CTV Dose Coverage Research Articles

The impact of motion on onboard MRI-guided pencil beam scanned proton therapy treatments

Objective. Online magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) guidance could be especially beneficial for pencil beam scanned (PBS) proton therapy of tumours affected by respiratory motion. For the first time to our knowledge, we investigate the dosimetric impact of respiratory motion on MRI-guided proton therapy compared to the scenario without magnetic field. Approach. A previously developed analytical proton dose calculation algorithm accounting for perpendicular magnetic fields was extended to enable 4D dose calculations. For two geometrical phantoms and three liver and two lung patient cases, static treatment plans were optimised with and without magnetic field (0, 0.5 and 1.5 T). Furthermore, plans were optimised using gantry angle corrections (0.5 T +5° and 1.5 T +15°) to reproduce similar beam trajectories compared to the 0 T reference plans. The effect of motion was then considered using 4D dose calculations without any motion mitigation and simulating 8-times volumetric rescanning, with motion for the patient cases provided by 4DCT(MRI) data sets. Each 4D dose calculation was performed for different starting phases and the CTV dose coverage V 95% and homogeneity D 5%–D 95% were analysed. Main results. For the geometrical phantoms with rigid motion perpendicular to the beam and parallel to the magnetic field, a comparable dosimetric effect was observed independent of the magnetic field. Also for the five 4DCT(MRI) cases, the influence of motion was comparable for all magnetic field strengths with and without gantry angle correction. On average, the motion-induced decrease in CTV V 95% from the static plan was 17.0% and 18.9% for 1.5 T and 0.5 T, respectively, and 19.9% without magnetic field. Significance. For the first time, this study investigates the combined impact of magnetic fields and respiratory motion on MR-guided proton therapy. The comparable dosimetric effects irrespective of magnetic field strength indicate that the effects of motion for future MR-guided proton therapy may not be worse than for conventional PBS proton therapy.

Dosimetric Accuracy of Multi-Target Biology-Guided Radiotherapy Treatments in a Single Session

We present the first dosimetric measurements of single session, multi-target BgRT deliveries using a clinically realistic motion phantom on a research-only version of the RefleXion X1 system. A custom-made anthropomorphic phantom of a human torso with embedded fillable targets mimicking 18F-FDG-avid lesions was used. From the three embedded spherical targets, Target 1 was 26 mm in diameter coupled with a 3D independent respiratory motion with 22 mm range, whereas Target 2 and 3 were 22 mm in diameter and moved with a 1D 5 mm maximum sinusoidal motion. The 18F-FDG concentration in the background cavity of the phantom was 5 kBq/ml, and the targets were loaded with 10:1, 8:1 and 6:1 contrast relative to the background for Targets 1, 2, 3, respectively. Spherical structures were contoured as GTVs (CTV = GTV) and a 5 mm margin was added to create PTVs. Motion extent of the tumors were captured to create biological tracking zones for each target. Treatment plans were generated using a research version of the Reflexion treatment planning software to deliver 8 Gy/fx to the PTVs. The treatment delivery was repeated 2 times, and each time the phantom was refilled according to the plan. PET image evaluation metrics for each of the three targets were also recorded. Target dosimetry was measured using a combination of radiographic film and ion chamber. The maximum distance between the 97% prescription isodose line from the plan and the film measurements was used to characterize the dosimetric accuracy of the tracked deliveries. CTV and PTV min, max, and mean doses measured on film were also recorded for each target. Treatment plans were successfully created with 100% prescription dose coverage to each target loaded with different FDG ratios. Total treatment times for the single-plan, three-target deliveries were less than 80 minutes. PET evaluation metrics at imaging-only and pre-scan, and planning and film dosimetry to the GTV and PTV for each of the three targets is shown in table below (mean ± standard deviation of both deliveries). The CTV dose coverage was maintained for all targets. The shrinkage distance of the 97% prescription dose isodose line on the film plane for all three targets was less than 3 mm for both tests, and ranged from -0.4 to -2.34 mm. These results demonstrate that high tracking accuracy and dosimetric accuracy can be achieved in single session, multi-target deliveries over a range of target-to-background 18F-FDG concentrations and target motion patterns.

Optimal Fractionation and Timing of Weekly Cone-Beam CT in Daily Surface-Guided Radiotherapy for Breast Cancer

SGRT has been demonstrated as a promising supplement to CBCT in adjuvant breast cancer radiotherapy, but a rational combination mode is lacking in clinical practice. The aim of this study was to explore this mode and investigate its impact on setup and dose accuracy. Both daily SGRT and weekly CBCT images were acquired for 23 breast cancer patients receiving conventional fractionated radiotherapy after lumpectomy. Based on the scanning frequencies and time intervals of CBCT, sixteen modes were acquired by randomly selecting one (CBCT1), two (CBCTij), three (CBCTijk), four (CBCTijkl), and five (CBCT12345) images from the patient's off-line CBCT images for fusion with SGRT. Due to TPS system limitations, the 6D SGRT setup errors were transformed into 3D deviations in the translational directions, and the CTV-PTV margins, the dose coverage (V95%) of PTV and CTV, and the OAR doses (the ipsilateral lung's V5, V10, V20, and Dmean, the contralateral breast's V3 and Dmean, and the heart's Dmean and Dmax) were calculated based on the 3D deviations with different regions of interest (ROIs). Dose correlations between these modalities were investigated using Pearson and Spearman's methods. For the ipsilateral breast ROI, the larger SGRT errors in the AP direction and higher target doses were found in all modes compared to the whole breast ROI (P < 0.05). In the ipsilateral ROI, the CTV-PTV margins decreased as CBCT frequencies increased, reaching approximately 5 mm for CBCTijkl and CBCT12345. The decline of Σ (systematic errors) was greater than the decline of σ (random errors), and it contributed more to the decline of margins. For the same frequency, the CBCT time intervals had essentially little influence on the errors and margins. Compared with other directions, the margins in the SI direction were the largest for all modes except for CBCT124 and CBCT125. The target dose correlations between all modes increased with increasing CBCT time intervals, decreased and then increased with increasing CBCT frequencies, with the turning point observed at week 5 of CBCT participation. The dose deviations in CBCT123, CBCT124, CBCT125, CBCTijkl, and CBCT12345 were minimal and not significantly different (P > 0.05). There was excellent agreement in CBCT124 vs. CBCT1234, and (CBCTijkl, CBCT12345) vs. CBCT125 in determining the classification for the percentage of PTV deviation (Kappa = 0.775-0.901). The frequencies and time intervals of CBCT had little effect on the OAR doses. For all modes, there were strong correlations (R > 0.9) in the OAR doses between different modes, except for the ipsilateral lung's V20 and Dmean (R = 0.734-0.987). Based on weekly CBCT, these modes with the ipsilateral breast ROI and a combination of daily SGRT and CBCT frequencies of ≥ 3 were recommended, and the CBCT was required at weeks 1 and 2. Considering the additional radiation, time consumption, and expensive cost of CBCT, modes CBCT124 and CBCT125 could replace the modes with higher CBCT frequencies.

Clinical experiences with online adaptive radiotherapy of vulvar carcinoma

Background and purpose Radiotherapy for vulvar carcinoma is challenging due to relatively high risk of locoregional disease recurrence, a technically challenging target, and postoperative lymphocele, and a high risk radiation sequelae. We aim to explore, if it is possible to reduce dose to normal tissue, while maintaining CTV coverage for this patient group with online adaptive radiotherapy. Materials and methods 20 patients with vulvar carcinoma (527 fractions) were treated with online adaptation on a Varian Ethos accelerator. Setup CBCTs were acquired daily for adaptive planning. Verification CBCTs were acquired immediately prior to dose delivery. CTV dose coverage and dose to bladder and rectum were extracted from the scheduled and adapted plans as well as from adapted plans recalculated based on verification CBCTs. In addition, analysis of the decision of the adaptive procedure was performed for 17 patients (465 fractions). Results Mean CTV D95% and standard deviation was 98% ± 5% for the scheduled plan compared to 100.0 ± 0.3% and 100.0 ± 0.8% for the adapted plan on the setup and verification CBCT respectively. Dose to OARs varied substantially and did not show any benefit from adaption itself, however a margin reduction was implemented after the first patients treated. The adapted plan was chosen for 63.5% of the fractions and dominant reasons for not adapting were ‘no significant dosimetric gain’ (75 fractions, 14%) and ‘Medical doctor (MD) not available for treatment’ (50 fractions, 9.5%). The median adaption time was 15 min and the 25th and 75th percentile was 12 and 17 min, respectively. Conclusion CTVs and PTVs dose coverage were significantly improved with adaptation compared to image-guided RT. This gain was robust during the treatment time.

Impact of varying the number of irradiation fields on dose distribution: A four-dimensional scanned carbon-ion lung radiotherapy

To shorten the treatment procedure and increase the treatment efficiency, we performed planning studies to evaluate the 4D dose (4DD) distributions of different number of irradiation fields with the fixed treatment ports of scanning carbon-ion beam delivery. We enrolled 10 lung cancer patients treated with respiratory-gated scanning carbon-ion therapy. 4-field, 3-field, and 2-field plans were generated with fixed treatment ports by rotating the beam angle with a 20∼40-degree difference. For each field, the range-adapted internal target volume (raITV) was calculated. The prescription dose of 50 Gy (RBE)-weighted dose with 1 fraction was optimized on the reference phase (T50). The 4DD distributions were calculated for each patient, and dose metrics of CTV dose coverage and OARs sparing were evaluated. p < 0.05 was considered to be statistically significant by Wilcoxon signed-rank test. The sufficient CTV-D95 > 97.8% could be achieved for all the three types of treatment plan. The Dmax of skin was increased (= 19.1 ± 5.7 Gy (RBE)) for the 2-field plans as compared to 4-field plans (= 14.2 ± 6.6 Gy (RBE), p = 0.006), which is still acceptable for clinical use (<35 Gy (RBE)). And there were no differences (p > 0.076) of V20 of lung (= 15.5 ± 6.6%, 16.2 ± 7.0%, 15.6 ± 6.3%) and Dmax of spinal cord (= 3.0 ± 2.9, 3.4 ± 3.9, 3.3 ± 4.3 Gy (RBE)) among the three types of plans. Lung treatment plans under the fixed orthogonal beam ports with zero-degree couch pitch angle is feasible for clinical use to further increase the treatment efficiency and throughput.

Optimal fractionation and timing of weekly cone-beam CT in daily surface-guided radiotherapy for breast cancer

PurposeSurface-guided radiotherapy (SGRT) has been demonstrated to be a promising supplement to cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) in adjuvant breast cancer radiotherapy, but a rational combination mode is lacking in clinical practice. The aim of this study was to explore this mode and investigate its impact on the setup and dose accuracy.Methods and materialsDaily SGRT and weekly CBCT images were acquired for 23 patients with breast cancer who received conventional fractionated radiotherapy after lumpectomy. Sixteen modes were acquired by randomly selecting one (CBCT1), two (CBCTij), three (CBCTijk), four (CBCTijkl), and five (CBCT12345) images from the CBCT images for fusion with the SGRT. The CTV-PTV margins, OAR doses, and dose coverage (V95%) of PTV and CTV was calculated based on SGRT setup errors with different regions of interest (ROIs). Dose correlations between these modalities were investigated using Pearson and Spearman’s methods. Patient-specific parameters were recorded to assess their impact on dose.ResultsThe CTV-PTV margins decreased with increasing CBCT frequencies and were close to 5 mm for CBCTijkl and CBCT12345. For the ipsilateral breast ROI, SGRT errors were larger in the AP direction, and target doses were higher in all modes than in the whole breast ROI (P < 0.05). In the ipsilateral ROI, the target dose correlations between all modes increased with increasing CBCT time intervals, decreased, and then increased with increasing CBCT frequencies, with the inflection point being CBCT participation at week 5. The dose deviations in CBCT123, CBCT124, CBCT125, CBCTijkl, and CBCT12345 were minimal and did not differ significantly (P > 0.05). There was excellent agreement between CBCT124 and CBCT1234, and between (CBCTijkl, CBCT12345) and CBCT125 in determining the classification for the percentage of PTV deviation (Kappa = 0.704–0.901). In addition, there were weak correlations between the patient’s Dips_b (ipsilateral breast diameter with bolus) and CTV doses in modes with CBCT participation at week 4 (R = 0.270 to 0.480).ConclusionsBased on weekly CBCT, these modes with ipsilateral ROI and a combination of daily SGRT and a CBCT frequency of ≥ 3 were recommended, and CBCT was required at weeks 1 and 2 for CBCTijk.

Evaluation of CTV to PTV Margin for Head and Neck Cancer with Daily Setup Using MVCBCT Imaging

Purpose: Geometrical inaccuracies of setup using MV-CBCT imaging for patients with head and neck cancer were evaluated. Possibility of modifying of CTV to PTV margin while delineation of such tumors was estimated. Materials and methods: Additional adjustment of simulation kV CT pictures with MV-CBCT images received during the implementation of the online protocol was conducted for 35 patients with head and neck cancer. Offline analysis revealed the discrepancy in the results of online correction and offline analyses. CTV to PTV margin considering daily setup was computed. Results: Obtained values of CTV to PTV margin: 2.4 mm in Vrt, 2.1 mm in Lng and 2.5 mm in Lat. Upward variations from 5 mm margin used in unit were registered for 2 patients. Conclusions: Reduction of CTV to PTV margin up to 2.5 mm is precarious because CTV dose coverage is not reasonable for all patients. Implementation of routine work practice in Off-line Review is required for identification of problem cases and determination of individual CTV to PTV margin.

Dosimetric effect of respiratory motion on planned dose in whole-breast volumetric modulated arc therapy using moderate and ultra-hypofractionation

Background and purposeThe interplay effect of respiratory motion on the planned dose in free-breathing right-sided whole-breast irradiation (WBI) were studied by simulating hypofractionated VMAT treatment courses.Materials and methodsTen patients with phase-triggered 4D-CT images were included in the study. VMAT plans targeting the right breast were created retrospectively with moderately hypofractionated (40.05 Gy in 15 fractions of 2.67 Gy) and ultra-hypofractionated (26 Gy 5 fractions of 5.2 Gy) schemes. 3D-CRT plans were generated as a reference. All plans were divided into respiratory phase-specific plans and calculated in the corresponding phase images. Fraction-specific dose was formed by deforming and summing the phase-specific doses in the planning image for each fraction. The fraction-specific dose distributions were deformed and superimposed onto the planning image, forming the course-specific respiratory motion perturbed dose distribution. Planned and respiratory motion perturbed doses were compared and changes due to respiratory motion and choice of fractionation were evaluated.ResultsThe respiratory motion perturbed PTV coverage (V95%) decreased by 1.7% and the homogeneity index increased by 0.02 for VMAT techniques, compared to the planned values. Highest decrease in CTV coverage was 0.7%. The largest dose differences were located in the areas of steep dose gradients parallel to respiratory motion. The largest difference in DVH parameters between fractionation schemes was 0.4% of the prescribed dose. Clinically relevant changes to the doses of organs at risk were not observed. One patient was excluded from the analysis due to large respiratory amplitude.ConclusionRespiratory motion of less than 5 mm in magnitude did not result in clinically significant changes in the planned free-breathing WBI dose. The 5 mm margins were sufficient to account for the respiratory motion in terms of CTV dose homogeneity and coverage for VMAT techniques. Steep dose gradients near the PTV edges might decrease the CTV coverage. No clinical significance was found due to the choice of fractionation.

A treatment planning comparison of photon stereotactic ablative radiotherapy and proton beam therapy for the re-irradiation of pelvic cancer recurrence.

BackgroundPatients who experience a pelvic cancer recurrence in or near a region that received initial radiotherapy, typically have few options for treatment. Organs at risk (OAR) have often reached their dose constraint limits leaving minimal dose remaining for standard re-irradiation (reRT). However, photon based stereotactic ablative radiotherapy (SABR) has been utilised for reRT with promising initial results although meeting OAR constraints can be challenging. Proton beam therapy (PBT) could offer an advantage.Materials and methodsSABR plans used for treatment for ten pelvic reRT patients were dosimetrically compared to PBT plans retrospectively planned using the same CT and contour data. PBT plans were created to match the CTV dose coverage of SABR treatment plans with V100% ≥95%. An ‘as low as reasonably achievable’ approach was taken to OAR tolerances with consideration of OAR dose from the initial radiation (using equivalent dose in 2 Gy fractions).ResultsDosimetric comparison of relevant OAR statistics showed a decrease in OAR dose using PBT over SABR in all patients, with equivalent target coverage. The largest statistically significant reduction was seen for the colon D0.5 cm3 with a median reduction from 13.1 Gy to 5.9 Gy. There were statistically significant dose reductions in the median dose to small bowel, sacral plexus and cauda equina.ConclusionPBT has the potential for significant dose reductions for OARs in the pelvic reRT setting compared to SABR. However, it remains unclear if the magnitude of these OAR dose reductions will translate into clinical benefit.

Combining rescanning and gating for a time-efficient treatment of mobile tumors using pencil beam scanning proton therapy

Background and purposeRespiratory motion during proton therapy can severely degrade dose distributions, particularly due to interplay effects when using pencil beam scanning. Combined rescanning and gating treatments for moving tumors mitigates dose degradation, but at the cost of increased treatment delivery time. The objective of this study was to identify the time efficiency of these dose degradation-motion mitigation strategies for different range of motions. Materials and methodsSeventeen patients with thoracic or abdominal tumors were studied. Tumor motion amplitudes ranged from 2–30 mm. Deliveries using different combinations of rescanning and gating were simulated with a dense dose spot grid (4 × 4 × 2.5 mm3) for all patients and a sparse dose spot grid (8 × 8 × 5 mm3) for six patients with larger tumor movements (>8 mm). The resulting plans were evaluated in terms of CTV coverage and time efficiency. ResultsBased on the studied patient cohort, it has been shown that for amplitudes up to 5 mm, no motion mitigation is required with a dense spot grid. For amplitudes between 5 and 10 mm, volumetric rescanning should be applied while maintaining a 100% duty cycle when using a dense spot grid. Although gating could be envisaged to reduce the target volume for intermediate motion, it has been shown that the dose to normal tissues would only be reduced marginally. Moreover, the treatment time would increase. Finally, for larger motion amplitudes, both volumetric rescanning and respiratory gating should be applied with both spot grids. In addition, it has been shown that a dense spot grid delivers better CTV dose coverage than a sparse dose grid. ConclusionVolumetric rescanning and/or respiratory gating can be used in order to effectively and efficiently mitigate dose degradation due to tumor movement.

Dose constraints for whole breast radiation therapy based on the quality assessment of treatment plans in the randomised Danish breast cancer group (DBCG) HYPO trial

PurposeQuality assessment of the treatment plans in the Danish Breast Cancer Group (DBCG) HYPO trial was carried out based on prospectively reported dosimetric parameters and evidence-based dose constraints for whole breast radiation therapy were derived. Materials and methodsFrom 2009 to 2014, 1882 patients (pts) were randomised between 50 Gy/25fractions (fr) versus 40 Gy/15fr. Doses to CTVp_breast (V95%, V107%-V110%, Dmax, and in addition for 40 Gy plans V105%-V107%), ipsilateral lung (V20Gy/V17Gy), heart (V20Gy/V17Gy, V40Gy/V35Gy), and left anterior descending coronary artery (LADCA) (Dmax) and use of respiratory gated technique were prospectively reported to the DBCG database. After end of accrual, these dosimetric parameters from all plans in the trial were compared to the pre-specified treatment constraints. ResultsIn total, 1854 pts from eight radiation therapy (RT) centres in three countries were treated. No statistically significant differences were found between the results for 40 Gy and 50 Gy plans, except for CTVp_breast hot-spot volume (V107%-V110%). Of the 40 Gy pts, 90% with CTVp_breast > 600 mL and 95% with CTVp_breast ≤ 600 mL had a CTVp_breast hot-spot volume (V105%-V107%) <2%. In 95% of the 50 Gy plans, the CTVp_breast absolute hot-spot volume (V107%-V110%) was <0.5 mL and 1.7 mL for CTVp_breast ≤ 600 mL and > 600 mL, respectively. Compliance was >99% for both heart and lung constraints. Largest deviation from protocol constraints was found for the volume of CTVp_breast covered with 95% of the prescription dose or more (V95%). The CTV dose coverage (V95%) was >94.3% in 95% of the right-sided pts, whereas the figures for 95% of the left-sided pts treated with and without respiratory gating were 93.2% and 88.8%, respectively. ConclusionA high degree of compliance with protocol dose constraints was found for treatment plans in the DBCG HYPO trial. New constraints for dose to organs at risk and high-dose volumes in the breast are suggested for breast-only RT planning.

Perturbation analysis of 4D dose distribution for scanned carbon-ion beam radiotherapy

PurposeTo evaluate the patients’ set-up error-induced perturbation effects on 4D dose distributions (4DDD) of range-adapted internal target volume-based (raITV) treatment plan using lung and liver 4DCT data sets. MethodsWe enrolled 20 patients with lung and liver cancer treated with respiratory-gated carbon-ion beam scanning therapy. PTVs were generated by adding a 2 mm range-adapted set-up margin on the raITVs. Set-up errors were simulated by shifting the beam isocenter in three translational directions of ±2 mm, ±4 mm, and ±6 mm. 4DDDs were calculated for both nominal and isocenter-shifted situations. Dose metrics of CTV dose coverage (D95) and normal tissue sparing were evaluated. Statistical significance with p < 0.01 was considered by Wilcoxon signed rank test. ResultsThe CTV dose coverage was more sensitive to set-up errors for lung cases than for liver cases, and more serious in superior-inferior direction. The sufficient CTV-D95 > 98% could be achieved with set-up errors less than ±2 mm in all shift directions both for lung and liver cases. With the increase of set-up error, the CTV dose coverage decreased gradually. The clinical criterial of CTV-D95 > 95% could not be fulfilled with set-up error reached to ±4 mm for lung cases, and ±6 mm for liver cases. OAR doses did not have a significant difference with each set-up error for both lung and liver cases. ConclusionsThe range-adapted set-up margin successfully prevented dose degradation of 4DDDs in the presence of the same magnitude of set-up error for raITV-based carbon-ion beam scanning therapy.

Simulated multileaf collimator tracking for stereotactic liver radiotherapy guided by kilovoltage intrafraction monitoring: Dosimetric gain and target overdose trends

PurposeTo investigate the potential benefit of multileaf collimator (MLC) tracking guided by kilovoltage intrafraction monitoring (KIM) during stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) in the liver, and to understand trends of target overdose with MLC tracking. MethodsSix liver SBRT patients with 2–3 implanted gold markers received SBRT delivered with volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) in three fractions using daily cone-beam CT setup. The CTV-to-PTV margins were 5 mm in the axial plane and 10 mm in the cranio-caudal directions, and the plans were designed to give minimum target doses of 95% (CTV) and 67% (PTV). The three-dimensional marker trajectory estimated by post-treatment analysis of kV fluoroscopy images acquired throughout treatment delivery was assumed to represent the tumor motion. MLC tracking guided by real-time KIM was simulated. The reduction in CTV D95 (minimum dose to 95% of the clinical target volume) relative to the planned D95 (ΔD95) was compared between actual non-tracking and simulated MLC tracking treatments. ResultsMLC tracking maintained a high CTV dose coverage for all 18 fractions with ΔD95 (mean: 0.2 percentage points (pp), range: −1.7 to 1.9 pp) being significantly lower than for the actual non-tracking treatments (mean: 6.3 pp range: 0.6–16.0 pp) (p = 0.002). MLC tracking of large target motion perpendicular to the MLC leaves created dose artifacts with regions of overdose in the CTV. As a result, the mean dose in spherical volumes centered in the middle of the CTV was on average 2.4 pp (5 mm radius sphere) and 1.3 pp (15 mm radius sphere) higher than planned (p = 0.002). ConclusionsIntrafraction tumor motion can deteriorate the CTV dose of liver SBRT. The planned CTV dose coverage may be restored with KIM-guided MLC tracking. However, MLC tracking may have a tendency to create hotspots in the CTV.

Dosimetric impact of intrafraction rotations in stereotactic prostate radiotherapy: A subset analysis of the TROG 15.01 SPARK trial

Background and purposeAccurate delivery of radiotherapy is critical to achieve optimal treatment outcomes. Interfraction translational IGRT is now standard, and intrafraction motion management is becoming accessible. Some platforms can report both translational and rotational movements in real time. This study aims to quantify the dosimetric impact of observed intrafraction rotation of the prostate measured using monitoring software. Materials and methodsA dose grid resampling algorithm was used to model the dosimetric impact of prostate rotations for 20 patients on a SBRT prostate clinical trial. Translations were corrected before and during treatment, but rotations were not. Real time rotation data were acquired using KIM and a cumulative histogram analysis performed. Prostate volumes were rotated by the range of observed angles and used to calculate DVH data. ResultsThe pitch axis had a higher range of observed rotations resulting in only 7 patients spending at least 90% of the beam on time across all fractions within rotation angles resulting in PTV D95% ≥36 Gy in this axis. The yaw and roll axes saw 17 and 15 patients respectively achieving this criterion. All but one of 20 patients exceeded CTV D98% ≥36 Gy for all observed rotation angles. ConclusionsCurrent CTV–PTV margins do not result in compromised CTV dose coverage due to inter and intrafraction prostate rotations in the absence of other uncertainties. Reduced PTV dosing is due to the extremely conformal treatment delivery but is unlikely to be clinically deleterious. Prostate standard IGRT should continue to focus on correcting any observed translational movements. Margin reduction could be explored in conjunction with other uncertainties.

Optimal selection of optimization bolus thickness in planning of VMAT breast radiotherapy treatments

The aim of this study was to find an optimal optimization skin flash thickness in volumetric modulated arc radiotherapy of the breast in consideration of soft tissue deformations during the treatment course. Ten breast radiotherapy patients with axillary lymph node inclusion were retrospectively planned with volumetric modulated arc radiotherapy technique. The plans were optimized with the planning target volume (PTV) extending outside the skin contour by 0, 5, 7, and 10 mm; and with optimization boluses of 3 or 5 mm on the extended PTV. The final dose was calculated without the bolus. The plans were compared in terms of PTV homogeneity and conformity, and dose minima and maxima. The doses to organs at risk were also evaluated. The doses were recalculated in real patient geometries based on cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) images captured 3 to 6 times during each patient's treatment course. The optimization to the PTV without the PTV extension resulted in the best CTV coverage in the original plans (V95% = 98.0% ± 1.2%). However, when these plans were studied in real CBCT-based patient geometries, the CTV V95% was compromised (94.6% ± 8.3%). In addition, for the surface (4 mm slap inside the PTV 4 mm below the body contour) dose V95% was reduced from the planned 74.7% ± 7.5% to the recalculated 65.5% ± 11.5%. Optimization with an 8-mm bolus to a PTV with 5-mm extension was the most robust choice to ensure the CTV and surface dose coverage (recalculated V95% was 95.2% ± 6.4% and 74.6% ± 8.4%, respectively). In cases with the largest observed deformations, even a 10-mm PTV extension did not suffice to cover the target. Optimization with a 5-mm PTV extension and an 8-mm optimization bolus improved the surface dose and slightly improved the CTV dose when compared to no extension plans. For deformations over 1 cm, no benefit was seen in PTV extensions and replanning is recommended. Frequent tangential and CBCT imaging should be used during treatment course to detect potential large anatomical changes.

Under-reported dosimetry errors due to interplay effects during VMAT dose delivery in extreme hypofractionated stereotactic radiotherapy.

Radiotherapy of extracranial metastases changed from normofractioned 3D CRT to extreme hypofractionated stereotactic treatment using VMAT beam techniques. Random interaction between tumour motion and dynamically changing beam parameters might result in underdosage of the CTV even for an appropriately dimensioned ITV (interplay effect). This study presents a clinical scenario of extreme hypofractionated stereotactic treatment and analyses the impact of interplay effects on CTV dose coverage. For a thoracic/abdominal phantom with an integrated high-resolution detector array placed on a 4D motion platform, dual-arc treatment plans with homogenous target coverage were created using a common VMAT technique and delivered in a single fraction. CTV underdosage through interplay effects was investigated by comparing dose measurements with and without tumour motion during plan delivery. Our study agrees with previous works that pointed out insignificant interplay effects on target coverage for very regular tumour motion patterns like simple sinusoidal motion. However, we identified and illustrated scenarios that are likely to result in a clinically relevant CTV underdosage. For tumour motion with abnormal variability, target coverage quantified by the CTV area receiving more than 98% of the prescribed dose decreased to 78% compared to 100% at static dose measurement. This study is further proof of considerable influence of interplay effects on VMAT dose delivery in stereotactic radiotherapy. For selected conditions of an exemplary scenario, interplay effects and related motion-induced target underdosage primarily occurred in tumour motion pattern with increased motion variability and VMAT plan delivery using complex MLC dose modulation.

Effect of different patient positions on target dose coverage in rectal cancer IMRT

Objective To compare the effect between the supine and prone patient positions upon target dose coverage during intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) for rectal cancer, aiming to provide clinical reference for the selection of position for rectal cancer patients. Methods Twenty-four patients diagnosed with rectal cancer receiving postoperative adjuvant radiotherapy were selected and divided into the supine (n=12) and prone position groups (n=12). Before and during the IMRT (1-4 weeks), all patients received CT scans, which were defined as: Plan, 1W, 2W, 3W and 4W, respectively. The organs at risk were delineated based on CT scan images. Plan, 1W, 2W, 3W and 4W CT scan images were fused. The CTV and PTV from Plan CT scan were copied to the 1-4W CT scan images, and the therapeutic plans from Plan CT scan were copied as well. The target dose coverage was assessed and the failure rate of target dose coverage was calculated. The couch-position data for each patient during each cycle of IMRT were recorded by using the MOSAIQ network and the overall deviation (S) of couch position was calculated. Results The failure rates of CTV and PTV target dose coverage in the prone position group were higher than those in the supine position group (18.60% VS 0%, 69.76% VS 53.65%). The S value was significantly correlated with the target dose coverage (r=-0.683, P=0.000). The S value in the prone position group was (1.23±0.76) cm, significantly greater than (0.28±0.18) cm in the supine position (P=0.001), and the most significant deviation was noted in the y (head and foot) and z (frontal and dorsal) directions (P=0.003 and 0.003). Compared with the supine group, the V5 and V10 of the small intestine were significantly less (P=0.003 and 0.004) and the chronic toxicity (NTCPC) was considerably reduced (P=0.041) in the prone position group. Conclusions A better target dose coverage can be maintained during IMRT with a supine position during rectal cancer IMRT, whereas the positioning repeatability is worsened with a prone position due to use of the belly board, thereby affecting the target dose coverage. Although the prone position combined with belly board can reduce the tolerated dosage of the small intestine, effective measures should be taken to guarantee the patient positioning repeatability. Key words: Rectal neoplasms/intensity-modulated radiotherapy; Radiotherapy dosage; Belly board

Using daily diagnostic quality images to validate planning margins for prostate interfractional variations

The purpose of this study is to use the same diagnostic‐quality verification and planning CTs to validate planning margin account for residual interfractional variations with image‐guided soft tissue alignment of the prostate. For nine prostate cancer patients treated with IMRT to 78 Gy in 39 fractions, daily verification CT‐on‐rails images of the first seven and last seven fractions (n=126) were retrospectively selected for this study. On these images, prostate, bladder, and rectum were delineated by the same attending physician. Clinical plans were created with a margin of 8 mm except for 5 mm posteriorly, referred to as 8/5 mm. Three additional plans were created for each patient with the margins of 6/4 mm, 4/2 mm, and 2 mm uniform. These plans were subsequently applied to daily images and radiation doses were recalculated. The isocenters of these plans were placed according to clinical online shifts, which were based on soft tissue alignment to the prostate. Retrospective offline shifts by aligning prostate contours were compared to online shifts. The resultant daily target dose was analyzed using D99, the percentage of the prescription dose received by 99% of CTV. The percent of bladder volume receiving 65 Gy (V65Gy) and rectum V70Gy were also analyzed. After interfractional correction, using CTV D99>97%% criteria, 8/5 mm, 6/4 mm, 4/2 mm, and 2 mm planning margins met the CTV dose coverage in 95%, 91%, 65%, and 53% of the 126 fractions with online shifts, and 99%, 98%, 85%, and 68% with offline shifts. The rectum V70Gy and bladder V65Gy were significantly decreased at each level of margin reduction (p<0.05). With daily diagnostic quality imaging‐guidance, the interfractional planning margin may be reduced from 8/5 mm to 6/4 mm. The residual interfractional uncertainties most likely stem from prostate rotation and deformation.PACS number(s): 87.53.‐j

Dosimetric effects of positioning shifts using 6D-frameless stereotactic Brainlab system in hypofractionated intracranial radiotherapy.

Dosimetric consequences of positional shifts were studied using frameless Brainlab ExacTrac X‐ray system for hypofractionated (3 or 5 fractions) intracranial stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT). SRT treatments of 17 patients with metastatic intracranial tumors using the stereotactic system were retrospectively investigated. The treatments were simulated in a treatment planning system by modifying planning parameters with a matrix conversion technique based on positional shifts for initial infrared (IR)‐based setup (XC: X‐ray correction) and post‐correction (XV: X‐ray verification). The simulation was implemented with (a) 3D translational shifts only and (b) 6D translational and rotational shifts for dosimetric effects of angular correction. Mean translations and rotations (± 1 SD) of 77 fractions based on the initial IR setup (XC) were 0.51±0.86 mm (lateral), 0.30±1.55 mm (longitudinal), and −1.63±1.00 mm (vertical); 0.53±0.56 mm (pitch), 0.42±0.60 mm (roll), and 0.44±0.90 mm (yaw), respectively. These were −0.07±0.24 mm, −0.07±0.25 mm, 0.06±0.21 mm, 0.04±0.23 mm, 0.00±0.30 mm, and 0.02±0.22 mm, respectively, for the postcorrection (XV). Substantial degradation of the treatment plans was observed in D95 of PTV (2.6%±3.3%; simulated treatment versus treatment planning), Dmin of PTV (13.4%±11.6%), and Dmin of CTV (2.8%±3.8%, with the maximum error of 10.0%) from XC, while dosimetrically negligible changes (< 0.1%) were detected for both CTV and PTV from XV simulation. 3D angular correction significantly improved CTV dose coverage when the total angular shifts (|pitch|+|roll|+|yaw|) were greater than 2°. With the 6D stereoscopic X‐ray verification imaging and frameless immobilization, submillimeter and subdegree accuracy is achieved with negligible dosimetric deviations. 3D angular correction is required when the angular deviation is substantial. A CTV‐to‐PTV safety margin of 2 mm is large enough to prevent deterioration of CTV coverage.PACS number: 87.55.dk

Impact of fractionation and number of fields on dose homogeneity for intra-fractionally moving lung tumors using scanned carbon ion treatment

Background and purposeScanned particle beam therapy may result in over and under dosages within the target volume. This study quantifies how CTV dose coverage improves with number of fractions and fields. Materials and methodsBased on 4DCTs of nine lung tumor patients, treatment plans were optimized separately for four different fields using an ITV approach. 4D RBE-weighted dose distributions were calculated for varying motion parameters and fraction numbers. The total RBE-weighted dose was determined for one and four-field application per fraction. DVHs were analyzed for the tumor and interpreted based on statistical modeling. ResultsDose homogeneity within the CTV increased with the fraction number, but depends significantly on the tumor motion amplitude. For single-field schedules and amplitudes >6mm, the dose coverage indices (V95min=90.7% and V107max=0.4%) differed to the stationary case even after 40 fractions. Target coverage for a four-field approach followed a proposed model and homogeneous dose distributions could be achieved 6-times faster than single-field treatments. ConclusionsFractionated delivery improves dose homogeneity in scanned ion beam therapy of moving targets. The achievable homogeneity depends mainly on tumor volume and motion amplitude. The outcome of multiple-field irradiations can be predicted based on single-field results and accelerates the achievement of homogeneous dose distributions.