ROELFS, A. P., and J. V. GROTH. 1980. A comparison of virulence phenotypes in wheat stem rust populations reproducing sexually and asexually. Phytopathology 70:855-862. The number and distribution of 16 loci expressing virulence were loci expressing virulence per isolate was about 6 and 10 for the sexual and compared in two populations of wheat stem rust in the USA. In 1975, asexual populations, respectively. The distribution of numbers of loci samples were collected from a population on barley and wheat in Idaho and expressing virulence differences between pairs of isolates was nearly Washington that undergoes sexual reproduction annually and from a random in the sexual population, while it was characterized by clusters of population east of the Rocky Mountains that reproduces asexually. phenotypes in the asexual population. These clusters differed from one Virulence was determined by inoculating 16 wheat lines, each differing by a another by 4 to 10 genes expressing virulence; genotypes within clusters single gene for stem rust resistance. The sexual population had a larger differed by 1 to 2 loci. None of the loci, examined in all of their paired frequency of distinct phenotypes expressed as a percentage. In the sexual combinations, deviated strongly from expected mean frequencies based on population, the frequency was 23.5% with 426 isolates and in the asexual products of individual locus frequencies, providing no evidence for strong population it was 0.07% with 2,377 isolates. Simpson's measure of diversity positive or negative fitness effects associated with individual genes. was 0.974 and 0.501 for the two populations, respectively. Mean number of Eradication of common barberry (Berberis vulgaris L.) from the model in 1971 (6). If certain conditions were met, the latter model wheat fields of the central Great Plains of North America was predicted two effects of sexual reproduction: first accelerated completed, for all practical purposes, by 1928. The effects of this evolutionary adaptation; and second more variable progeny, eradication on populations of stem rust of wheat (Puccinia resulting in production of some offspring of high fitness. The first graminis Pers. f. sp. tritici) have been the subject of much debate effect will occur if the population size, N, is about equal to or larger and speculation. One obvious effect noted was that the source of than 10 M-', where p is the mutation rate. The second effect required local, often early, epidemics of stem rust was eliminated (13). The frequent, large environmental fluctuations. Both of these claim (11) has been made that barberry eradication increased the conditions are met in stem rust. Populations are generally very average useful life of resistance genes in wheat (Triticum aestivum large, and the major component of the environment of the rust L.). Comparisons of this sort are confounded, however, by fungus-the host-changes frequently and dramatically, as differences in agronomic practices, the extent of monoculture, and compared with that of parasites in natural biota or with that of the wheat cultivars used before and after eradication. Thus, all nonparasites. Additionally, the physical environment changes as perceived differences in useful life of resistant cultivars cannot the season progresses and the pathogen spreads to new areas. necessarily be attributed to eradication of barberry and its Accelerated evolutionary adaptation is difficult or impossible to
Read full abstract