Clinical algorithms are utilized in clinical decision-making — whether for diagnosis or treatment — with the aim of accounting for pertinent biological factors. However, the use of race in some clinical algorithms disproportionately harms patients of color, often delaying necessary care. The erroneous use of race as a biological variable perpetuates the antiquated notion of race essentialism and demonstrates how medical racism is embedded in health care. In 2021, the New York City (NYC) Department of Health and Mental Hygiene launched the Coalition to End Racism in Clinical Algorithms (CERCA). To the authors’ knowledge, CERCA was the first citywide effort to convene seven safety-net and four private health care systems for the elimination of harmful race-based clinical algorithms, representing the health institutions in NYC serving the most patients. Focusing on estimated glomerular filtration rate, vaginal birth after cesarean, and pulmonary function testing, CERCA serves as a platform for health systems to discuss and strategize how to effectively de-implement these harmful race-based algorithms. NYC CERCA serves as a model for how a public health department can leverage its role as a convener by collaborating with health systems to address matters of racial inequities caused by systemic racism in medicine and supporting the swift implementation of reparative initiatives on a systems level.
Read full abstract