Cooperativity In ATP Hydrolysis Research Articles

Cooperativity in ATP Hydrolysis by MopR Is Modulated by Its Signal Reception Domain and by Its Protein and Phenol Concentrations.

The NtrC family of AAA+ proteins are bacterial transcriptional regulators that control σ54-dependent RNA polymerase transcription under certain stressful conditions. MopR, which is a member of this family, is responsive to phenol and stimulates its degradation. Biochemical studies to understand the role of ATP and phenol in oligomerization and allosteric regulation, which are described here, show that MopR undergoes concentration-dependent oligomerization in which dimers assemble into functional hexamers. The oligomerization occurs in a nucleation-dependent manner with a tetrameric intermediate. Additionally, phenol binding is shown to be responsible for shifting MopR's equilibrium from a repressed state (high affinity toward ATP) to a functionally active, derepressed state with low-affinity for ATP. Based on these findings, we propose a model for allosteric regulation of MopR. IMPORTANCE The NtrC family of bacterial transcriptional regulators are enzymes with a modular architecture that harbor a signal sensing domain followed by a AAA+ domain. MopR, a NtrC family member, responds to phenol and activates phenol adaptation pathways that are transcribed by σ54-dependent RNA polymerases. Our results show that for efficient ATP hydrolysis, MopR assembles as functional hexamers and that this activity of MopR is regulated by its effector (phenol), ATP, and protein concentration. Our findings, and the kinetic methods we employ, should be useful in dissecting the allosteric mechanisms of other AAA+ proteins, in general, and NtrC family members in particular.

Insights into the Cooperative Nature of ATP Hydrolysis in Actin Filaments

Actin filaments continually assemble and disassemble within a cell. Assembled filaments “age” as a bound nucleotide ATP within each actin subunit quickly hydrolyzes followed by a slower release of the phosphate Pi, leaving behind a bound ADP. This subtle change in nucleotide state of actin subunits affects filament rigidity as well as its interactions with binding partners. We present here a systematic multiscale ultra-coarse-graining approach that provides a computationally efficient way to simulate a long actin filament undergoing ATP hydrolysis and phosphate-release reactions while systematically taking into account available atomistic details. The slower conformational changes and their dependence on the chemical reactions are simulated with the ultra-coarse-graining model by assigning internal states to the coarse-grained sites. Each state is represented by a unique potential surface of a local heterogeneous elastic network. Internal states undergo stochastic transitions that are coupled to conformations of the underlying molecular system. The model reproduces mechanical properties of the filament and allows us to study whether conformational fluctuations in actin subunits produce cooperative filament aging. We find that the nucleotide states of neighboring subunits modulate the reaction kinetics, implying cooperativity in ATP hydrolysis and Pi release. We further systematically coarse grain the system into a Markov state model that incorporates assembly and disassembly, facilitating a direct comparison with previously published models. We find that cooperativity in ATP hydrolysis and Pi release significantly affects the filament growth dynamics only near the critical G-actin concentration, whereas far from it, both cooperative and random mechanisms show similar growth dynamics. In contrast, filament composition in terms of the bound nucleotide distribution varies significantly at all monomer concentrations studied. These results provide new insights, to our knowledge, into the cooperative nature of ATP hydrolysis and Pi release and the implications it has for actin filament properties, providing novel predictions for future experimental studies.

Insights into the Cooperative Nature of ATP Hydrolysis in Actin Filaments

Actin filaments continually assemble and disassemble in the cell cytoplasm, during which they age as the nucleotides bound to newly added actin sub-units hydrolyze from ATP to an intermediate ADP-Pi, followed by a slower release of Pi to form ADP. This results into a spatial distribution of all three states of the bound nucleotide along the growing filament. It is not fully understood whether ATP hydrolysis and Pi release in a growing actin filament are spatially cooperative or purely random. Using a bottom-up multi-scale coarse-grained modeling strategy, we design simulations to study cooperativity in these reactions and find that the reactions are indeed cooperative to a certain extent. At first level of coarse-graining, we construct an ultra-coarse-grained (UCG) model based on atomistic simulations of short actin filaments. The UCG model agrees with experiments in terms of mechanical properties such as persistence length, which is governed by the bound nucleotide's state. The model also predicts that states of the bound nucleotides of neighboring sub-units significantly modulate the reaction kinetics, implying cooperativity especially in the slower Pi release reaction. We further coarse-grain the system into a Markov state model that incorporates assembly and disassembly, and the cooperativity predicted by the UCG model. The model reveals that cooperativity in ATP hydrolysis and Pi release has significant effects on the filament growth dynamics, but only near the critical g-actin monomer concentration. Filament dynamics are robust to the mechanism of hydrolysis far from the critical concentration and both cooperative and random mechanisms show similar growth dynamics. On the contrary, the filament composition in terms of the bound nucleotide distribution varies significantly at all monomer concentrations studied. These results provide new insights into the mechanism of ATP hydrolysis and its implications on actin filament properties.

Interdomain regulation of the ATPase activity of the ABC transporter haemolysin B from Escherichia coli.

Type 1 secretion systems (T1SS) transport a wide range of substrates across both membranes of Gram-negative bacteria and are composed of an outer membrane protein, a membrane fusion protein and an ABC (ATP-binding cassette) transporter. The ABC transporter HlyB (haemolysin B) is part of a T1SS catalysing the export of the toxin HlyA in E. coli HlyB consists of the canonical transmembrane and nucleotide-binding domains. Additionally, HlyB contains an N-terminal CLD (C39-peptidase-like domain) that interacts with the transport substrate, but its functional relevance is still not precisely defined. In the present paper, we describe the purification and biochemical characterization of detergent-solubilized HlyB in the presence of its transport substrate. Our results exhibit a positive co-operativity in ATP hydrolysis. We characterized further the influence of the CLD on kinetic parameters by using an HlyB variant lacking the CLD (HlyB∆CLD). The biochemical parameters of HlyB∆CLD revealed an increased basal maximum velocity but no change in substrate-binding affinity in comparison with full-length HlyB. We also assigned a distinct interaction of the CLD and a transport substrate (HlyA1), leading to an inhibition of HlyB hydrolytic activity at low HlyA1 concentrations. At higher HlyA1 concentrations, we observed a stimulation of the hydrolytic activities of both HlyB and HlyB∆CLD, which was completely independent of the interaction of HlyA1 with the CLD. Notably, all observed effects on ATPase activity, which were also analysed in detail by mass spectrometry, were independent of the HlyA1 secretion signal. These results assign an interdomain regulatory role for the CLD modulating the hydrolytic activity of HlyB.

Sensing Cooperativity in ATP Hydrolysis for Single Multisubunit Enzymes in Solution

Cooperative interactions are critical for multisubunit enzymes to fulfill their enzymatic cycle in a coordinated fashion. To study this poorly understood process in the mammalian double-ring 16-subunit chaperonin TRiC/CCT, ATP number distributions in various hydrolyzed states are measured for single copies of the enzyme as each of the subunits can bind and hydrolyze ATP. Fluorescent-nucleotide-bound chaperonins are localized in free solution by closed-loop feedback provided by an Anti-Brownian ELectrokinetic trap (ABEL trap), producing fluorescence emission traces which allow determination of the number of nucleotides on each enzyme. As ADP molecules are dissociating from the chaperonin, the single peak at eight ADP bound simply falls in height over time, indicating a highly cooperative ADP release process difficult to observe by ensemble-averaged methods (figure).By adding AlFx during ATP incubation, ATP transition state mimics (ADP•AlFx) are locked to the complex and show a dominant peak at 8 nucleotides for all incubation concentrations above 25 μM. Although ensemble averages of the single-molecule data can be matched with standard cooperativity models, surprisingly, the observed number distributions depart significantly from standard models and reveal stronger cooperativity, illustrating the power of the single-molecule distribution-based approach.View Large Image | View Hi-Res Image | Download PowerPoint Slide

Sensing cooperativity in ATP hydrolysis for single multisubunit enzymes in solution

In order to operate in a coordinated fashion, multisubunit enzymes use cooperative interactions intrinsic to their enzymatic cycle, but this process remains poorly understood. Accordingly, ATP number distributions in various hydrolyzed states have been obtained for single copies of the mammalian double-ring multisubunit chaperonin TRiC/CCT in free solution using the emission from chaperonin-bound fluorescent nucleotides and closed-loop feedback trapping provided by an Anti-Brownian ELectrokinetic trap. Observations of the 16-subunit complexes as ADP molecules are dissociating shows a peak in the bound ADP number distribution at 8 ADP, whose height falls over time with little shift in the position of the peak, indicating a highly cooperative ADP release process which would be difficult to observe by ensemble-averaged methods. When AlFx is added to produce ATP hydrolysis transition state mimics (ADP·AlFx) locked to the complex, the peak at 8 nucleotides dominates for all but the lowest incubation concentrations. Although ensemble averages of the single-molecule data show agreement with standard cooperativity models, surprisingly, the observed number distributions depart from standard models, illustrating the value of these single-molecule observations in constraining the mechanism of cooperativity. While a complete alternative microscopic model cannot be defined at present, the addition of subunit-occupancy-dependent cooperativity in hydrolysis yields distributions consistent with the data.

An Interaction between the Walker A and D-loop Motifs Is Critical to ATP Hydrolysis and Cooperativity in Bacteriophage T4 Rad50

The ATP binding cassette (ABC) proteins make up a large superfamily with members coming from all kingdoms. The functional form of the ABC protein nucleotide binding domain (NBD) is dimeric with ATP binding sites shared between subunits. The NBD is defined by six motifs: the Walker A, Q-loop, Signature, Walker-B, D-loop, and H-loop. The D-loop contains a conserved aspartate whose function is not clear but has been proposed to be involved in cross-talk between ATP binding sites. Structures of various ABC proteins suggest an interaction between the D-loop aspartate and an asparagine residue located in Walker A loop of the opposing subunit. Here, we evaluate the functional role of the D-loop using a bacteriophage T4 ABC protein, Rad50 (gp46). Mutation of either the D-loop aspartate or the Walker A asparagine results in dramatic reductions in ATP affinity, hydrolysis rate, and cooperativity. The mutant proteins bind Mre11 (gp47) and DNA normally, but no longer support the ATP-dependent nuclease activities of Mre11. We propose that the D-loop aspartate functions to stabilize the Walker A asparagine in a position favorable for catalysis. We find that the asparagine is crucially important to the mechanism of ATP hydrolysis by increasing the affinity for ATP and positioning the γ-phosphate of ATP for catalysis. Additionally, we propose that the asparagine acts as a γ-phosphate sensor and, through its interaction with the conserved D-loop aspartate, transmits conformational changes across the dimer interface to the second ATP binding site.

Sensor I Threonine of the AAA+ ATPase Transcriptional Activator PspF Is Involved in Coupling Nucleotide Triphosphate Hydrolysis to the Restructuring of σ54-RNA Polymerase

Transcriptional initiation invariably involves the transition from a closed RNA polymerase (RNAP) promoter complex to a transcriptional competent open complex. Activators of the bacterial sigma(54)-RNAP are AAA+ proteins that couple ATP hydrolysis to restructure the sigma(54)-RNAP promoter complex. Structures of the sigma(54) activator PspF AAA+ domain (PspF(1-275)) bound to sigma(54) show two loop structures proximal to sigma(54) as follows: the sigma(54) contacting the GAFTGA loop 1 structure and loop 2 that classifies sigma(54) activators as pre-sensor 1 beta-hairpin AAA+ proteins. We report activities for PspF(1-275) mutated in the AAA+ conserved sensor I threonine/asparagine motif (PspF(1-275)(T148A), PspF(1-275)(N149A), and PspF(1-275)(N149S)) within the second region of homology. We show that sensor I asparagine plays a direct role in ATP hydrolysis. However, low hydrolysis rates are sufficient for functional output in vitro. In contrast, PspF(1-275)(T148A) has severe defects at the distinct step of sigma(54) promoter restructuring. This defect is not because of the failure of PspF(1-275)(T148A) to stably engage with the closed sigma(54) promoter, indicating (i) an important role in ATP hydrolysis-associated motions during energy coupling for remodeling and (ii) distinguishing PspF(1-275)(T148A) from PspF(1-275) variants involved in signaling to the GAFTGA loop 1, which fail to stably engage with the promoter. Activities of loop 2 PspF(1-275) variants are similar to those of PspF(1-275)(T148A) suggesting a functional signaling link between Thr(148) and loop 2. In PspF(1-275) this link relies on the conserved nucleotide state-dependent interaction between the Walker B residue Glu(108) and Thr(148). We propose that hydrolysis is relayed via Thr(148) to loop 2 creating motions that provide mechanical force to the GAFTGA loop 1 that contacts sigma(54).

ATP-Mediated Conformational Changes in the RecA Filament

The crystal structure of the E. coli RecA protein was solved more than 10 years ago, but it has provided limited insight into the mechanism of homologous genetic recombination. Using electron microscopy, we have reconstructed five different states of RecA-DNA filaments. The C-terminal lobe of the RecA protein is modulated by the state of the distantly bound nucleotide, and this allosteric coupling can explain how mutations and truncations of this C-terminal lobe enhance RecA's activity. A model generated from these reconstructions shows that the nucleotide binding core is substantially rotated from its position in the RecA crystal filament, resulting in ATP binding between subunits. This simple rotation can explain the large cooperativity in ATP hydrolysis observed for RecA-DNA filaments.

Nested allosteric interactions in the cytoplasmic chaperonin containing TCP-1.

Initial rates of ATP hydrolysis by the chaperonin containing TCP-1 (CCT) from bovine testis were measured as a function of ATP concentration. Two allosteric transitions are observed: one at relatively low concentrations of ATP (<100 microM) and the second at higher concentrations of ATP. The data suggest that CCT has positive intra-ring cooperativity and negative inter-ring cooperativity in ATP hydrolysis, with respect to ATP, as previously observed in the case of GroEL. It is shown that the relatively weak positive intra-ring cooperativity found in the case of CCT may be due to heterogeneity in its subunit composition. Our results suggest that nested allosteric behavior may be common to chaperone double-ring systems.

The RadA protein from a hyperthermophilic archaeon Pyrobaculum islandicum is a DNA-dependent ATPase that exhibits two disparate catalytic modes, with a transition temperature at 75 degrees C.

The radA gene is an archaeal homolog of bacterial recA and eukaryotic RAD51 genes, which are critical components in homologous recombination and recombinational DNA repair. We cloned the radA gene from a hyperthermophilic archaeon, Pyrobaculum islandicum, overproduced the radA gene product in Escherichia coli and purified it to homogeneity. The purified P. islandicum RadA protein maintained its secondary structure and activities in vitro at high temperatures, up to 87 degrees C. It also showed high stability of 18.3 kcal.mol-1 (76.5 kJ.mol-1) at 25 degrees C and neutral pH. P. islandicum RadA exhibited activities typical of the family of RecA-like proteins, such as the ability to bind ssDNA, to hydrolyze ATP in a DNA-dependent manner and to catalyze DNA strand exchange. At 75 degrees C, all DNAs tested stimulated ATPase activity of the RadA. The protein exhibited a break in the Arrhenius plot of ATP hydrolysis at 75 degrees C. The cooperativity of ATP hydrolysis and ssDNA-binding ability of the protein above 75 degrees C were higher than at lower temperatures, and the activation energy of ATP hydrolysis was lower above this break point temperature. These results suggest that the ssDNA-dependent ATPase activity of P. islandicum RadA displays a temperature-dependent capacity to exist in two different catalytic modes, with 75 degrees C being the critical threshold temperature.

Role of the GroEL Chaperonin Intermediate Domain in Coupling ATP Hydrolysis to Polypeptide Release

Modification of the Escherichia coli chaperonin GroEL with N-ethylmaleimide at residue Cys138 affects the structural and functional integrity of the complex. Nucleotide affinity and ATPase activity of the modified chaperonin are increased, whereas cooperativity of ATP hydrolysis and affinity for GroES are reduced. As a consequence, release and folding of substrate proteins are strongly impaired and uncoupled from ATP hydrolysis in a temperature-dependent manner. Folding of dihydrofolate reductase at 25 degrees C becomes dependent on GroES, whereas folding of typically GroES-dependent proteins is blocked completely. At 37 degrees C, GroES binding is restored to normal levels, and the modified GroEL regains its chaperone activity to some extent. These results assign a central role to the intermediate GroEL domain for transmitting conformational changes between apical and central domains, and for coupling ATP hydrolysis to productive protein release.

A single mutation at the catalytic site of TF 1-α 3β 3γ complex switches the kinetics of ATP hydrolysis from negative to positive cooperativity

Previously, we reported the substitution of Tyr 341 of the F 1-ATPase β subunit from a thermophilic Bacillus strain PS3 with leucine, cysteine, or alanine (M. Odaka et al. J. Biochem., 115 (1994) 789–796). These mutations resulted in a great decrease in the affinity of the isolated β subunit for ATP-Mg and an increase in the apparent K m of the α 3β 3γ complex in ATP hydrolysis when examined above 0.1 mM ATP. Here, we examined the ATPase activity of the mutant complexes in a wide range of ATP concentration and found that the mutants exhibited apparent positive cooperativity in ATP hydrolysis. This is the first clear demonstration that a single mutation in the catalytic sites converts the kinetics from apparent negative cooperativity in the wild-type α 3β 3γ complex to apparent positive cooperativity. The conversion of apparent cooperativity could be explained in terms of a simple kinetic scheme based on the binding change model proposed by Boyer.

The Maltose Transport System of Escherichia coli Displays Positive Cooperativity in ATP Hydrolysis

Maltose transport across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli is catalyzed by a periplasmic binding protein-dependent transport system and energized by ATP. The maltose system, a member of the ATP-binding cassette or ABC transport family, contains two copies of an ATP-binding protein in a complex with two integral membrane proteins. ATP hydrolysis by the transport complex can be assayed following reconstitution into proteoliposomes in the presence of maltose binding protein and maltose. Mutations in the transport complex that permit binding protein-independent transport render ATP hydrolysis constitutive so that hydrolysis can also be assayed with the transport complex in detergent solution. We have used both of these systems to study the role of two ATP binding sites in ATP hydrolysis. We found that both the wild-type and the binding protein-independent systems hydrolyzed ATP with positive cooperativity, suggesting that the two ATP binding sites interact. Vanadate inhibited the ATPase activity of the transport complex with 50% inhibition occurring at 10 mum vanadate. In detergent solution, the degree of cooperativity in the binding protein-independent complex decreased with increasing pH. The loss of cooperativity was accompanied by a decrease in ATPase activity and a decrease in sensitivity to vanadate. Because reconstitution of the complex into a lipid bilayer prevented the loss of cooperativity, we expect that ATP hydrolysis is cooperative in vivo. The mutations leading to binding protein-independent transport do not significantly alter the affinity, cooperativity, vanadate sensitivity, or substrate specificity of the ATP binding sites during hydrolysis. These results justify the use of the binding protein-independent system to investigate the mechanism of transport and hydrolysis.

Nested cooperativity in the ATPase activity of the oligomeric chaperonin GroEL

Initial rates of ATP hydrolysis by wild-type GroEL were measured as a function of ATP concentration from 0 to 0.8 mM. Two allosteric transitions are observed: one at relatively low ATP concentrations (< or = 100 microM) and the second at higher concentrations of ATP with respective midpoints of about 16 and 160 microM. Two allosteric transitions were previously observed also in the case of the Arg-196-->Ala GroEL mutant [Yifrach, O., & Horovitz, A. (1994) J. Mol. Biol. 243, 397-401]. On the basis of these observations a mathematical model for nested cooperativity in ATP hydrolysis by GroEL is developed in which there are two levels of allostery: one within each ring and the second between rings. In the first level, each hepatameric ring is in equilibrium between the T and R states, in accordance with the Monod-Wyman-Changeux (MWC) model of cooperativity [Monod et al. (1965) J. Mol. Biol. 12, 88-118]. A second level of allostery is between the rings of the GroEL particle which undergoes sequential Koshland-Némethy-Filmer (KNF)-type transitions from the TT state via the TR state to the RR state [Koshland et al. (1966) Biochemistry 5, 365-385]. Using our model, we estimate the values of the Hill coefficient for the negative cooperativity between rings in wild-type GroEL and the Arg-196-->Ala mutant to be 0.003 (+/- 0.001) and 0.07 (+/- 0.02), respectively. The inter-ring coupling free energies in wild-type GroEL and the Arg-196-->Ala mutant are -7.5 (+/- 0.4) and -3.9 (+/- 0.3) kcal mol-1, respectively.

Residue lysine-34 in GroES modulates allosteric transitions in GroEL.

The conserved residue Lys-34 in GroES was replaced by alanine and glutamic acid using site-directed mutagenesis. This residue is near the carboxy terminus of the mobile loop in GroES (residues 17-32) which becomes immobilized upon formation of the GroEL/GroES complex [Landry et al. (1993) Nature 364, 255-258]. Both charge neutralization (Lys-34-->Ala) and charge reversal (Lys-34-->Glu) at this position have little effect on the binding constant of GroES to GroEL, but they increase the enhancement by GroES of cooperativity in ATP hydrolysis by GroEL. This is reflected by a change in the Hill coefficient (at 10 mM K+) from 4.10 (+/- 0.22) in the presence of wild-type GroES to 5.17 (+/- 0.24) and 4.46 (+/- 0.14) in the presence of the GroES mutants Lys-34-->Ala and Lys-34-->Glu, respectively. The results are interpreted using the Monod-Wyman-Changeux (MWC) model for cooperativity [Monod et al. (1965) J. Mol. Biol. 12, 88-118]. They suggest that Lys-34 in GroES modulates the allosteric transition in GroEL by stabilizing a relaxed (R)-like state.

Mutation Ala2 → Ser Destabilizes Intersubunit Interactions in the Molecular Chaperone GroEL

The mutations Ala2 → Ser in the molecular chaperone GroEL increases positive co-operativity in ATP hydrolysis, as reflected by a change in the Hill coefficient from 2·36(±0·23) for wild-type to 3·19(±0·17) for the mutant. This amino acid replacement destabilizes the oligomeric structure of GroEL. It is shown that adenine nucleotides also have a specific destabilizing effect which is more pronounced in the case of the Ala2 → Ser mutant. Addition of GroES or the non-folded protein ligand rhodanese blocks the destabilizing effect of adenine nucleotides for both wild-type and mutant. The results are interpreted using the Monod-Wyman-Changeux (MWC) model for co-operatively.

Cooperativity in ATP hydrolysis by GroEL is increased by GroES

The kinetics of ATP hydrolysis by the ‘molecular chaperone’ GroEL and the inhibition of this hydrolysis by GroES have been studied in more detail. It is shown that the hydrolysis of ATP by GroEL is cooperative with respect to ATP with a Hill coefficient of 1.86 (±0.13). In the presence or GroES, there is an increase in the degree of cooperativity with a Hill coefficient of 3.01 (±0.18). The observed cooperativity is not due to dissociation of the GroEL oligomer into smaller units but more probably involves structural changes within the GroEL oligomer.