To the Editor The implications of the recent article by Frank et al.1 are that erythrocyte storage time is associated with decreased cell membrane deformability and that this change might impede capillary transit of red blood cells and, thereby, tissue oxygenation. Thus, the longer the storage time toward the 6 weeks standard before the blood is discarded, the poorer tissue oxygenation will be. In 2008, we published an article2 demonstrating that the oxygen transport rate from the hemoglobin molecule through the cell membrane to the tissues appears to be unique for each individual tested and that the oxygen transport rate increases during storage (1.72-fold over 8 weeks, 95% confidence interval 1.5–1.95). Thus, the longer the storage time toward the 6 weeks standard before the blood is discarded, the better tissue oxygenation will be. Although on the surface these 2 hypotheses appear to conflict with one another, there are differences between the 2 studies that might explain this conflict. We assessed stored blood outside the context of the capillary, whereas the Frank et al.1 article dealt with red blood cell deformability taking place in the context of the capillary. In other words, the 2 groups addressed completely different variables that contribute to tissue oxygenation capacity of stored blood, the results of which point to all the physical traits of stored blood that must be measured to understand the most important issue of outcomes. Furthermore, though both articles are correct, the contribution of either effect may be outweighed by other characteristics of stored blood, for example, the nitric oxide scavenging effects. The bottom line of these apparently conflicting studies is that more research needs to be done studying blood storage and the selection of red blood cell units for transfusion. Henry Buchwald, MD, PhD Hector J. Menchaca, MD Department of Surgery University of Minnesota Minneapolis, Minnesota [email protected]
Read full abstract