Detection Of Gunshot Residue Research Articles

Effects of carbonization on gunshot residue detection in an animal model

The detection of gunshot residue (GSR) can be useful to determine if the wound has been caused by a firearm and it could help to differentiate the entry wound from the exit one. Carbonization is a good method for altering crime scenes. However, there are few studies in this specific context. The first objective of our study was to examine the persistence of GSR in wounds after carbonization. The second aim was to differentiate entry wounds from exit ones.For the experiment, bullets were fired with a 22LR on sheep limbs at contact range.The specimens were divided into four groups: two that weren't shot at (fresh and carbonized limbs) and two of shot limbs (one with carbonization and one without). Carbonization was performed in the open air using an accelerant.Wounds were analyzed using Scanning Electron Microscopy with Energy Dispersive X-ray spectrometry (SEM–EDX) and Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS).Lead, Antimony and Barium were observed using SEM-EDX only in the entry wounds, while lead was found in the exit ones. ICP-MS enabled the detection of these elements in the entry and exit wounds but predominantly in the entry ones. After carbonization we observed a huge decrease of GSR. With SEM-EDX most of the particles detected were only consistent with GSR. Anyway, the identification of GSR and the differentiation between entry and exit wounds were still possible with both techniques. Therefore, they are suitable for detecting GSR in carbonized gunshot wounds under the specific conditions of our experiment.

Detection of gunshot residue by flash-pulse and long-pulse infrared thermography

Detection of gunshot residues (GSR) in a bullet hole area is one of the forensic investigations aiding in the reconstruction of crime scenes. Traditionally, chromogenic methods based on chemical exposure or microscopic/spectroscopic methods are used for this purpose. In this study, we explore the applicability of active excitation infrared thermography methods for GSR detection in the bullet hole area on fabric samples. A standard 9 mm full metal jacket ammunition with a nickel-plated shell and natural cotton fabric samples were used for experiments in this study. The applicability of active thermography methods based on two different light/heat excitation sources to detect the GSR was investigated. Flash-pulse and long-pulse thermography were compared through an experimental investigation. We evaluated the effectiveness of various thermographic data processing methods, including background subtraction, temperature derivative analysis, Fourier transform phase analysis, principal component analysis, and higher-order statistics for GSR evaluation. Our findings demonstrate that flash-pulse thermography and kurtosis analysis yield the highest contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) and produce sharp, clear images of GSR, making it the optimal method for thermographic GSR detection. Our study indicates that even though the GSR particles are tiny, they can produce sufficient contrast to be detected by the thermographic methods if appropriate experimental and post-processing procedures are used. Thus, these methods could complement GSR detection as they are non-destructive and offer rapid inspection.

Detection of Gunshot Residue on Glass Fired using Airguns and Insas LMG 5.56mm

Detection of Gunshot Residue on Glass Fired using Airguns and Insas LMG 5.56mm

Point-and-shoot: portable Raman and SERS detection of organic gunshot residue analytes

Raman spectroscopy is one of many tools available to verify the molecular composition of an analyte. Due to its non-destructive nature and its ability to accurately discern differences in closely related molecular structures, it has become invaluable in many fields, including its potential for forensic gunshot residue detection. Firearm-related fatalities in the United States continue to rise and many of them remain unsolved. This necessitates tools that are better equipped to aid in the investigation of firearm-related crimes, capable of high-throughput analysis yet remaining sensitive to give accurate and valuable information. The comparative downside of Raman spectroscopy to neighboring techniques like mass spectrometry and nuclear magnetic resonance is its lower sensitivity. Surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy allows for the benefits of Raman spectroscopy alongside the added lower limit of detection with the simple application of nanoparticles, typically gold. Unfortunately, these benefits have seen little on-site application due to the difficulty of translating methods from conventional tabletop Raman spectrometers to point-and-shoot portable Raman spectrometers which have even lower sensitivities (higher limits of detection). Herein, we outline a versatile methodology for the detection of 6 organic gunshot residue components (diphenylamine (DPA), ethyl centralite (EC), 2,4-dinitrotoluene (2,4-DNT), 2-nitrodiphenylamine (2-nDPA), 4-nitrodiphenylamine (4-nDPA), and N-nitrosodiphenylamine (N-nDPA)) in liquid-phase that allows us to detect millimolar concentrations of these analytes. Furthermore, we report calculated vibrational assignments for these 6 analytes in solution, alongside detailed peak-by-peak analyses on a portable instrument. We showed signal enhancement and lower LODs through our data processing as well as a proof-of-concept SERS enhancement in a complex liquid-phase matrix, with an increased sensitivity of 700% when using SERS.

Exploring gunshot residue detection in fingerprints by functionalized particle-coupled matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry.

In firearm forensic investigations, detecting gunshot residue (GSR) is crucial for linking firearms to suspects and determining firing distance for forensic reconstruction. Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-ToF-MS) is emerging as a versatile and promising technological platform for fingerprint analysis. The capability of functionalized particles as an advanced dusting powder for visualizing latent fingerprints is widely recognized. This study aims to investigate the feasibility of employing functionalized magnetic fingerprint dusting powders for distinguishing regular and GSR fingerprints using MALDI-ToF-MS, thereby enhancing forensic evidentiary support. In this study, silica and carbon coated magnetic iron oxide particles were surface functionalized with phenyltriethoxy orthosilicate (PTEOS) or 3-aminopropyl triethoxysilane (APTES) to create hydrophobic and hydrophilic particles, respectively. Donor shooters' fingerprints, both GSR-containing and regular, were analyzed using these functionalized particles coupled with MALDI-ToF-MS. The results demonstrated effective fingerprint visualization and conclusive discrimination between GSR-containing and regular fingerprints through orthogonal partial least squares discriminant analysis. This technique provides enhanced sensitivity, speed, and adaptability compared to conventional methods, making it a promising choice for initial detection of GSR in latent fingerprints. Moreover, when subjected to thorough analysis using advanced instruments, it has the potential to significantly strengthen the probative value of fingerprint evidence in forensic investigations.

Assessment of gunshot residue detection on a large variety of surfaces by portable LIBS system for crime scene application

The application of Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) in forensic science has garnered increasing attention. The ability to perform real-time, on-site analysis of Gunshot Residue (GSR) particles and potential elements originating from bullets or projectile cores on various surfaces holds the potential to assist in resolving firearms-related cases. This includes facilitating trajectory determination by locating distinct impact points and identifying the types of ammunition used. This study evaluates the utilization of a portable LIBS device for ballistic forensic purposes. Additionally, it focuses on the assessment of potential false positives and false negatives arising from the different materials where the shots have been fired. Since the system performs laser ablation of both surface particles and the substrate, it emphasizes the importance of conducting preliminary screening in an area with the same composition as the impact zone to minimize potential false positives during direct surface analysis. Furthermore, the results demonstrate the capability to detect the constituent elements of characteristic gunshot residue particles (GSR particles): lead (Pb), antimony (Sb), and barium (Ba) adhering to bullets, as well as the principal elements composing the jacket or core of the projectile: lead (Pb), copper (Cu), and zinc (Zn) through direct analysis, without the need for a sampling kit, on different surfaces such as walls, furniture, or fabrics. Analyses conducted a month after the shots were fired indicate the potential for finding residues in the vicinity of the bullet hole. Analyses conducted a month after the shots were fired indicate the possibility of finding residues in the area around the bullet hole.

Methodological Features of Validating Forensic Expert Techniques

The article reviews and summarizes the experience of validating forensic expert techniques in the Russian Federal Centre of Forensic Science of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation. The authors point out the methodological features of practical implementation of the validation procedure. They demonstrate that the specificity, diversity, and complexity of the objects of expert study require the classification of the applied methods in terms of metrology, identification of the main validation parameters of quantitative and qualitative methods, organization of experiments, and evaluation of validation parameters using mathematical analysis methods. They also propose to divide methods into two types: forensic expert measurement methods (FMT) and forensic expert testing methods (FTT). Based on the generalization of information presented in several regulatory documents and scientific publications, the following parameters are identified for FMT: metrological characteristics or properties of the method (specificity, linearity, sensitivity, range of determined values, detection limit, quantitative determination limit) and quality indicators of the method (precision, correctness, accuracy of the analysis result, or uncertainty). When validating FTT, it is proposed to evaluate the reliability of the method and the competence of the expert.An experiment to assess validation parameters is performed using enough control samples with established characteristics of controlled indicators and with the participation of a sufficient number of experts. Requirements for control samples are provided.The authors also give examples of probabilistic evaluation of validation parameters for two qualitative testing methods: microscopic examination of textile fibers and detection of gunshot residue using scanning electron microscopy and X-ray microanalysis. The reliability of these methods is assessed by calculating the likelihood ratio, and the specificity of interpreting the results of FMT and FTT validation is noted.The decision on compliance with the requirements is made if the interval of the established extended uncertainty for the obtained result does not exceed the tolerance field. In the absence of tolerances, FMT is considered suitable for solving forensic expert tasks if the values of the extended uncertainty of the measurement results of the controlled indicator do not exceed the values established during validation. For FTT, a low probabilistic proportion of false positive and false negative results in determining the presence/absence of controlled indicators, as well as experimentally confirmed competence of the expert during validation, are indicators of the suitability of the method for its intended use

Surgical mask as an alternative sampling site for gunshot residue analysis

Gunshot residue (GSR) has been identified in the oro-nasal cavities and in various areas of the face. However, there is no study in the literature about the outcome of the analysis if the mouth and nose are covered with a mask. The purpose of this study is to experimentally ascertain whether GSR detection can be made on surgical masks. Twelve civilians wearing facemasks were divided into six groups of two, each consisting of a shooter and an accompanying person. A single shot was fired by the mask wearing shooters of all six groups in an outdoor and indoor shooting range. The inner surface, outer surface, and strap of the mask were the three areas where we investigated for the presence of GSR. GSR particle counts of the shooter were higher than those of accompanying person. Analysis after outdoor range shootings yielded fewer particles than indoor range shootings. The most particles were detected on the outer surface of the masks, and the least on the inner surface. All analyzes performed on the shooters' mask revealed significantly higher number of particles compared to accompanying persons. The results showed a significant difference in the quantity of GSR particles identified, which could aid in distinguishing between the shooter and the accompanying person. The outer surface of the mask has been determined to be the most useful sampling location in this regard, as it is the sample where the difference is most prominent.

Development of a Dimensional Analysis Approach in Gunshot Residue Images Using Computerized Image Processing

Computer image processing is a method that uses artificial intelligence and machine learning-based general learning algorithms. With this method, objects in digital images (photos or videos) can be grouped by being perceived and detected. Computerized image processing method can be applied to almost all kinds of digital data produced with the developing technology. Nowadays, the identification and detection of gunshot residues (GSR) can be done manually by experts from the acquired images. In this study, computerized image processing method was used for the identification and dimensional analysis of gunshot residues (GSR). In this new proposed method, a dataset of 18500 digital image samples obtained from three different caliber cartridges (MKE, Gecco and S&B brands) was used. From the results of the study, it has been shown that the Computer Vision Method is a successful method in the automatic dimensional classification of GSRs.

A pilot study on review of GSR with a case study

In all types of heinous crime cases like murder, homicides, assassinations, police encounter with criminal firearms are mostly involved which make important trace evidence as Gunshot residue (GSR), helps the investigating agency and forensic expert to solve and get a proper direction of investigations. Though this review article we tried to cover the how GSR form, composition and recent advancement in detection of GSR. This pilot study will provide a hand on single article to the reader with great interest of GSR and its value in forensic investigations. The review results are in the form of impact of GSR in crime solving possibility and very interesting case study also report.

Yttrium orthovanadates phosphors as up-conversion luminescent markers for gunshot residue identification

In this work, yttrium orthovanadate phosphors doped with Er3+ and Yb3+ (YVO4: Er3+, Yb3+) were synthetized by the combustion method. After a post-synthesis heat treatment (1100 °C for 6 h), samples were highly crystalline, with only the tetragonal zircon phase remaining. Additionally, all samples presented promising down and up conversion properties, exhibiting a strong green luminescence when excited by either UV or IR radiation. The up-conversion process involved the absorption of two-photons, with the intensity of the Er3+ transitions (2H11/2–4I15/2, 4S3/2–4I15/2 and 4F9/2–4I15/2) heightened with the Yb3+ content. The co-doped orthovanadate samples were introduced into 9 mm non-toxic ammunition (NTA) for evaluation as luminescent markers for gunshot residues (GSR). After shots with marked ammunition were fired, these phosphors enabled the visual detection of luminescent GSR (LGSR) on the shooter, firearm and firing place, facilitating an analysis of the simulated crime scene. These residues also presented a chemical signature that enabled their identification as LGSR. Besides, the down and up conversion properties observed in the residues provide an additional security feature for the unequivocal characterization of the LGSR.

A preliminary study on the treatment of human blood soiled stubs, in presence of GSR particles

In the investigation of gunshot deaths, Bloodstains Pattern Analysis (BPA) and, in particular, backspatter patterns found on the body of the suspect/victim and on the surfaces close to the entrance wound of the bullet can provide investigators with important indications on the dynamics of the events. Backspatter patterns have, however, morphological characteristics common to other bloodstains of different origin, so, in order to positively identify them, a possible solution is represented by their sampling, using an aluminum stub for electron microscopy, for the detection of gunshot residues (GSR) present. The latter, however, if present below the small blood crusts, could be difficult to detect during analysis by Scanning Electron Microscopy/Energy Dispersive X-ray microanalysis (SEM/EDX). In this preliminary study we propose the treatment of the stub surface with a solution based on sodium hypochlorite and calcium chloride, in order to remove/reduce the blood crusts present on the stub surface.

Surface Analysis Techniques in Forensic Science: Successes, Challenges, and Opportunities for Operational Deployment.

Surface analysis techniques have rapidly evolved in the last decade. Some of these are already routinely used in forensics, such as for the detection of gunshot residue or for glass analysis. Some surface analysis approaches are attractive for their portability to the crime scene. Others can be very helpful in forensic laboratories owing to their high spatial resolution, analyte coverage, speed, and specificity. Despite this, many proposed applications of the techniques have not yet led to operational deployment. Here, we explore the application of these techniques to the most important traces commonly found in forensic casework. We highlight where there is potential to add value and outline the progress that is needed to achieve operational deployment. We consider within the scope of this review surface mass spectrometry, surface spectroscopy, and surface X-ray spectrometry. We show how these tools show great promise for the analysis of fingerprints, hair, drugs, explosives, and microtraces.

Efficacy study of non-lanthanide small luminescent molecules as gunshot residue indicators

The efficiency of using small, non-lanthanide and readily available molecules was tested as luminescent markers for gunshot residue (GSR) analysis. Three luminophores, namely pyrene (Py), fluorescein (Fl) and a Pt-CNN complex (Pt-C) were used in the present study by using their 5 wt% additives to gunpowder filled in a cartridge followed by firing with a 9 mm pistol. The easy visualization of GSR location, collection of GSR samples followed by their identification through various characterization techniques and the possibility of strategically using these markers as a cost-effective alternative compared to any lanthanide material were evaluated through this work. The comparison of physical mixture of marker and gunpowder and surface soaked gunpowder with the same marker (Py) was also evaluated. Spectroscopic (Optical, Luminescence and Raman), Microscopic, Spectrometric (Mass) and thermal analysis (Differential Scanning Calorimetry, DSC) of the marker, gunpowder and GSR residues implies that both the dyes and gunpowder retains their individual properties and those are merely a physical mixture. Overall, the present study clearly demonstrates that these small organic/metal complex based luminophores are cost effective luminescent marker as compared to lanthanide materials for GSR detection / collection and can be strategically use to track the illegal / unauthorized use of gunpowder.

Preliminary Evaluation of Gunshot Residue (GSR) Using 3-Aminophenol as a Substitute in Modified Griess Test

In forensic ballistics, gunshot residue (GSR) particles can be detected using screening or presumptive tests which are mainly focused on the chromophoric reaction. Most tests serve as an initial indication for a forensic investigator at the crime scene before instrumental analysis for definitive identification. The screening methods are known to be convenient, have fast analysis, and minimal preparation. In GSR analysis, the well-known method of detecting GSR known as the Modified Griess Test (MGT) requires acid and heat for the reaction. Therefore, this study demonstrated a new and rapid screening test named the Rapid Griess Test (RGT) for the detection of GSR. This study intends to improve the functionality of previous screening reagents in determining nitrite (NO2–), the composition present after shooting activity. To do this, chemical reagents with an amino group, 3-aminophenol, were substituted with alpha-naphthol. The experiment showed that the reactions were positive color changes using standard NO2– and real GSR samples. The diazotization reactions involving sulfanilic acid and 3-aminophenol produced azo dyes that changed the solution from colorless to orange in the presence of NO2–. The RGT reagent will make it possible to avoid using heat and the addition of acetic acids in a sample to form chromophoric reactions. Moreover, the colorimetric method using Video Spectral Comparator (VSC) showed that RGT had higher intensity of the orange color when compared to MGT.

Finding GSR evidence on used towels

When a firearm is discharged, gunshot residue (GSR) is produced and may be deposited on a shooter’s body and his close vicinity. The tendency of GSR to drop off easily from the shooter may hinder forensic detection; this well-known phenomenon is accelerated by various common physical activities so that the number of particles detected on a suspect decreases over time. After shooting incidents, suspects will often try to cover their tracks by taking a shower. In these cases, it was assumed that no GSR will be detected upon examining the suspect's hand and hair. In the present study, we provide a way to overcome this loss of evidence by taking advantage of another occurrence, namely secondary transfer. Our participants were asked to take a shower after shooting a firearm. Samples were thereafter collected from the used bath towels and were found to contain up to a few dozen particles characteristic of GSR, including very large particles (>45 µm). The detection of GSR on a suspect's towel may provide significant forensic evidence aiding an investigation. When a shooter tries to remove evidence by taking a shower, sampling the towels that he may have used can preserve important evidence and connect a suspect to a shooting incident.

A Simple and Rapid Spectrophotometric Method for Nitrite Detection in Small Sample Volumes

A simple, rapid, and environmentally-friendly spectrophotometric method for nitrite detection was developed. Detection was based on a redox reaction with iodide ions in an acidic condition. The reaction was evaluated by detecting the increase in absorbance of the colored product of iodine at 362 nm wavelength. To obtain a good spectrophotometric performance, the iodide ions concentration, hydrochloric acid concentration, and reaction time were optimized. In the optimal condition, the developed spectrophotometric method provided a linear range of 0.0625 to 4.00 mg L−1 (r = 0.9985), reaction time for 10 min, a limit of detection of 25 µg L−1, and a limit of quantitation of 85 µg L−1. This method showed good repeatability (RSD < 9.21%), high sample throughput (9 samples min−1), and good accuracy (recovery = 88 ± 2 to 99.5 ± 0.4%). The method has the potential to be used in crime scene investigations as a rapid screening test for gunshot residue detection via nitrite detection.

Gunshot residue detection in stagnant water: SEM-EDX or ICP-MS? A preliminary study.

The identification of gunshot residue (GSR) on wounds enables the differentiation of entry and exit wounds. Unfortunately, studies analyzing GSR on degraded bodies have been poorly documented, and no data exist regarding GSR detection after stagnant water immersion. The aim of this preliminary experimental study was to detect GSR on wounds altered in stagnant water, using scanning electron microscopy coupled with energy-dispersive X (SEM-EDX) and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). Shots were performed on sheep limbs with a 22LR at a distance of 20cm. The limbs were then submerged in stagnant water and analyzed on days 0, 6, and 14. SEM-EDX was performed on previously dehydrated wounds. For ICP-MS analysis, the wounds were rubbed with a cotton swab that was then analyzed. In the SEM studies, a higher number of particles were detected in entry wounds compared to exit wounds under every set of experimental conditions. Unfortunately, SEM-EDX failed to detect GSR particles, even on day 0. ICP-MS enabled the detection of Pb, Sb, and Ba at every stage with higher quantities on entry than in exit. These elements remained detectable following limb immersion. ICP-MS enabled differentiate entry from exit wounds, even after immersion in stagnant water. Nevertheless, when manually swabbing the wounds, quantities of matter collected is highly variable. ICP-MS is a more suitable technique than SEM-EDX for GSR identification of wounds after decomposition in stagnant water; however, standardization is needed.

Trends in Gunshot Residue Detection by Electrochemical Methods for Forensic Purpose

Gunshot Residue (GSR) has been a subject of interest for the forensic fraternity. Numerous analytical contributions towards the GSR analysis have been reported. Sensitivity, portability, cost-effectiveness, speed, etc. are such factors of electrochemical methods that have attracted the researchers across the globe to test the applicability of these as a potential analytical tool for forensic evaluation of GSR. With the development of scientific technology, efforts have been made towards the hand-held device for the on-field analysis of GSR. Recently, chemometric treatment of data generated from the electrochemical analysis of GSR has offered more effective approach. It makes the analysis more conclusive and minimizes the chances of false-positive detection. It will be very fruitful to anticipate the analytical potential of electrochemical tools for GSR analysis. This article reviews the research progress towards the development of electrochemical sensor for GSR detection reported during 2013–2020 along with challenges and future perspectives.

Analysis of primer gunshot residue particles by laser induced breakdown spectroscopy and laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry.

This study reports novel approaches for the detection of gunshot residues (GSR) from the hands of individuals using Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) and Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS). The methods' performance was evaluated using 159 GSR standard and authentic samples. Forty specimens generated from characterized microparticles were used as matrix-matched primer gunshot residue (pGSR) standards to examine the elemental profiles of leaded and lead-free residues, compared to SEM-EDS and solution-ICP-MS. Also, 119 authentic skin samples were analyzed to estimate error rates. Shooter samples were correctly classified into three categories based on their elemental composition (leaded, lead-free, or mixed pGSR). A total of 60 non-shooter samples were used to establish background thresholds and estimate specificity (93.4% for LA-ICP-MS and 100% for LIBS). All the authentic leaded items resulted in the detection of particle(s) with composition characteristic of pGSR (Pb-Ba-Sb), as observed by simultaneous elemental identification of target analytes at the exact ablation times and locations. When considering the pre-characterized elemental composition of these primers as the "ground truth", LA-ICP-MS resulted in 91.8% sensitivity (true positive rate), while LIBS resulted in 89.2% sensitivity. Particles containing Ba, Bi, Bi-Cu-K, and Cu-Ti-Zn were found in the lead-free residues. Identification of lead-free GSR proved more challenging as some of these elements are common in the environment, resulting in 85.2% sensitivity for LA-ICP-MS and 44.4% for LIBS. Overall accuracies of 94.9% and 88.2% were obtained for the LA-ICP-MS and LIBS sets, respectively. LA-ICP-MS provided an additional level of confidence in the results by its superior analytical capabilities, complementing the LIBS chemical profiles. The laser-based methods provide rapid chemical profiling and micro-spatial information of gunshot residue particles, with minimal destruction of the sample and high accuracy. Chemical mapping of 25 micro-regions per sample is possible in 2-10 minutes by LIBS and LA-ICP-MS, offering new tools for more comprehensive forensic case management and quick GSR screening in environmental and occupational sciences.