Reviewed by: The South’s Forgotten Fire-Eater: David Hubbard and North Alabama’s Long Road to Disunion by Chris McIlwain William L. Barney The South’s Forgotten Fire-Eater: David Hubbard and North Alabama’s Long Road to Disunion. By Chris McIlwain. Montgomery: NewSouth Books, 2020. 288 pp. $27.95. ISBN 978-1-5883-8411-9. The South’s Forgotten Fire-Eater ably fulfills its goal of using the life of David Hubbard as a window into studying “the troubled birth of Alabama, its intermittent economic development, and its lengthy radicalization process” (ix). In doing so, it offers much to the student of Alabama history, especially in its treatment of the often neglected pre-1850 period dominated by issues related to banking and boom and bust economic cycles. It is less successful in adding to our understanding of secession sentiment in North Alabama. Born in Virginia in 1792, Hubbard emigrated to Tennessee with his family and there joined militia forces under Andrew Jackson. A wound he suffered in the battle of New Orleans was a valuable asset when he settled in North Alabama after the War of 1812 and plunged into the pursuits that consumed him until his world came crashing down in the Civil War – land speculation, politics, and populist appeals to non-slaveholders that combined a fervid defense of slavery with attacks on haughty aristocrats. Beginning with the uproar over nullification in the early 1830s, he never missed an opportunity to stake out an increasingly radical stance on behalf of southern rights. Hubbard was the driving force behind the building of the Tuscumbia, Courtland, and Decatur Railroad in North Alabama, the first railroad west of the Allegheny Mountains. Like other internal improvements funded by the legislature when times were flush, the railroad was undercapitalized and fell into chronic debt when credit markets collapsed in the next financial panic. The same was true of [End Page 176] Hubbard’s efforts to strike it rich by speculating in Native American land acquired by whites in a series of questionable, if not fraudulent, treaties. Working through surrogates in the legislature, he was able to stay one step ahead of his creditors and establish himself as a cotton planter with an enslaved work force. Positioning himself as a Calhoun Democrat, he served in both houses of the Alabama legislature and twice was elected as a congressman. Always tailoring his stand on state and national economic issues to best protect his precarious financial entanglements, he was viewed as too much of an economic maverick by the state’s planter elite to be included in their inner circle. Few of Hubbard’s personal papers have survived, and McIlwain had to rely mainly on legislative debates and newspaper accounts to piece together Hubbard’s life story. This results in extremely detailed descriptions of legislative maneuverings and overly long quotations that at times slowed the narrative down to a crawl. Another consequence was the gap between Hubbard’s economic activities and his political radicalism on sectional issues. Just what meaning and identity Hubbard found in assuming the role of the fire-eater is never systematically analyzed. Was it political opportunism, an attempt to link his public stand with the ambitions of other slaveholders who had enough wealth and power to want more and hence demanded no checks on the South’s quest to carve out limitless opportunities for the expansion and prosperity of slavery? This is a question that McIlwain leaves unanswered and perhaps could not answer. What is clear is that Hubbard, like countless other fire-eaters, agitated in relative obscurity compared to a William Lowndes Yancey, who could rely on his spell-binding oratory to gain a following, or a Robert Barnwell Rhett, who had a public platform for his views in the Charleston Mercury. For all his railing against the exclusion of Kansas as a slave state and proclaiming the South’s destiny to expand slavery to the tropics, Hubbard operated most effectively in the shadows as he prodded the legislature to stake out the most radical stance against alleged northern aggressions. [End Page 177] Whether, as suggested by McIlwain on several occasions, Hubbard served as a mentor to the post-nullification...
Read full abstract