Color Perception Research Articles

Long-Lasting Neural Activity Indexed by Cognitive Function Underlying Unconscious Color Perception

Long-Lasting Neural Activity Indexed by Cognitive Function Underlying Unconscious Color Perception

A study on color visual perception of museum exhibition space based on eye movement experiments

Color is an essential element in the exhibition space of museums, influencing people’s visual experience. To quantitatively study the relationship between color and individual visual perception in museum exhibition spaces, the study used eye-tracking technology combined with a questionnaire, exploring the relationship between color and visual perception in the exhibition environments of history museums in terms of hue, saturation, and brightness of color. Taking the Ruijin Central Revolutionary Base in Jiangxi Province as a historical display space for research, the results show that when the saturation is 69–77%, or the hue is red (0°H), the exhibited. environments have stronger color attractiveness. The study demonstrated that the first fixation duration in eye movement data significantly negatively correlates with the subject’s personal preference, comfort, pleasure, and attractiveness. Researchers can use this as an evaluation parameter for visual perception of exhibition space.

The nature of multi-channel color perception from three photodetector types with wide overlapping spectral sensitivity bands

The nature of multi-channel color perception from three photodetector types with wide overlapping spectral sensitivity bands

Increasing intensity directly increases the perceived warmth of primary colors.

There is a long history of linking the perceptions of temperature and color (the "Hue-heat hypothesis"): red (R) and yellow (Y) are often considered warm, whereas blue (B) and green (G) are cool. Past studies, however, have largely used relatively broad-band light at a fixed intensity to test these relations. We tested whether increasing the intensity of highly saturated primary colors would lead to a concomitant change in the perceived temperature of those colors. 20 young healthy participants (M = 24.80±3.53 years; 45% female; 5% Hispanic; 45% non-White) with normal color vision were tested. An optical system with a Xenon-arc light source, chromatic filters (peak l = 465, 530, 572, 652nm), and a circular neutral density wedge to vary intensity were used (5 intensity levels). Temperature perception was assessed using an ordinal scale from - 5 (coolest) to + 5 (warmest). The order of the colors used and the intensity levels were varied randomly. Considering the average across intensity levels, B (-1.87) and G (+ 1.09) were considered the coolest, whereas Y (+ 2.1) and R (+ 3.75) were considered the warmest colors. All colors, however, warmed with increasing intensity. A linear regression fit to the averaged data across luminance explained the majority of the variance: B (r2 = 0.78), Y (r2 = 0.93), G (r2 = 0.98), and R (r2 = 0.92). Consistent with past data, our results show that color is significantly linked with temperature perception. Increasing the luminance of colors, however, strongly shifts the perception toward increased warmth.

Enhanced visual contrast suppression during peak psilocybin effects: Psychophysical results from a pilot randomized controlled trial.

In visual perception, an effect known as surround suppression occurs wherein the apparent contrast of a center stimulus is reduced when it is presented within a higher-contrast surrounding stimulus. Many key aspects of visual perception involve surround suppression, yet the neuromodulatory processes involved remain unclear. Psilocybin is a serotonergic psychedelic compound known for its robust effects on visual perception, particularly texture, color, object, and motion perception. We asked whether surround suppression is altered under peak effects of psilocybin. Using a contrast-matching task with different center-surround stimulus configurations, we measured surround suppression after 25mg of psilocybin compared with placebo (100mg niacin). Data on harms were collected, and no serious adverse events were reported. After taking psilocybin, participants (n = 6) reported stronger surround suppression of perceived contrast compared to placebo. Furthermore, we found that the intensity of subjective psychedelic visuals induced by psilocybin correlated positively with the magnitude of surround suppression. We note the potential relevance of our findings for the field of psychiatry, given that studies have demonstrated weakened visual surround suppression in both major depressive disorder and schizophrenia. Our findings are thus relevant to understanding the visual effects of psilocybin, and the potential mechanisms of visual disruption in mental health disorders.

A robust approach for balancing the color and light integrity of underwater images

Abstract As light travels under the deep water, it scatters and is absorbed, resulting in a loss of intensity and altered color perception—a phenomenon known as underwater light attenuation. Images captured under these low light conditions suffered from color distortions, as you go deeper, colors fade in this order: red, orange, and yellow, while green and blue become more prominent. The red channel experiences significant attenuation due to the scattering properties of light under the deep water. As a consequence, deep water images often display noticeable color casts. Researchers encounter various challenges when enhancing low-light underwater images, such as reduced contrast, detail loss, artifacts, noise, and color distortion. In this paper, we present a novel Adaptive Color and Light Correction (ACLC) method for color correction and an Intuitionistic Fuzzy Generator (IFG) for enhancing low-light underwater images. The proposed Adaptive Color and Light Correction (ACLC) method tackles color casts on individual pixels by considering the scene depth. The proposed Intuitionistic Fuzzy Generator (IFG) method balances the image contrast by computing an intuitionistic fuzzy image representation using the proposed IFG approach. Experimental results reveal that the proposed approach significantly improves the color quality and contrast of the output image. The proposed ACLC and IFG methods exceed existing underwater color correction and low-light image enhancement techniques in visual and quantitative evaluations, as evidenced by extensive experimentation on well-established underwater image datasets, such as UIEB, Ocean dark, and LSUI.

Health Effects Of Using Visual Display Terminal

Screen devices are widely used office tools around the world. We are also known as Visual Display Terminal (VDTs). The use of VDT causes health hazards due to the need for high levels of attention and concentration and constant sitting work. Musculoskeletal disorders such as back pain, upper extremity disorders, eye problems, fatigue, and stress are common in VDT users. The computer is a frequently used display device, and computer vision syndrome (CVS) has emerged as a leading occupational health problem. Symptoms of CVS include dry eye, eye fatigue, blurred vision, double vision, redness in the eyes, burning and stinging sensation in the eyes, increase or decrease in tears, double vision, delay in changing focus and color perception irregularities, and deterioration in near vision. Risks arising from screened vehicles can be avoided in healthy and safe working conditions where the work center is set up correctly and breaks are taken at regular intervals. Simple measures such as exercising regularly, taking short frequent breaks, and using a screen filter are important simple interventions to prevent work-related diseases in VDT users. Since VDT use is a frequent part of our lives, we wanted to draw attention to VDT-related disorders and provide simple interventions to prevent them.

Optic Neuritis and its Prevalence in Immunocompromised Patients: A Review Article

Optic neuritis is an inflammation that affects the optic nerve, causing vision loss, eye pain, and changes in color perception. The condition can be associated with autoimmune diseases such as multiple sclerosis (MS) or infections, especially in immunocompromised individuals such as HIV/AIDS patients or those undergoing chemotherapy. In these individuals, optic neuritis usually results from opportunistic infections like toxoplasmosis and syphilis, complicating diagnosis and treatment. In immunocompetent patients, optic neuritis may indicate autoimmune diseases like MS or neuromyelitis optica (NMO), with better prognoses when treated early with corticosteroids. However, in immunocompromised individuals, the prognosis tends to be worse due to underlying infections and a limited response to immunosuppressive treatment. The management of optic neuritis involves anti-inflammatory therapies and, in cases of infections, specific antimicrobials. Continuous clinical and visual follow-up is also crucial. Studies suggest that clinical outcomes vary depending on the etiology and the patient's immune status, highlighting the need for personalized therapeutic strategies. Early diagnosis is critical to improving vision and quality of life for patients.

Environmental therapy: interface design strategies for color graphics to assist navigational tasks in patients with visuospatial disorders through an analytic hierarchy process based on CIE color perception.

Environmental therapy theory has been applied in the research of disease prevention, and the effectiveness of using color and graphic designs to assist patients with spatial orientation has been confirmed. Visual-spatial impairments are common symptoms associated with cognitive decline. However, the interaction and driving factors between these impairments and spatial color and graphic designs remain unclear. This paper first discusses the correlation between the characteristics of visual-spatial impairments and environmental factors and then investigates the color preferences of such patients based on the CIE 1976 color system and the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). Subsequently, the paper explores spatial design strategies conducive to spatial orientation from the perspective of adaptability to pathological characteristics, utilizing case study analysis. (1) Pathological characteristics of visual-spatial impairments (such as difficulties in spatial orientation and spatial neglect) are related to environmental factors; (2) Emotional attachment factors play a key role in patients' perception of satisfaction with environmental colors; (3) Color associations have the potential to strengthen spatial memory. Additionally, interface designs with high luminance, low saturation, and clear color differentiation facilitate patients' recognition of space. This paper posits that spatial interface design is a feasible approach to assist with spatial orientation, and it achieves this through a mediating process that progresses from influencing visual stimuli to cognitive memory and then to behavioral orientation. The article provides insights into the operational feasibility of this method.

Towers of Kuwait Arabic Neurocognitive Assessment: A novel executive and visuospatial functions assessment tool added to the CERAD neuropsychological battery-Arabic version (CERAD-ArNB)

Assessment of executive and visuospatial neurocognitive domains is lacking in the Omani population, especially for elderly individuals with low educational levels. Therefore, the Towers of Kuwait-Arabic Neurocognitive Assessment (ToK-ArNA) was developed using similar psychometric features of Tower of London (ToL) test, and the unique architecture of Towers of Kuwait, with the potential to overcome the limitation of ToL color perception difficulties that might be encountered in subjects with hereditary or acquired color vision disorders. We enrolled 120 older Arabic-speaking Omanis from January 2022 to November 2022 and all participants underwent screening to ensure normal cognitive function before performing the ToL and ToK-ArNA tests. Validity, reliability, and non-parametric statistical tests were used for data analysis. A total of 85 participants, 51 men (60%) and 34 women (40%) met the inclusion criteria and completed the testing. Statistical analyses confirmed the validity and reliability of ToK-ArNA compared to ToL, with comparable total Time and Accuracy scores and more preference towered the ToK-ArNA among the participants. Despite the study limitations, these results indicate that the ToK-ArNA is a reliable and applicable executive and visuospatial function assessment tool and further studies are warranted to establish its validity in patients with various neurocognitive disorders

Effect of attention on ensemble perception: Comparison between exogenous attention, endogenous attention, and depth.

Ensemble perception is an important ability of human beings that allows one to extract summary information for scenes and environments that contain information that far exceeds the processing limit of the visual system. Although attention has been shown to bias ensemble perception, two important questions remain unclear: (1) whether direct manipulations on different types of spatial attention could produce similar effects on ensembles and (2) whether factors potentially influencing the attention distribution, such as depth perception, could evoke an indirect effect of attention on ensemble representation. This study aims to address these questions. In Experiments 1 and 2, two types of precues were used to evoke exogenous and endogenous attention, respectively, and the ensemble color perceptions were examined. We found that both exogenous and endogenous attention biased ensemble representation towards the attended items, and the latter produced a greater effect. In Experiments 3 and 4, we examined whether depth perception could affect color ensembles by indirectly influencing attention allocation in 3D space. The items were separated in two depth planes, and no explicit cues were applied. The results showed that color ensemble was biased to closer items when depth information was task relevant. This suggests that ensemble perception is naturally biased in 3D space, probably through the mechanism of attention. Computational modeling consistently showed that attention exerted a direct shift on the ensemble statistics rather than averaging the feature values over the cued and noncued items, providing evidence against an averaging process of individual perception.

Color perception and its relation to dental anxiety in children.

One of the major causes of dental anxiety in children is their first impression of the dental environment. Even minor details, such as the choice of color in a dental setting and the color of dental equipment, can positively influence a child's behavior. The aim of the study was to assess the relationship between the emotions in children and color combinations in a pediatric setting. The study involved 200 children (99 boys and 101 girls) aged between 6 and 12 years who visited the dental clinics at the College of Dentistry, Jazan University, for the first time between November 2017 and January 2018. The participants were divided into 2 groups based on age. The younger children group included participants aged from 6 to 9 years, while the older children group included participants aged from 10 to 12 years. Anxiety levels were recorded using the Modified Dental Anxiety Scale. Colored pencils and images of emoticons were provided to all children, who were instructed to color the negative and positive emoticons with their preferred colors. The analysis of anxiety levels among children in both groups revealed statistically significant differences across sexes in the younger age group, with girls being more anxious than boys (p = 0.003). Additionally, a statistically significant difference was observed in the choice of colors by children of both sexes in 2 age groups (p = 0.001). Most children were inclined towards bright colors and used them to express their emotions. The incorporation of colors in a dental setting could invoke positive emotions in children. Hence, the use of colors in the workplace has the potential to ease anxiety.

Efficacy of ChromaGen lenses in enhancing color perception in color vision deficiency: a critical evaluation

Aims: Despite advancements in color vision correction, evidence supporting the efficacy of ChromaGen haploscopic filter systems in improving color perception remains limited. This study primarily investigates the performance of ChromaGen lenses (CL). Methods: The study included 27 volunteers diagnosed with color vision deficiency (CVD). An anomaloscope was used to detect color vision defects. Participants underwent color vision tests (Ishihara and Panel D15) both with and without CL. The results were statistically analyzed. Results: All participants were male, aged 21 to 57. Among them, 12 (44%) had protan defect (10 protanopes, 2 protanomalies) and 15 (56%) had deutan defect (12 deuteranopes, 3 deuteranomalies). Without CL, protan defect participants read 2.0±1.0 pages on the Ishihara test, while deutan defect participants read 3.0±1.9 pages. With CL, protan defect participants read 4.5±2.2 pages and deutan defect participants read 14.2±0.9 pages, showing statistically significant improvement (p<0.05). The difference between protan and deutan groups was also statistically significant (p<0.05). In the Panel D15 test, without the use of CL 81% of individuals with protanopia and deuteranopia made significant errors, whereas participants with protanomaly and deuteranomaly performed well. No significant improvement was noted with CL in the Panel D15 results. Twenty-three participants preferred magenta and four preferred pink CL. Fifteen participants expressed interest in using CL solely to pass the Ishihara test. Conclusion: This study concludes that commercially available ChromaGen filters do not provide clinically significant evidence of improved subjective color perception. Therefore, recommending these devices to the CVD population for color perception may not be highly beneficial. However ChromaGen lenses may be used by some CVD patients to pass the Ishihara test.

Design of a virtual reality serious game for experiencing the colors of Dunhuang frescoes

With the rapid advancement of digital games, serious games have emerged as a significant medium for engaging with cultural heritage. As a primary visual element in cultural heritage, color plays a crucial role in users’ digital learning. However, there is currently a scarcity of serious game designs that specifically focus on cultural heritage colors, indicating potential for improvement in the user experience. To further enhance users’ perception of color and create a more engaging and enriching digital cultural heritage experience, this study proposes a virtual reality serious game (VR SG) design method specifically tailored to cultural heritage colors. Additionally, it explores the potential of VR SG in enhancing the education, entertainment, and dissemination aspects of these colors within cultural heritage. Specifically, we explore how to integrate relevant knowledge of cultural heritage colors into the application process of VR SG and assess users’ learning performance, engagement, and interactive willingness within these VR SG. The study employs the colors of the Dunhuang cave frescoes as a case study for design practice. A total of 30 participants took part in a between-group comparison experiment, utilizing a mixed-methods approach that combined quantitative and qualitative assessments to compare the performance of a VR SG with a VR exhibition game. The results indicate that both the VR SG and the VR exhibition game effectively enhance users’ understanding and retention of knowledge, with VR SG users demonstrating higher levels of task engagement, emotional engagement, willingness to explore, and willingness to share. This study confirms the potential of VR SG to enhance the education, entertainment, and dissemination aspects of cultural heritage colors and discusses the implications of VR SG in supporting digital cultural heritage experiences.

Urban Color Perception and Sentiment Analysis Based on Deep Learning and Street View Big Data

The acceleration of urbanization has resulted in a heightened awareness of the impacts of urban environments on residents’ emotional states. This present study focuses on the Lixia District of Jinan City. By using urban street view big data and deep learning methods, we undertook a detailed analysis of the impacts of urban color features on residents’ emotional perceptions. In particular, a substantial corpus of street scene image data was extracted and processed. This was performed using a deep convolutional neural network (DCNN) and semantic segmentation technology (PSPNet), which enabled the simulation and prediction of the subjective perception of the urban environment by humans. Furthermore, the color complexity and coordination in the street scene were quantified and combined with residents’ emotional feedback to carry out a multi-dimensional analysis. The findings revealed that color complexity and coordination were significant elements influencing residents’ emotional perceptions. A high color complexity is visually appealing, but can lead to fatigue, discomfort, and boredom; a moderate complexity stimulates vitality and pleasure; high levels of regional harmony and aesthetics can increase perceptions of beauty and security; and low levels of coordination can increase feelings of depression. The environmental characteristics of different areas and differences in the daily activities of residents resulted in regional differences regarding the impacts of color features on emotional perception. This study corroborates the assertion that environmental color coordination has the capacity to enhance residents’ emotions, thereby providing an important reference point for urban planning. Planning should be based on the functional characteristics of the region, and color complexity and coordination should be reasonably regulated to optimize the emotional experiences of residents. Differentiated color management enhances urban aesthetics, livability, and residents’ happiness and promotes sustainable development. In the future, the influences of color and environmental factors on emotions can be explored in depth, with a view to assist in the formulation of fine urban design.

CoolerSpace: A Language for Physically Correct and Computationally Efficient Color Programming

Color programmers manipulate lights, materials, and the resulting colors from light-material interactions. Existing libraries for color programming provide only a thin layer of abstraction around matrix operations. Color programs are, thus, vulnerable to bugs arising from mathematically permissible but physically meaningless matrix computations. Correct implementations are difficult to write and optimize. We introduce CoolerSpace to facilitate physically correct and computationally efficient color programming. CoolerSpace raises the level of abstraction of color programming by allowing programmers to focus on describing the logic of color physics. Correctness and efficiency are handled by CoolerSpace. The type system in CoolerSpace assigns physical meaning and dimensions to user-defined objects. The typing rules permit only legal computations informed by color physics and perception. Along with type checking, CoolerSpace also generates performance-optimized programs using equality saturation. CoolerSpace is implemented as a Python library and compiles to ONNX, a common intermediate representation for tensor computations. CoolerSpace not only prevents common errors in color programming, but also does so without run-time overhead: even unoptimized CoolerSpace programs out-perform existing Python-based color programming systems by up to 5.7 times; our optimizations provide up to an additional 1.4 times speed-up.

Fostering Inclusivity and Creativity: A Card Game for Color Perception and Inclusion

The gaming industry has undergone a dramatic transformation in recent years, with inclusivity emerging as a core value in the development of new games. Despite these efforts, there remains a gap in the inclusivity of visually impaired individuals in gaming. This paper seeks to address this gap by asking: How can game design enhance colour perception and inclusivity for visually impaired players? The industry has recognized the importance of addressing the needs of individuals with diverse needs and abilities and has responded with innovative approaches aimed at creating games that are accessible to all. One such approach is the development of a card game that has been meticulously designed to stimulate color perception and promote the inclusion of visually impaired individuals. Chroma Harmony is a pioneering mobile application meticulously crafted to facilitate users' understanding of color concepts and the outcomes of different color combinations. Its primary aim is to promote inclusivity by offering features tailored to individuals with visual impairments. Leveraging the innovative ColorADD system, it revolutionizes the perception and communication of color, thereby paving the way for enhanced participation in gaming among those with vision impairments. Its main objective is to paint a cube by combining cards in the player's possession to achieve the closest or exact combination to the objective. With each move, a new card is presented, challenging players to choose the best one to achieve their goals and improve their color perception abilities. By the end of the game, players will have a better understanding of how colors are combined, preparing them for real-world scenarios. Furthermore, the game features a multiplayer mode to foster a sense of community and healthy competition among players. This multiplayer mode not only promotes inclusivity but also provides an opportunity for players to collaborate and challenge each other fostering community sense. In terms of competencies and skills, this game aims to develop several key abilities in its users such as the ability to identify colors, the ability to combine different colors effectively and the necessary motivation and drive for results. By focusing on these competencies and skills, Chroma Harmony strives to provide a comprehensive and engaging experience for all players, regardless of their abilities or background. This study highlights the ongoing challenge in the gaming industry to enhance accessibility and inclusivity, especially for visually impaired individuals, while also standing as a testament to the industry's commitment to inclusivity and innovation, pushing the boundaries of what is possible in gaming.

Temporal and spatial analysis of event-related potentials in response to color saliency differences among various color vision types.

Human color vision exhibits significant diversity that cannot be fully explained by categorical classifications. Understanding how individuals with different color vision phenotypes perceive, recognize, and react to the same physical stimuli provides valuable insights into sensory characteristics. This study aimed to identify behavioral and neural differences between different color visions, primarily classified as typical trichromats and anomalous trichromats, in response to two chromatic stimuli, blue-green and red, during an attention-demanding oddball task. We analyzed the P3 component of event-related potentials (ERPs), associated with attention, and conducted a broad spatiotemporal exploration of neural differences. Behavioral responses were also analyzed to complement neural data. Participants included typical trichromats (n = 13) and anomalous trichromats (n = 5), and the chromatic stimuli were presented in an oddball paradigm. Typical trichromats exhibited faster potentiation from the occipital to parietal regions in response to the more salient red stimulus, particularly in the area overlapping with the P3 component. In contrast, anomalous trichromats revealed faster potentiation to the expected more salient blue-green stimulus in the occipital to parietal regions, with no other significant neural differences between stimuli. Comparisons between the color vision types showed no significant overall neural differences. The large variability in red-green sensitivity among anomalous trichromats, along with neural variability not fully explained by this sensitivity, likely contributed to the absence of clear neural distinctions based on color saliency. While reaction times were influenced by red-green sensitivity, neural signals showed ambiguity regarding saliency differences. These findings suggest that factors beyond red-green sensitivity influenced neural activity related to color perception and cognition in minority color vision phenotypes. Further research with larger sample sizes is needed to more comprehensively explore these neural dynamics and their broader implications.

A Clinical Comparison Between New and Conventional Methods for Quantification of Intended and Fabricated Dental Porcelain Color

Introduction: The accurate selection of dental porcelain shades is crucial for achieving natural-looking and aesthetically pleasing restorations. This study aimed to compare the effectiveness of various shade selection methods, including visual assessment, spectrophotometry, and intraoral scanning. Aims and Objectives: This study aims to improve the accuracy of shade selection in prosthodontics. To achieve this, it will compare digital, intraoral, and visual methods, identify factors influencing shade selection, develop educational guidelines for dentists, and minimize color discrepancies between chosen and final shades. Methods: A diverse group of 37 participants with 111 shades of teeth were involved. Three shade selection methods were employed: visual assessment using a shade guide, spectrophotometry with the VITA Easyshade Compact, and intraoral scanning with the Medit i700. The accuracy of each method was determined by comparing the selected shade to the fabricated porcelain restoration. Results: While digital methods (spectrophotometry and intraoral scanning) simplified the shade selection process, visual assessment, especially when performed by experienced dentists, consistently demonstrated higher accuracy. Factors such as lighting conditions and individual variations in color perception influenced the reliability of visual assessment. Discussion: The study emphasizes the importance of a comprehensive approach to shade selection, combining both visual and digital methods. Digital tools offer objective measurements, while visual assessment captures subtle nuances in color and ensures patient satisfaction. Conclusion: The optimal shade selection method depends on the specific clinical situation and the dentist's expertise. By incorporating both visual and digital techniques, dental professionals can enhance the accuracy and reliability of shade selection, ultimately leading to more natural-looking and aesthetically pleasing dental restorations.

Impact of Substrate Material, Esthetic Material Thickness, and Cement on Color Reproduction in Implant-Supported Fixed Restorations.

Purpose This study aimed to evaluate the impact of substrate material, esthetic material type and thickness, and cement shade on the final color reproduction of implant-supported fixed restorations. The goal was to identify optimal combinations for achieving clinically acceptable esthetic outcomes. Material and methods An in vitro study was conducted using four substrate materials, hybrid polyetherketoneketone (PEEK)-based ceramic-reinforced polymer (BioHPP), chromium-cobalt alloy (CrCo), grade 5 titanium (Ti), and white zirconium oxide ceramic (WZirCAD), and three esthetic materials, lithium disilicate ceramic (e.max CAD), polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA), and zirconia oxide ceramic (e.max ZirCAD), at five different thicknesses (0.5, 1, 1.5, 2, and 2.5 mm). Color differences (ΔE*) were measured using a spectrophotometer, both with and without cement application. Statistical analysis was performed using the Kruskal-Wallis test and Bonferroni correction to assess the effects of material combinations on color reproduction. Results The study found that a 1 mm thickness of e.max CAD on BioHPP and CrCo substrates provided the best color matching, with ΔE* values closest to clinical acceptability. PMMA showed higher ΔE* values, indicating lower color stability compared to e.max CAD and e.max ZirCAD. Cement shade had a near-significant influence on final color perception, particularly with e.max ZirCAD on CrCo substrates. Conclusions The study suggests that using e.max CAD at 1 mm thickness on BioHPP or CrCo substrates provides superior esthetic results, underscoring the need for careful material selection in clinical practice. Further in vivo research is recommended to validate these findings and explore long-term outcomes.