The objective of this study is to investigate changes in spermatogenesis as a consequence of the quantitative reduction in testosterone production and action and/or possible direct effects of estrogen on seminiferous epithelium. This unique patient population provides this unusual opportunity because of the high volume of individuals undergoing gender confirmation surgery. An IRB-approved retrospective review of 35 neovaginoplasty patients and 21 patients who underwent bilateral orchiectomy as a stand-alone procedure was conducted. Testicular histology of 56 patients (112 testicles) was examined by the investigators, and predominant patterns of spermatogenic disruption were defined. Presently, a prospective, IRB-approved analysis is being conducted on these same two patient populations to correlate testicular histology, intraoperative wet prep analysis to identify fully formed spermatozoa, medication type and dosage, and serum levels of Estradiol, Testosterone (T), Luteinizing hormone (LH), and Follicle Stimulating hormone (FSH) obtained immediately prior to surgery. This is in an effort to refine or define an explanation for the negative effect of these medications on spermatogenesis. Between January 2017 to September 2018, 35 transgender women underwent neovaginoplasty, and seminiferous tubule histology was retrospectively examined. In addition, in 2017, 21 patients underwent bilateral orchiectomy as a stand-alone procedure. Classification included complete absence of germ cells, spermatocytic maturation arrest (SMA), hypospermatogenesis (mild, moderate, and severe), and normal histology. As part of the early prospective cohort, 6 patients underwent bilateral orchiectomy, and 2 patients underwent neovaginoplasty. Intraoperative testicular wet prep findings were recorded as number of spermatozoa per high powered field. Retrospectively, of the 35 neovaginoplasty patients, the following histology was seen: 2 with complete absence of germ cells, 3 with mild hypospermatogenesis, 8 with SMA only, and the remaining with a combination of SMA with mild (4), moderate (5), and severe (11) hypospermatogenesis. Of the 21 orchiectomy patients, the following histology was seen: 4 with SMA only, and the remaining with a combination of SMA and mild (4), moderate (6), and severe (7) hypospermatogenesis. In our early prospective data set, 2 out of 8 patients had spermatozoa seen on intraoperative wet prep (T:70, E2:168 ; T:18, E2:120). Estrogen therapy and testosterone blockers (spironolactone) are routinely used in combination in MTF individuals to suppress testosterone and its androgenic effects while promoting welcome estrogenic bodily changes. The consequent reduction in spermatogenesis is quite variable, as clearly demonstrated by the unexpected results of the retrospective review—meiotic progression was uniformly impaired while a decrease in the total number of germ cells per tubule was not uncommon. We envision our nascent prospective study to allow us to formulate some mechanistic models of biological causality.
Read full abstract