Early modern diplomatic history has begun to emerge from the shadow of Garrett Mattingly’s seminal Renaissance Diplomacy. Several collections of essays and special editions of journals have begun to question a once-familiar chronological framework and to bring the insights of cultural historians to a field that was once conceived of as high political history (see, for example, Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies, xxxviii/1 [2008], Journal of Early Modern History, xiv/6 [2010], D. Frigo, ed., Diplomacy and Politics in Early Modern Italy: The Structure of Diplomatic Practice, 1450–1700 [2000]). This present volume, edited by Robyn Adams and Rosanna Cox, which professes to be part of this reassessment, arises from a conference held at the University of Kent in 2008. Anyone who picks it up expecting a collection of essays exploring the role of diplomats as art agents and cultural consumers, or a discussion of the significance and complexity of diplomatic ceremonies, or the role of diplomacy in mediating cultural conceptions, will be disappointed. Few of the essays in this volume deal with such issues: in many, culture is more textual, rooted in correspondence, treatises, ciphers, and news, while the thread holding them together is intelligence—whether conceived of as news gathering, news networks, or espionage, albeit sometimes in diplomatic contexts. Consequently, the volume contains several valuable contributions which further our knowledge of an underexplored area, but it also neglects important fields that are essential for a cultural understanding of early modern diplomacy.
Read full abstract