Electrospray Stability Research Articles

Investigating the Chemical Stability of Electrospray Plumes During Particle Collisions

Electrospray thrusters fulfill the main propulsion requirements for long-term small-satellite missions. However, the molecules present in the plume are susceptible to collisions, chemical reactions, and fragmentation, which may introduce different new species with various mass-to-charge ratios inside the plume. Prediction of the byproducts that appear upon collisions is of prime importance to predicting the evolution of the plume and estimating the performance and the lifetime expectancy of the thruster. In this work, we use molecular dynamics simulations to investigate monomer–neutral collisions at different impact configurations, impact energies, and impact parameters, and we provide the mass spectra of the resulting species. We predict that 1) collisions within a center-of-mass distance of 6 Å can result in momentum exchange and molecular fragmentation, 2) higher-energy impacts produce more byproducts, and 3) heavy molecules (e.g., 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium [EMI] and BF4) are more likely to result from weak collisions (<30 eV), whereas light molecules (e.g., H, F, and CH3) are more likely to result from strong collisions. Collisional fragmentation is shown to negatively affect key performance indicators, including reductions in thrust, specific impulse, and propulsive efficiency. This phenomenon potentially accounts for the observed discrepancies in experimental measurements of current and mass loss rates.

Supercritical Fluid Nanospray Mass Spectrometry.

Supercritical fluids are typically electrosprayed using an organic solvent makeup flow to facilitate continuous electrical connection and enhancement of electrospray stability. This results in sample dilution, loss in sensitivity, and potential phase separation. Premixing the supercritical fluid with organic solvent has shown substantial benefits to electrospray efficiency and increased analyte charge state. Presented here is a nanospray mass spectrometry system for supercritical fluids (nSF-MS). This split flow system used small i.d. capillaries, heated interface, inline frit, and submicron emitter tips to electrospray quaternary alkyl amines solvated in supercritical CO2 with a 10% methanol modifier. Analyte signal response was evaluated as a function of total system flow rate (0.5-1.5 mL/min) that is split to nanospray a supercritical fluid with linear flow rates between 0.07 and 0.42 cm/sec and pressure ranges (15-25 MPa). The nSF system showed mass-sensitive detection based on increased signal intensity for increasing capillary i.d. and analyte injection volume. These effects indicate efficient solvent evaporation for the analysis of quaternary amines. Carrier additives generally decreased signal intensity. Comparison of the nSF-MS system to the conventional SF makeup flow ESI showed 10-fold signal intensity enhancement across all the capillary i.d.s. The nSF-MS system likely achieves rapid solvent evaporation of the SF at the emitter point. The developed system combined the benefits of the nanoemitters, sCO2, and the low modifier percentage which gave rise to enhancement in MS detection sensitivity.

Evaluation of Prototype CE-MS Interfaces.

Capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry (CE-MS) coupling is a powerful analytical solution bringing together the separation power of CE and the wealth of chemical information afforded by MS. Nevertheless, interfaces making the hyphenation of both techniques possible have always been the subject of a quest for improvement by their users in search for more sensitive and robust setups. This fact has led to numerous technical developments and new interface designs claiming to outrival existing approaches in different aspects. Nevertheless, the task of evaluating and comparing a new interface to previous solutions is not always straightforward. Issued from our own experience in the field, we herein propose a protocol to optimize the operation parameters of a new CE-MS interface design, assess its analytical performance, and compare it to a reference interface if desired. Electrospray stability, sensitivity, reproducibility, and robustness are practically evaluated as key elements of the process.

LC-MS/MS characterisation and determination of dansyl chloride derivatised glyphosate, aminomethylphosphonic acid (AMPA), and glufosinate in foods of plant and animal origin

Glyphosate and other polar and acidic pesticides have been particularly studied due to the concerns over widespread and intensive use. The chemical properties of these compounds necessitate use of customised methods, such as derivatisation or ion exchange chromatography. These approaches present a compatibility problem with ESI-MS due to presence of salts and non-volatile compounds. For that reason, a simple procedure has been developed for the extraction, pre-column derivatisation with dansyl chloride (5-(dimethylamino)naphthalene-1-sulfonyl chloride), and mass spectrometric detection of glyphosate, AMPA, and glufosinate after the separation on a C18stationary phase. The dansyl derivatives were characterised with ESI-MS and their separation from derivatisation reagent byproducts was demonstrated with UV absorption detection. Reagent byproducts eluted before the analytes and were separated from the analytes completely, thus the proposed procedure did not contaminate the mass spectrometers. The proposed procedure was evaluated with respect to the matrix effects and extraction efficiency, and was validated with different mass spectrometers for milk, cucumber, honey, porridge formula, bovine kidney and liver matrix. The LOQ was 10 μg kg−1 for AMPA and glufosinate, and 10–25 μg kg−1for glyphosate, depending on matrix. Measurement uncertainties ranged from 4 to 44%. Method performance was compared to the QuPPe (Quick Polar Pesticides) procedure in combination with a diethylamino-based column from Waters™. In the case of Orbitrap™ detection, the proposed procedure had a comparable performance to the QuPPe procedure. Although, improved peak shape, higher absolute peak intensity, and lower standard deviation of the calibration curve slope was observed with the proposed procedure. This could be explained by the superior electrospray stability and lower extent of ion suppression.

Aperture-controllable nano-electrospray emitter and its application in cardiac proteome analysis

The emitter clogging is the most common hardware failure of nano-electrospray ionization, to improve the durability and electrospray stability of fused silica emitters, we demonstrate a means of fabricating nano-electrospray emitters with controllable aperture size and gradually-narrowed channel on the tip. We simulated the fluid morphologies in the emitter channels by computational fluid dynamics and found more stable flow on aperture-controllable nano-electrospray emitter. Besides, we found the unstable flow sections of commercial emitters match the actual clogging sections very well, indicating the main cause of emitter clogging is unstable flow. We further tested the emitters by nano-LC-MS based proteome analysis. Compared with the commercial emitter, aperture-controllable nano-electrospray emitters promoted the total ion chromatogram intensity by 25%, the number of identified proteins by 6.58%, and the number of identified peptides by 7.87%. In total, 989 proteins were identified from 1 μg of extracted mouse cardiac proteins. After the optimization by using mouse samples, we analyzed clinical auricular dextral tissues from patients undergoing cardiac surgery and found 16 proteins related to atrial fibrillation. Overall, aperture-controllable nano-electrospray emitter exhibits better sensitivity and reproducibility in the application of nano-LC-MS cardiac proteome analysis.

Improvement of electrospray stability in negative ion mode for nano-PGC-LC-MS glycoanalysis via post-column make-up flow.

Analysis of glycans via a porous graphitized carbon liquid chromatography (PGC-LC) coupled with electrospray ionization (tandem) mass spectrometry (ESI-MS(/MS)) is a powerful analytical method in the field of glycomics. Isobaric glycan structures can be identified reliably with the help of PGC-LC separation and subsequent identification by ESI-MS(/MS) in negative ion mode. In an effort to adapt PGC-LC-ESI-MS(/MS) to the nano-scale operation, spray instability along the nano-PGC-LC gradient was repeatedly observed on an LTQ Orbitrap Elite mass spectrometer equipped with a standard nano-electrospray ionization source. A stable electrospray was achieved with the implementation of a post-column make-up flow (PCMF). Thereby, acetonitrile was used to supplement the eluate from the nano-PGC-LC column. The improved spray stability enhanced detection and resolution of glycans during the analysis. This was in particular the case for smaller O-glycans which elute early in the high aqueous content regime of the nano-PGC-LC elution gradient. This study introduces PCMF as an easy-to-use instrumental adaptation to significantly improve spray stability in negative ion mode nano-PGC-LC-ESI-MS(/MS)-based analysis of glycans.

Investigation of electrospray stability with a dynamic liquid flow splitter

The article gives the results of research of electrospray stability with the use of a dynamic splitting of a flow in the spray area under normal conditions. An acidified water-acetonitrile solution (1: 1) was used as an eluant. Experimental results for the used configuration of electrospray junction with a coaxial selection of fluid excess as a steam-gas mixture taken out of the dispersion area (meniscus fluid on the butt-end of a capillary) in the compass of a fluid flow along the capillary from 50 up to 200 μL/min showed more stable relation of an atomized solution flow in comparison with a mode without use of a dynamic splitting of an atomized fluid flow.

Analyses of sulfonamide antibiotics in meat samples by on-line concentration capillary electrochromatography–mass spectrometry

In this work, a series of poly(divinylbenzene-alkyl methacrylate) monolithic stationary phases, which were prepared by single step in situ polymerization of divinylbenzene and various alkyl methacrylates (butyl-, octyl-, lauryl- or stearyl methacrylate), were developed as separation columns of nine common sulfonamide antibiotics for capillary electrochromatography (CEC) coupled to mass spectrometry (MS). Results indicated that the sulfonamide's retention became weak with increased carbon chain length of alkyl methacrylate monomer (for example, t R = 68 min and 21 min for butyl- and lauryl methacrylate, respectively). Among them, the poly(divinylbenzene-octyl methacrylate) (poly(DVB-OMA)) monolith was regarded as the optimal separation column as this provided better resolution within the shortest retention time. Moreover, the cross-sectional roughness of the monolithic column-end, that was used to couple to the ESI interface, strongly influenced the electrospray stability in the CEC–MS. Before the column was connected to the ESI-MS, a simple polishing was done to reduce the roughness of the column end that resulted to a great improvement in the signal stability. The relative standard deviations (RSDs) of the peak areas for the unpolished and polished ends of the poly(DVB-OMA) columns ( n = 5) were in the range of 46.1–60.2% and 8.9–16.4%, respectively. Furthermore, optimization of the mobile phase composition and the gradient elution strategy successfully determined the sulfonamide antibiotics in meat samples with as low as 10 μg/L level.

Advantages of using a modified orthogonal sampling configuration originally designed for LC–ESI-MS to couple CE and MS for the determination of antioxidant phenolic compounds found in virgin olive oil

A ThermoFinnigan sheath liquid flow capillary electrophoresis–mass spectrometry system designed for coupling via a co-axial interface was coupled through an adapted via an alternative, commercially available interface for orthogonal sampling. The affordable, reversible structural alterations made in the commercial LC–MS interface resulted in improved analytical performance. The results of a conventional capillary electrophoresis (CE) method using a commercial co-axial source to determine antioxidant phenolic acids present in virgin olive oil, were compared with those obtained by using a modified orthogonal sampling position. In both cases, separations were done using a 10 mM ammonium acetate/ammonium hydroxide buffer solution at pH 10.0 and a constant applied voltage of 25 kV. The operating variables for the mass spectrometry interface were re-optimized for the modified orthogonal orientation. This allowed the sheath liquid, sheath gas flow rates and capillary voltage to be lowered with respect to the co-axial coupling configuration. In addition, the orthogonal sampling position provided a higher selectivity by effect of ion sampling excluding larger droplets—with an increased momentum along the axis—which were drained through the sink at the bottom of the ion source. Also, the new configuration facilitated sample ionization, improved electrospray stability and led to stronger signals as a result. The new system was validated in terms of precision (repeatability), linearity, and limits of detection and quantification. A comparison of the validation data with the results previously obtained by using a commercial co-axial configuration revealed the adapted orthogonal sampling position to provide better repeatability in both migration times and relative peak areas (<1% and 7% respectively with n = 15 replicates), a good linear range (with levels in the microgram-per-litre region) and lower limits of detection—especially for the compounds detected with the lowest sensitivity when co-axial ESI was used, as HFA, GEN, FER and VAN finding LOD among 24–3.0 μg L −1 respectively.

Parameters affecting electrospray performance of hot-embossed open-channel polymer microfluidic chips

We investigate the effect of chip tip-to-counter electrode spacing (gap), channel-size aspect ratio, onset voltage on electrospray ionization (ESI) performance of embossed polymer microfluidic chips. Planar polymer substrates were hot embossed using an electroformed tool and a laser machined tool. The embossed microchips were tested for successful ESI demonstration with minimum sample consumption and high throughput. Factors influencing the stability of electrospray were analyzed by a series of experiments. Theoretically and experimentally, it was observed that the distance of the microchannel tip to the counter electrode directly relates to the onset voltage applied. Furthermore, the overall pattern observed is the decrease in Taylor cone size with a decrease in channel dimensions. The total ion current was analyzed as a function of time and onset voltage at various gaps. Five electrospray modes, namely, drop mode, pulse mode, Taylor-cone jet mode, multijet mode, and oscillating jet mode recorded at the open channel tips were identified and the electrospray cycle investigated. These results are in good accordance with theory, and comparisons are drawn with the findings of other researchers.

Microstructured Photonic Fibers as Multichannel Electrospray Emitters

Novel multichannel electrospray emitters are presented that use silica-based microstructured fibers (MSFs) to split the flow allowing efficient desolvation during electrospray. The MSFs investigated in this study possess 30-168 individual fluidic channels (each channel being 5 microm in diameter) that form a 2D emitting array. Multiple flow paths afford stable electrospray at flow rates ranging from the microspray (e.g., 1000 nL/min) to the nanoelectrospray (e.g., 10 nL/min) regime with moderate to negligible flow-induced backpressures. The electrospray stability of highly aqueous solutions (up to 99.9% water with 0.1% acetic acid) is enhanced through modification of the emitting surface with a hydrophobic silylation reagent (chlorotrimethylsilane). Furthermore, by successfully spraying highly concentrated salt solutions, this study demonstrates that multichannel MSF emitters provide enhanced robustness to clogging, leading to increased operational throughput.

Optimization of a pressurized liquid junction nanoelectrospray interface between CE and MS for reliable proteomic analysis

A pressurized liquid junction nanoelectrospray interface was designed and optimized for reliable on-line CE-MS coupling. The system was constructed as an integrated device for highly sensitive and selective analyses of proteins and peptides with the separation and spray capillaries fixed in a pressurized spray liquid reservoir equipped with the electrode for connection of the electrospray potential. The electrode chamber on the injection side of the separation capillary and the spray liquid reservoir were pneumatically connected by a Teflon tube filled with pressurized nitrogen. This arrangement provided precisely counterbalanced pressures at the inlet and outlet of the separation capillary. The pressure control system was driven by an electrically operated valve and maintained the optimum flow rate for the electrospray stability. All parts of the interface being in contact with the CEBGE, spray liquid and/or sample were made of glass or Teflon. The use of these materials minimized the electrospray chemical noise often caused by plastic softeners or material degradation. During optimization, the transfer of the separated zones between the separation and electrospray capillaries was monitored by UV absorbance and contactless conductivity detectors placed at the outlet of the separation capillary and inlet of the electrospray tip, respectively. This arrangement allowed independent monitoring of the effects of pressure, CE voltage and geometry of the liquid junction on the spreading and dilution of the separated zones after passage through the interface.

Open‐tubular capillary electrochromatography‐mass spectrometry with sheathless nanoflow electrospray ionization for analysis of amino acids and peptides

A novel, rugged sheathless capillary electrochromatography-electrospray ionization (CEC-ESI) device, in which an open-tubular separation capillary and an electrospray tip are integrated with a Nafion tubing junction, is coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) for the analysis of amino acids and peptides. A stable electrospray was generated at nanoflow rates by applying a positive electrical potential at the Nafion membrane junction. To sustain the stable spray, an electroosmotic flow (EOF) to the spray was supported by coating the fused silica capillary with Lupamin, a high-molecular-weight linear positively charged polyvinylamine (PVAm) polymer, which also minimizes analyte adsorption. Electrochromatographic separation of amino acids and peptides was further enhanced by the chromatographic selectivity of Lupamin stationary phase for these molecules. The device was very reliable and reproducible for CEC-ESI-MS analyses of amino acids and peptides for over a hundred injections. The separation and detection behaviors of amino acids and peptides under different conditions including pH, concentration, and composition of mobile phases on Lupamin-coated and uncoated capillaries have been investigated. The relationship between nano electrospray stability and EOF is discussed.

Sample pretreatment on a microchip with an integrated electrospray emitter

This study presents a microbead-packed PDMS microchip with an integrated electrospray emitter for sample pretreatment prior to sheathless ESI-MS. We prove the concept of analytical functions integrated onto a cm-sized area of a single bulk material. The microchip consists of two PDMS substrates replicated from SU-8 fabricated silicon wafer masters, bonded together after oxidation by corona discharge treatment. The channel within the microchip contains a grid structure that was used to trap 5 microm hypercross-linked polystyrene beads. The beads acted as a medium for sample desalting and enrichment. Electrical contact for the sheathless ESI process was achieved by coating the integrated emitter with conductive graphite powder after applying a thin layer of PDMS as glue. The coating as well as the bond of the PDMS structures showed excellent durability. A continuous spray was obtained from the microchip for over 800 h in a long-term electrospray stability experiment. Desalting and enrichment of neuropeptides from a physiological salt solution was successful by loading the sample onto the packed beads, followed by a washing and an eluting step. The results were obtained and evaluated using a TOF MS. An LOD of approximately 20 fmol (loaded onto the beads) for angiotensin II was obtained from a sample of neuropeptides dissolved in physiological salt solution.

Fabrication of Internally Tapered Capillaries for Capillary Electrochromatography Electrospray Ionization Mass Spectrometry

In this study, we report a novel procedure for fabricating internally tapered capillary columns suitable for the coupling of capillary electrochromatography (CEC) to electrospray mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). The internal tapers were prepared by slowly heating the capillary end in a methane/O2 flame. Due to continuous self-shrinking of the inner channel of the capillary, the inside diameter of the opening was reduced to 7-10 microm. The procedure is easy to handle, with no requirement for expensive equipment as well as elimination of problematic grinding of the tip. Several advantages of these new internal tapers, as compared to using externally tapered columns, are described. First, the problems of poor durability and tip breakage associated with external tapering were successfully overcome with the internal taper. A comparison of the online CEC/ESI-MS between external versus internal tapers showed that the latter provides enhanced electrospray stability, resulting in significantly lower short-term noise and very short-term noise values. In turn, the more rugged design of internal tapers allows performing CEC/MS utilizing a harsh polar organic mobile phase, which was not previously successful using an external taper due to higher operating current and electrospray arcing. Next, data on the reproducibility of the internally tapered CEC/MS column using warfarin and beta-blockers as model analytes are presented. For example, when comparing the reproducibility for separation of warfarin under reversed-phase conditions, the internal taper demonstrated superior intraday % RSD (1.6-3.4) as compared to the external taper intraday % RSD (5-6). Last, the applicability of performing quantitative CEC/MS with internally tapered capillaries is demonstrated for simultaneous enantioseparation of beta-blockers. Impressive quantitative results include good linearity of calibration curves (e.g., R2 = 0.9940-0.9988) and limit of detection as low as 30 nM. The sensitive detection of a minor impurity of one enantiomer at the 0.1% level in a major chiral entity buttresses the suitability of compliance with FDA guidelines.

Capillary electrophoresis‐mass spectrometry: Recent advances to the analysis of small achiral and chiral solutes

We describe here the state-of-the-art development of on-line capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry (CE-MS) over the last two years. Technological developments included are novel designs of new interfaces and ionization sources, new capillary coatings, buffers, and micelles as well as application of various modes of CE-MS published in the recent literature. The areas of CE-MS application in analysis of small achiral and chiral solutes are covered in sections that highlight the recent advances and possibilities of each mode of CE-MS. Application areas reviewed in this paper include achiral and chiral pharmaceuticals, agrochemicals, carbohydrates, and small peptides. The separation of enantiomers using micellar electrokinetic chromatography (MEKC)-MS with molecular micelles and capillary electrochromatography (CEC)-MS using pack tapered columns appears to provide good tolerance to electrospray stability for routine on-line CE-MS. These two modes seem to be very suitable for sensitive detection of chiral pharmaceuticals in biological samples, but their use will probably increase in the near future. Overall, it seems that one mode of CE-MS, in particular capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE)-MS, is now recognized as established technique for analysis of small charged solutes, but other modes, such as MEKC-MS and CEC-MS, are still within a period of development in terms of both MS-compatible pseudostationary phases and columns as well as applications.

Quantitative mass spectrometric determination of methylphenidate concentration in urine using an electrospray ionization source integrated with a polymer microchip.

We have demonstrated the use of a simple microfabricated electrospray ionization source for coupling microfluidic chips to mass spectrometry (MS). A polymer-based microchip, coupled to a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer, has been employed for direct infusion quantitative bioanalysis of methylphenidate (Ritalin) extracted from human urine samples. The approach used a microfabricated polymer electrospray emitter to couple a microfluidic channel to a stable electrospray ionization source. The microchip was fabricated from cycloolefin plastic plate by hot embossing and thermal bonding. This microfluidic chip contained two independent microfluidic channels, integrated with two corresponding electrospray emitters and an internal gold electrode. Liquid-liquid extraction was used to prepare urine samples, spiked with methylphenidate. A trideuterated analogue of methylphenidate (methylphenidate-d(3)) was used as the internal standard for the analysis. The system showed good electrospray stability and reproducibility with different spray tips. Four different electrospray tips were used to analyze the same sample, and the results showed very small variation with a relative standard deviation of 1.4%. A standard curve prepared for methylphenidate in urine (R(2) = 0.999) was linear over the range of 0.4-800 ng/mL. The precision of the quality control samples for three different concentrations ranged from 19.1% at 20 ng/mL, 3.2% at 200 ng/mL, to 3.5% at 667 ng/mL while the accuracy was 96.3% at 20 ng/mL, 101.2% at 200 ng/mL, and 101.6% at 667 ng/mL. No system carryover was detected even when the same device was used for sequential analysis. These results suggest the potential of this microdevice for MS-based quantitative analysis in drug discovery and development.

Optimization of capillary electrophoresis conditions for coupling to a mass spectrometer via a sheathless interface.

When optimizing a capillary electrophoresis/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (CE/ESI-MS) system, consideration has to be given not only to the separation but also to the electrospray stability. Methods developed for CE/UV analysis of drugs and peptides were considered and modified to be suitable for a CE/MS system with a robust sheathless interface. Different concentrations of the organic modifiers acetonitrile, methanol and 2-propanol were used in the separation buffer. The type and concentrations of these modifiers were also compared with reference to electrospray stability, sensitivity and time of analysis. In addition, different ionic strengths in the buffers were evaluated with reference to electrospray stability. The repeatability was used for the estimation of electrospray stability. The degree to which these parameters influenced the separation and the ESI stability was studied using a nine-peptide standard mixture and the antibiotic drugs bacampicillin and ampicillin as test substances. The analysis time and resolution were used as measures of the efficiency of the separation. A time-of-flight MS analyzer was used since it has the potential advantages of becoming a better fit for integration of CE with MS owing to the speed and sensitivity of this mass analyzer. The detection limit, i.e. 1 microM, for bacampicillin was comparable to what could be achieved with CE/MS on a quadrupole instrument using selected ion monitoring and sheath flow ESI.