One of the major ways in which microcomputers may be used in education is in computer assisted instruction (CAI). However, effective CA1 is difficult to find. Although there are a large number of programs currently available, a school or a school district must surmount a number of difficulties if it wishes to implement a successful CA1 program. Some of these difficulties are: (1) There is a great amount of microcomputer software available. As of December 1982, it was conservatively estimated that 3000 software titles were available in Apple format alone. Moreover, this number is increasing rapidly. For example, in Ausust 1982 the Clearinghouse had identified 200 potential titles in mathematics. One year later that number had doubled. (2) There are a large number of companies involved in microcomputer software production. Unlike textbooks where the bulk of the market is controlled by a limited number of large companies, current software is produced mainly by small companies. There are over 200 companies producing microcomputer coarseware for Apple computers in math and science alone. I do not know the total number of companies producing for all subjects and for all microcomputers, but it is certain that the number of such companies is increasing dramatically. (3) In view of the large number of titles available and the large number of companies that would have to be contacted, schools have a major problem in trying to identify what software is available. While a number of journals have been established recently which attempt to list the available titles, they do not provide the service that the schools need. Generally speaking, their lists are not comprehensive, the descriptive data they provide is limited and evaluative data is almost always absent. In view of these limitations, schools find it very difficult just to get a list of what software might be available. (4) If schools/school districts can find out what is available, they then have to determine what will be useful. In the absence of objective, reliable evaluation information, they have to either trust the publishers’ description or acquire copies for preview. Here they will encounter major difficulties including companies which do not allow preview, companies which do not allow returns, companies which allow preview only upon submission of a deposit, and companies which only allow preview of a demo diskette which may or may not be representative of the quality of the entire diskette. In defence of the companies, such restrictions are not unusual in view of the high amount of piracy and the high cost of developing quality software. Nevertheless, schools face a very difficult time in acquiring preview copies. (5) Even if they can acquire copies for preview, the likelihood of finding a significant number of quality programs is quite small. It is generally accepted that the quality of educational courseware is quite poor at the present time. Our own figures would indicate that only 10% of the available materials are satisfactory for effective CAI. As a result, a large number of packages will have to be previewed before quality materials are found.
Read full abstract