We were greatly interested in the article by Dhiman et al (1) discussing their experience with neuro-ophthalmology in a central government–funded tertiary eye care hospital in North India. We wish to share our experience from a private nongovernmental organization (NGO) tertiary eye care hospital in South India. Our hospital offers services to patients in 3 tiers as per their choice: (1) paying section (where patient pays for the services); (2) free direct section (where consultation is free and the surgeries are steeply subsidized); (3) camp section (where consultation and surgeries [mainly cataract] are free). In our retrospective analysis from January 2017 to December 2017, there were 143, 946 referrals to various specialty clinics, of which 9,238 (6.4%) were referred for neuro-ophthalmic evaluation. Of these, 7,387 patients were referred from paying hospitals and 1851 were referred from free direct and camp sections. For our analysis, we included only the paying section referrals, of which 1851 patients (25%) were excluded as they turned out to be non–neuro-ophthalmic cases, compared to 16% in the study by Dhiman et al. Thus, our patient cohort comprised 5,402 patients. We compared our results with those of Dhiman et al. Optic nerve disorders were seen in 64.6% (n = 3,511) of our patients compared to 63.8% (n = 1,020) in their study. We saw 84.6% (n = 2,971) of optic nerve disorders without disc edema and 15.4% (n = 540) with disc edema compared to 67% (n = 635) and 33% (n = 335), respectively, in their study. The most common optic nerve disorder without disc edema was traumatic optic neuropathy seen in 13% (n = 383) compared to 27.7% (n = 190) in their study. In the optic disc edema group, ischemic optic neuropathy was present in 34.4% (n = 186) of cases compared to 37.6% (n = 126) in their study. Papilledema was seen in 23% (n = 124) compared to 23.2% (n = 78) in their study. The most common cranial nerve palsy occurred with the sixth nerve in 44.3% (n = 314), followed by third nerve in 26% (n = 184), fourth nerve in 11.3% (n = 80), and seventh nerve in 18.4% (n = 130). Dhiman et al reported involvement of sixth, third, fourth, and seventh nerves with frequencies of 44%, 21.9%, 20.1%, and 14%, respectively. Our comparative analysis demonstrated that the occurrence of neuro-ophthalmic diseases in 2 diverse tertiary care centers in North India (central government funded) and South India (NGO) is quite similar. We strongly agree with Dhiman et al that in a vast country like ours, with a population of over a billion people, more subspecialty-trained neuro-ophthalmologists are needed.
Read full abstract