A nondimensional ized structural optimization analysis that recognizes several design restraints is described for cylinders stiffened with stringers and/or rings of rectangular cross section and subjected to uniform axial compression in combination with either internal or external pressure. The lateral (pressure)-to-axial load ratio Ny/Nx is positive for external pressure and negative for internal pressure. Results are presented for Ny/Nx = 0.2, 0.5, 2.0, and —0.2, —0.5, —1.0 in Parts I and II of this paper, respectively, for L/R ratios of 0.25 and 1.5. Designs stiffened with both rings and stringers are lightest when Ny/Nx « 0, except for short cylinders where rings may not be required. With increasing positive Nv/Nx9s9 designs stiffened with stringers only are very inefficient, but designs stiffened with rings only become almost as light as those with both rings and stringers. The differences in the weights of the latter two configurations often are small at the higher Ny/Nx's. On the other hand, with increasing negative Ny/Nx's, designs stiffened only with rings are relatively inefficient, whereas those stiffened only with stringers rapidly become more efficient than ring and stringer designs. The effect of ring/stringer eccentricity upon weight is most important when Ny/Nx = 0; for large Ny/Nx values, either positive or negative, it has an insignificant effect. Inversions in stiffener eccentricity effects occur at Ny/Nx = +2 and —1.
Read full abstract