After reading the latest report of yet another case of adult cor triatriatum sinister complicated by atrial fibrillation by Siniorakis et al. [1] the following quote by the bestselling British author of heroic fantasy, David Andrew Gemmell sprang into my mind: “Life is not so simple. There are many futures. The life of a single person is like a great tree: every branch, every twig, every leaf is a possible future” [2]. This is especially true in the clinical scenario of atrial fibrillation. Clearly a multifactorial disease with many possible causes...many branches, many twigs, many leaves.... Clearlywe can add adult cor triatriatum sinister as yet another leaf to the tree of atrial fibrillation. However, we are faced with numerous clinical questions on this fairly newly discovered adult clinical entity. Why do these adult patients present so late? It can be assumed that they had fairly asymptomatic childhood years as they would present as adults with extensive clinical investigations as children otherwise, which certainly is not the case if one looks at all the currently available case reports. Secondly, by merely assuming that this entity is as simple as a congenital membrane separating various parts of the left atrium one is left with a hypothesis which is fraught with many errors and open to criticism. If this was truly the case, then why the late presentation as adults. Therefore, a reasonable question is if this presumed developmental anomaly involves the whole atrial wall with abnormal atrial musculature as a whole affecting all structural components. Thirdly, we have to ask the question if whether they may all have had atrial fibrillation since birth which was simply not diagnosed before their adulthood years. This will imply that this particular subset of atrial fibrillation is more benign than the other subsets of adult onset cases with their respective diverse causes. Fourthly, how should these cases be treated, if at all? At present we do not have any evidence based medicine on this subset of patients. Lastly, in my opinion it is essential to obtain a proper imaging study of every single case of atrial fibrillation. I still see patients in my clinic who underwent unsuccessful ablation procedures where no imaging study of the left atriumwas ever performed and hence with no specific diagnosis—my published case report of adult cor triatriatum sinister with adult onset atrial fibrillation is an example of such an unacceptable scenario [3]. In my opinion this can be compared to performing a thoracotomy on a coughing patient without obtaining a chest radiograph first to look for a possible reason for the symptom of cough. In conclusion, we are left with a fairly newly discovered clinical entity with still many unanswered clinical questions. I look forward to these being answered and adding yet another leaf to the complex tree of atrial fibrillation.
Read full abstract