of bovine serum albumin and glucose. Furthermore, when compounds known to inhibit glycation were evaluated using this method, their antiglycation activities were clearly and significantly measured, demonstrating the practicality of this method.

Fluorimetric study on a novel FDA-approved combination used for the treatment of overactive bladder syndrome in different matrices

For the first time, two spectrofluorimetric techniques were created for the concurrent determination of mirabegron (MBN) and solifenacin (SOL) in different matrices. This novel combination recently received FDA approval to treat overactive bladder syndrome and was marketed under the brand name MiragoTMS25. SOL has a native fluorescence and can be estimated directly in the presence of MBN without any interference at 290 nm after excitation at 230 nm. In contrast to SOL, MBN is a weak fluorescent substance that requires the use of a fluorogenic reagent (like NBD-Cl) to be measured simultaneously with SOL in their mixtures. So, we reacted MBN with NBD-Cl to yield a yellow-colored fluorophore that could be estimated at 546 nm after excitation at 471 nm without any preliminary separation or interference from SOL. All experimental conditions of the applied methods were tested and enhanced for the best results. The applied fluorimetric methods succeeded in determining both drugs in nanograms, making them applicable in biological fluids like human plasma. The linearity ranges of SOL and MBN were found to be 5–250 ng/mL and 50–600 ng/mL, respectively. The LOD values were 0.96 ng/mL and 5.09 ng/mL for SOL and MBN, in order. Excellent results were attained for both drugs during their analysis in spiked plasma samples employing the applied fluorimetric methods, confirming their suitability for use in real human plasma samples and paving the way for further bioequivalence studies on both drugs.

Formation of fluorescent substances and correlation with process flavor changes of dehydrated Maillard reaction intermediates of peanut protein hydrolysates

Maillard reaction intermediates (MRIs) derived from peanut protein hydrolysates (PPH) and xylose (Xyl) were prepared using the water bath combined with spray drying and vacuum drying. The monitoring of free amino content, browning precursors, and taste characteristics was carried out throughout the thermal treatment at low temperature, where the Maillard reaction process was slowed down, and the formation and degradation of MRIs were dynamically balanced at low conversion rates. The reaction between amino compounds and the reducing sugars contributed to the increased taste characteristics during the early phase of Maillard reaction. Fluorescence intensity was reduced after reaching its maximum value and browning intensity was significantly increased during vacuum drying, which confirmed that the Maillard reaction entered into an advanced stage. Vacuum drying also led to a significant increase in the total amount of volatile compounds in the subsequent thermal processing reaction (from 212.93 ng/g to 564.91 ng/g), which demonstrated that the higher fluorescence intensities resulted in the more accumulation of MRIs and better capabilities of flavor formation.

Research on the progress of building the coloured monodisperse microspheres

Monodisperse microsphere is a kind of new polymer material with single particle size from micron to nanometer. Because of its outstanding properties, such as tiny particle size and huge specific surface area, it can be used as micro-separator, micro-storage, micro-reactor, micro-structural units, etc., and has been widely used in the fields of storage, life science, catalyst, pharmaceutical science and so on. In recent years, it has become a research hotspot for domestic and foreign scholars. Colored monodisperse microspheres have both the monodisperse property of microspheres and the color degree of dyes or fluorescent substances, which greatly improves the contrast of microspheres and thus increases their sensitivity in detection. In this paper, the methods of preparing monodisperse microspheres and color microspheres in various literatures currently are reviewed. Focusing on several representative techniques, the ideas, benefits, and drawbacks of many sample approaches are discussed in detail, the similarities and differences of various methods are compared, and the deficiencies in this field are analyzed, and their development prospects are discussed.