Continuous-variable Quantum Key Distribution Scheme Research Articles

Robust continuous-variable quantum key distribution in the finite-size regime

Quantum key distribution (QKD) has been proven to be theoretically unconditionally secure. However, any theoretical security proof relies on certain assumptions. In QKD, the assumption in the theoretical proof is that the security of the protocol is considered under the asymptotic case where Alice and Bob exchange an infinite number of signals. In the continuous-variable QKD (CV-QKD), the finite-size effect imposes higher requirements on block size and excess noise control. However, the local local oscillator (LLO) CV-QKD system cannot be considered time-invariant under long blocks, especially in cases of environmental disturbances. Thus, we propose an LLO CV-QKD scheme with time-variant parameter estimation and compensation. We first establish an LLO CV-QKD theoretical model under the temporal modes of continuous-mode states. Then, a robust method is used to compensate for arbitrary frequency shift and arbitrary phase drift in CV-QKD systems with longer blocks, which cannot be achieved under traditional time-invariant parameter estimation. Besides, the digital signal processing method predicated on high-speed reference pilots can achieve a time complexity of O(1). In the experiment, the frequency shift is up to 89.05 MHz/s and phase drift is up to 3.036 Mrad/s using a piezoelectric transducer (PZT) to simulate the turbulences in the practical channel. With a signal-to-interference ratio (SIR) of −51.67 dB, we achieve a secret key rate (SKR) of 0.29 Mbits/s with an attenuation of 16 dB or a standard fiber of 80 km. This work paves the way for future long-distance field-test experiments in the finite-size regime.

A Novel Continuous-Variable Quantum Key Distribution Scheme Based on Multi-Dimensional Multiplexing Technology

Dual-polarization division multiplexing (DPDM) is considered to be a potential method to boost the secure key rate (SKR) of the continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD) system. In this article, we propose a pilot alternately assisted local local oscillator (LLO) CV-QKD scheme based on multi-dimensional multiplexing, where time division multiplexing and frequency division multiplexing are combined with dual-polarization multiplexing techniques to dramatically isolate the quantum signal from the pilot tone. We establish a general excess noise model for the LLO CV-QKD system to analyze the influence mechanism of various disturbances (e.g., time-domain diffusion, frequency-domain modulation residual, and polarization perturbation) on the key parameters, such as the channel transmittance and excess noise. Specifically, the photon leakage noise from the reference path to the quantum path and that between quantum signals with two different polarization paths are simultaneously analyzed in the dual-polarization LLO CV-QKD scheme for the first time. Furthermore, a series of simulations are established to verify the performance of the proposed scheme. The results show that the maximal isolation degree achieves 84.0 dB~90.4 dB, and the crosstalk between pilot tones and quantum signals can be suppressed to a very small range. By optimizing the system parameters (e.g., modulation variance and repetition frequency), the SKR with 12.801 Mbps@25 km is achieved under the infinite polarization extinction ratio (PER) and 30 dB residual ratio of the frequency modulation in the nanosecond-level pulse width. Moreover, the performance of the proposed DPDM CV-QKD scheme under relatively harsh conditions is simulated; the results show that the SKR with 1.02 Mbps@25 km is achieved under a relatively low PER of 17 dB with the nanosecond-level pulse width and 20 dB residual ratio of the frequency modulation. Our work lays an important theoretical foundation for the practical DPDM LLO CV-QKD system.

Generating local oscillator locally in continuous variable quantum key distribution using optical injection phase locked loop: a theoretical approach.

In this study, we investigate the feasibility of utilizing optical injection locking with phase-locked loop feedback to generate a true local oscillator for continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD). We evaluate the noise and imperfections associated with this novel approach and compare our findings with existing CV-QKD schemes. Notably, our calculations demonstrate significantly lower noise levels compared to other locally generated local oscillator-based CV-QKD schemes. Furthermore, we assess the secure key rate and achievable distance under collective attack for our proposed scheme and compare it to other variants of CV-QKD protocols employing a true local oscillator. Our results align well with experimental data, highlighting the promise of our approach.

Experimental free-space continuous-variable quantum key distribution with thermal source.

Passive-state-preparation (PSP) continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD) protocol explores the intrinsic field fluctuations of a thermal source. Compared with traditional Gaussian-modulated coherent-state CVQKD, it does not need active modulations and has promising applications in chip integration and portable free-space quantum key distribution. In this Letter, we propose and experimentally realize a PSP CVQKD scheme with transmitted local oscillator (LO) through fluctuating transmittance free-space channel using an off-the-shelf amplified spontaneous emission source for the first time. By proposing thermal-state polarization multiplexing transmitted LO, synchronized channel transmittance monitoring and fine-grained phase compensation techniques, secure keys within -15 dB transmittance of simulated free-space channel with turbulence are generated, with a final average secure key rate of 1.015 Mbps asymptotically. Equivalent atmospheric turbulence model analysis shows that the free-space PSP CVQKD scheme provides a promising outlook for high-speed and chip-based CVQKD for kilometer-level atmospheric channel networks.

Performance analysis for OFDM-based multi-carrier continuous-variable quantum key distribution with an arbitrary modulation protocol.

Multi-carrier continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD) is considered to be a promising way to boost the secret key rate (SKR) over the existing single-carrier CV-QKD scheme. However, the extra excess noise induced in the imperfect multi-carrier quantum state preparation process of N subcarriers will limit the performance of the system. Here, a systematic modulation noise model is proposed for the multi-carrier CV-QKD based on the orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM). Subsequently, the performance of multi-carrier CV-QKD with arbitrary modulation protocol (e.g. QPSK, 256QAM and Gaussian modulation protocol) can be quantitatively evaluated by combining the security analysis method of the single-carrier CV-QKD. Under practical system parameters, the simulation results show that the SKR of the multi-carrier CV-QKD can still be significantly improved by increasing the carrier number N even with imperfect practical modulations. Specifically, the total SKR of multi-carrier CV-QKD can be optimized by carefully choosing N. The proposed model provides a feasible theoretical framework for the future multi-carrier CV-QKD experimental implementation.

Security of plug-and-play continuous-variable quantum key distribution

Subject of study. Two-way continuous-variable quantum key distribution schemes are studied. Aim. This study aims to prove the security of the plug-and-play continuous-variable quantum key distribution system in the context of the model of trusted noise from legitimate users. Method. Based on an analog of the well-known implementation in the plug-and-play format, the performance of such a system operating under the GG02 protocol is evaluated. The evaluation is conducted in the presence of collective attacks, considering the finite-key effects. Main results. A secure key that satisfies the composability criteria can be distributed with a channel loss of 5 dB, which is expected to be approximately half that in a one-way scheme. Practical significance. Two-way quantum key distribution schemes are more stable than one-way schemes, and hence, their stability requires detailed consideration. This paper is the first, to our knowledge, to propose considering the security of a two-way implementation of continuous-variable quantum key distribution, considering the trusted equipment noise.

Simple continuous-variable quantum key distribution scheme using a Sagnac-based Gaussian modulator.

Continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD) is a protocol that uses quantum mechanics to ensure that the distribution of an encryption key is secure even in the presence of eavesdroppers. The wide application of CV-QKD requires low cost, system simplicity, and system stability. However, owing to the particularity of Gaussian modulation in CV-QKD, an amplitude modulator (AM) and a bias controller are required, making the system structure complex and unstable. In this Letter, we achieve two-dimensional Gaussian modulation with only one phase modulator (PM) and a Sagnac ring structure, which significantly reduces the complexity of the system. We test the Gaussian modulation stability for 10 h, and the result shows that the expected secure key rate can be maintained at 80 kbit/s under a transmission distance of 50 km. This scheme opens up new, to the best of our knowledge, possibilities for a new generation of highly stable and simple CV-QKD systems.

Security Analysis of a Passive Continuous-Variable Quantum Key Distribution by Considering Finite-Size Effect.

We perform security analysis of a passive continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD) protocol by considering the finite-size effect. In the passive CV-QKD scheme, Alice utilizes thermal sources to passively make preparation of quantum state without Gaussian modulations. With this technique, the quantum states can be prepared precisely to match the high transmission rate. Here, both asymptotic regime and finite-size regime are considered to make a comparison. In the finite-size scenario, we illustrate the passive CV-QKD protocol against collective attacks. Simulation results show that the performance of passive CV-QKD protocol in the finite-size case is more pessimistic than that achieved in the asymptotic case, which indicates that the finite-size effect has a great influence on the performance of the single-mode passive CV-QKD protocol. However, we can still obtain a reasonable performance in the finite-size regime by enhancing the average photon number of the thermal state.

Experimental continuous-variable quantum key distribution using a thermal source

Gaussian-modulated coherent-state (GMCS) continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD) protocol can allow authenticated users to share secret key with unconditional security. So far, all previous experimental implementations of GMCS CVQKD schemes are based on active modulations, i.e. amplitude and phase modulators and quantum random number generator (QRNG) are required. However, high-speed modulation with high extinction ratio and stability is challenging, which is extremely remarkable in chip-scale silicon photonic realization. While the passive-state-preparation (PSP) CVQKD scheme, which explores the intrinsic field fluctuations of a thermal source, avoids the uses of active modulations and QRNG. In this paper, we experimentally realize the intact PSP CVQKD through a realistic optical fiber channel using off-the-shelf amplified spontaneous emission source. In particular, specially designed frame synchronization method is used to build the correlation between the data measured from the two legitimate parties, and excess noise are synthetically controlled to generate secure secret keys at the metro-area distances when considering the practical and non-negligible finite-size effects under collective Gaussian attacks. Due to the avoidance of modulators and QRNG, the passive state encoding scheme provides a promising direction of applicable high-speed, chip-based and even sunlight-based CVQKD with less cost and complexity.

Trans-Media Continuous-Variable Quantum Key Distribution via Untrusted Entanglement Source

We propose a continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD) scheme based on the atmosphere-to-seawater channel. In particular, an untrusted entanglement source (two modes of the compressed vacuum state, TMSV) is deployed on the surface of the seawater, each mode of TMSV is sent to one of the two legitimate parts, respectively. In this way, we can establish a trans-media CVQKD link between the atmosphere and the underwater. Meanwhile, a suitable non-Gaussian operation, namely photon subtraction, is introduced to enhance the performance of the trans-media CVQKD scheme. Security analysis shows that the proposed scheme can establish a trans-media quantum communication system on the atmosphere-to-seawater channel. Moreover, the maximum transmission distance can be further extended by using proper photon subtraction operation. Our scheme provides a guidance for applying CVQKD to trans-media channels.

Continuous-variable quantum key distribution based on peak-compensation

Continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD) is an important application of quantum technology, which enables long-distance communicating parties to establish a string of unconditionally secure keys in an insecure environment. However, in a practical CVQKD system, the finite sampling bandwidth of the analog-to-digital converter (ADC) at the receiver may create inaccurate sampling results, leading to errors in parameter estimation process and leaving a security loophole for eavesdroppers. In order to eliminate the finite sampling bandwidth effect, we propose a peak-compensation-based CVQKD scheme, which estimates the discrepancy between the maximum sampling value and the peak value of each pulse based on the characteristics of Gaussian pulse. The maximum sampling values are compensated by the estimated discrepancy, so that the legitimate parties can obtain correct sampling results. We analyze the influence of the finite sampling bandwidth on the security of the system, expounding the specific steps of peak-compensation, comparing the estimated excess noise before and after peak-compensation, and discussing the security of the system under Gaussian collective attacks. Simulation results show that this scheme can greatly improve the accuracy of pulse peak sampling and remove the finite sampling bandwidth effect. Moreover, the channel parameters estimated by the communicating parties are also corrected by using the compensated values. Compared with the scheme without peak-compensation, this scheme eliminates the limitation of the system repetition to the secret key bit rate, and has longer secure transmission distance and higher secret key bit rate. In addition, compared with other methods of solving the finite sampling bandwidth effect, the proposed scheme can be directly implemented in data processing stage after sampling without any additional devices, and thus increasing no complexity of the system.

Feasibility of quantum key distribution with macroscopically bright coherent light.

We address feasibility of continuous-variable quantum key distribution using bright multimode coherent states of light and homodyne detection. We experimentally verify the possibility to properly select signal modes by matching them with the local oscillator and this way to decrease the quadrature noise concerned with unmatched bright modes. We apply the results to theoretically predict the performance of continuous-variable quantum key distribution scheme using multimode coherent states in scenarios where modulation is applied either to all the modes or only to the matched ones, and confirm that the protocol is feasible at high overall brightness. Our results open the pathway towards full-scale implementation of quantum key distribution using bright light, thus bringing quantum communication closer to classical optics.

Subcarrier Domain of Multicarrier Continuous-Variable Quantum Key Distribution

The subcarrier domain of multicarrier continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD) is defined. In a multicarrier CVQKD scheme, the information is granulated into Gaussian subcarrier CVs and the physical Gaussian link is divided into Gaussian sub-channels. The subcarrier domain injects physical attributes to the description of the subcarrier transmission. We prove that the subcarrier domain is a natural representation of the subcarrier-level transmission in a multicarrier CVQKD scheme. We also extend the subcarrier domain to a multiple-access multicarrier CVQKD setting. We demonstrate the results through the adaptive multicarrier quadrature-division (AMQD) CVQKD scheme and the AMQD-MQA (multiuser quadrature allocation) multiple-access multicarrier scheme. The subcarrier domain representation provides a general apparatus that can be utilized for an arbitrary multicarrier CVQKD scenario.

Continuous-variable quantum key distribution based on high-rate phase reference

We propose a high-rate phase reference scheme for continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD). In this scheme, a transmission mode has been employed in which several quantum signal pulses are accompanied by a pair of reference pulses, calibrating the measurement bases of the communicating parties. Within a certain range, and with the ratio between quantum signal pulses and reference pulses increased, the secret key rate approaches that of the traditional CV-QKD scheme (which is a scheme without phase noise). Compared with general CV-QKD schemes, which adopt the transmission mode of a quantum signal pulse plus a pair of reference pulses, this scheme has a higher spectral efficiency, enabling high-rate CV-QKD. In addition, we reduce the interference of strong reference pulses with weak quantum signal pulses by using a pair of polarization beam splitters with a dynamic polarization controller. Simulation results demonstrate that we achieve a higher secret key rate than the self-coherent phase reference scheme. This provides a pathway towards large-scale quantum communication networks.

Practical Security Analysis of Self-Referenced CV-QKD System in the Presence of Polarization Aberration

How to remove local oscillator (LO) side channel attacks has been a notoriously hard problem in continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD). In the self-referenced CV-QKD schemes, the LO signal is locally generated at the receiver by an independent laser so that it is not co-transmitted with the quantum signal. This simple solution removes all LO side channels. However it also introduces some other practical vulnerabilities. Especially the polarization states of the quantum signal and LO signal may not be identical across the detector because of the presence of the polarization aberrations. Thus, the detection efficiency which is arguably the most critical experiment parameter of the practical implementation will be impaired. In this paper, we analyze the impact of polarization aberrations on the detection efficiency for CV-QKD and propose a self-referenced CV-QKD scheme in the presence of polarization aberrations by using an off-axis optical system. In the proposed scheme, the polarization states of the quantum signal would change with the off-axis optical system, thus impairing the heterodyne efficiency. Our security analysis shows a gap between the theory and practice of CV-QKD.

Continuous-variable quantum key distribution with non-Gaussian quantum catalysis

The non-Gaussian operation can be used not only to enhance and distill the entanglement between Gaussian entangled states, but also to improve quantum communications. In this paper, we propose an non-Gaussian continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD) by using quantum catalysis (QC), which is an intriguing non-Gaussian operation in essence that can be implemented with current technologies. We perform quantum catalysis on both ends of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) pair prepared by a sender, Alice, and find that for the single-photon QC-CVQKD, the bilateral symmetrical quantum catalysis (BSQC) performs better than the single-side quantum catalysis (SSQC). Attributing to characteristics of integral within an ordered product (IWOP) of operators, we find that the quantum catalysis operation can improve the entanglement property of Gaussian entangled states by enhancing the success probability of non-Gaussian operation, leading to the improvement of the QC-CVQKD system. As a comparison, the QC-CVQKD system involving zero-photon and single-photon quantum catalysis outperforms the previous non-Gaussian CVQKD scheme via photon subtraction in terms of secret key rate, maximal transmission distance and tolerable excess noise.

Performance analysis of the satellite-to-ground continuous-variable quantum key distribution with orthogonal frequency division multiplexed modulation

Continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD) is aiming at widespread application and adoption in different scenarios, and thus, the application of satellite-to-ground link may play a vital role in establishing the global secure quantum communications. In this paper, we propose an improved tunable CVQKD scheme for the satellite-to-ground free space optical (FSO) link in an orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) system. The OFDM-based CVQKD can effectively suppress the random fading effect that resulted from the atmospheric channel since it divides the initial transmission channel into multi-subcarriers working in parallel so as to compensate the weakness of single-channel transmission of the signals. Moreover, the influence of the intensity scintillation, atmospheric transmittance and phase noise caused by atmospheric turbulence is involved in security analysis. The results reveal that satellite-to-ground CVQKD system can reduce the atmosphere influence in an OFDM system. Compared with the single-channel CVQKD in the FSO link, the secret key rate is improved with the OFDM technique within a certain range of subcarrier numbers. Nevertheless, the reduction of symbols per channel cannot make the asymptotic assumption due to the limitation of technology and devices.

Notes on a Continuous-Variable Quantum Key Distribution Scheme

We develop a physical model to describe the signal transmission for a continuous-variable quantum key distribution scheme and investigate its security against a couple of eavesdropping attacks assuming that the eavesdropper’s power is partly restricted owing to today’s technological limitations. We consider an eavesdropper performing quantum optical homodyne measurement on the signal obtained by a type of beamsplitting attack. We also consider the case in which the eavesdropper Eve is unable to access a quantum memory and she performs heterodyne measurement on her signal without performing a delayed measurement. Our formulation includes a model in which the receiver’s loss and noise are unaccessible by the eavesdropper. This setup enables us to investigate the condition that Eve uses a practical fiber differently from the usual beamsplitting attack where she can deploy a lossless transmission channel. The secret key rates are calculated in both the direct and reverse reconciliation scenarios.

Improving continuous-variable quantum key distribution under local oscillator intensity attack using entanglement in the middle**Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 61379153, 61401519, and 61572529), the Natural Science Foundation of Hunan Province, China (Grant No. 2017JJ3415), the Science and Technology Project of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, China (Grant Nos. AC16380094 and 1598008-29), and the Natural

A modified continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD) protocol is proposed by originating the entangled source from a malicious third party Eve in the middle instead of generating it from the trustworthy Alice or Bob. This method is able to enhance the efficiency of the CVQKD scheme attacked by local oscillator (LO) intensity attack in terms of the generated secret key rate in quantum communication. The other indication of the improvement is that the maximum transmission distance and the maximum loss tolerance can be increased significantly, especially for CVQKD schemes based on homodyne detection.

Robust continuous-variable quantum key distribution against practical attacks

Recently, several practical attacks on continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD) were proposed based on faking the estimated value of channel excess noise to hide the intercept-and-resend eavesdropping strategy, including the local oscillator (LO) fluctuation, calibration, wavelength, and saturation attacks. However, the known countermeasures against all these practical attacks will inevitably increase the complexity of the implementation of CVQKD and affect its performance. We develop here an asynchronous countermeasure strategy without structural modifications of the conventional CVQKD scheme. In particular, two robust countermeasures are proposed by adding peak-valley seeking and Gaussian postselection steps in conventional data postprocessing procedure. The analysis shows that the peak-valley seeking method naturally make the schemes immune to all known types of calibration attacks even when Eve simultaneously performs wavelength or LO fluctuation attacks and exhibit simpler implementation and better performance than the known countermeasures. Meanwhile, since the Gaussian postselection is able to resist the saturation attacks, the proposed schemes are secure against all known types of practical attacks.