Circular Permutation Assay Research Articles

Kinetic Basis of the Bifunctionality of SsoII DNA Methyltransferase.

Type II restriction–modification (RM) systems are the most widespread bacterial antiviral defence mechanisms. DNA methyltransferase SsoII (M.SsoII) from a Type II RM system SsoII regulates transcription in its own RM system in addition to the methylation function. DNA with a so-called regulatory site inhibits the M.SsoII methylation activity. Using circular permutation assay, we show that M.SsoII monomer induces DNA bending of 31° at the methylation site and 46° at the regulatory site. In the M.SsoII dimer bound to the regulatory site, both protein subunits make equal contributions to the DNA bending, and both angles are in the same plane. Fluorescence of TAMRA, 2-aminopurine, and Trp was used to monitor conformational dynamics of DNA and M.SsoII under pre-steady-state conditions by stopped-flow technique. Kinetic data indicate that M.SsoII prefers the regulatory site to the methylation site at the step of initial protein–DNA complex formation. Nevertheless, in the presence of S-adenosyl-l-methionine, the induced fit is accelerated in the M.SsoII complex with the methylation site, ensuring efficient formation of the catalytically competent complex. The presence of S-adenosyl-l-methionine and large amount of the methylation sites promote efficient DNA methylation by M.SsoII despite the inhibitory effect of the regulatory site.

Straight core structure of DNA replication origins in the mammalian AMPD2 locus

Identification of the nucleotide consensus sequence in mammalian replication origins is a difficult and controversial problem. The hypothesis that local DNA topology could be involved in recognition by replication proteins is an exciting possibility. Secondary DNA structures, including intrinsically bent DNA, can be easily detected, and they may indicate a specific pattern in or near mammalian replication origins. This work presents the entire mapping of the intrinsically bent DNA sites (IBDSs), using in silico analysis and a circular permutation assay, of the DNA replication origins oriGNAI3, oriC, oriB, and oriA in the mammalian amplified AMPD2 gene domain. The results show that each origin presents an IBDS that flanks the straight core of these DNA replication sites. In addition, the in silico prediction of the nucleosome positioning reveals a strong indication that the center of an IBDS is localized in a nucleosome-free region (NFR). The structure of each of these curved sites is presented together with their helical parameters and topology. Together, the data that we present here indicate that the oriGNAI3 origin where preferential firing to the replication initiation events in the amplified AMPD2 domain occurs is the only origin that presents a straight, narrow region that is flanked on both sides by two intrinsically bent DNA sites within a short distance (~300 bp); however, all of the origins present at least one IBDS, which is localized in the NFR region. These results indicate that structural features could be implicated in the mammalian DNA replication origin and support the possibility of detecting and characterizing these segments.

The properties of NodD were affected by mere variation in length within its hinge region

In Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae, NodD, a member of the LysR-type transcriptional regulators, while auto-regulating, activates transcription of other nod genes in the presence of naringenin. A hinge region of NodD was previously identified in our laboratory as a functional region independent of its N-terminal DNA-binding and C-terminal regulatory domain. Further study was carried out to see the possible effect of the length variation in the hinge region on NodD properties. To our surprise, as many as seven classes of phenotypes were observed. Class I is deficient of activating nodA transcription and abolishes auto-regulation; class II is able to activate nodA transcription independently of naringenin and abolishes auto-regulation; class III retains autoregulating but partial activating ability; class IV is able to activate transcription independently of naringenin and retains auto-regulation; in class V, nodA is transcribed constitutively but the transcription level is drastically down-regulated in the presence of naringenin; in class VI, nodA is transcribed constitutively with higher induction ratio; in class VII, nodA is transcribed constitutively with lower induction ratio. To learn more about the possible mechanism, circular permutation assays were done, which showed that the length variation of the hinge of NodD caused by mutation led to the change in bend angles of nod promoter. This finding should help to get an insight into how transcriptional regulation is mediated by NodD at the molecular level as well as to understand the regulatory system of this important family.

Ss-LrpB from Sulfolobus solfataricus Condenses about 100 Base Pairs of Its Own Operator DNA into Globular Nucleoprotein Complexes

Ss-LrpB from the hyperthermoacidophilic crenarchaeote Sulfolobus solfataricus P2 is a member of the Lrp-like family of Bacterial/Archaeal transcription regulators that binds its own control region at three regularly spaced and partially conserved 15-bp-long imperfect palindromes. We have used atomic force microscopy to analyze the architecture of Ss-LrpB.DNA complexes with a different stoichiometry formed with the wild type operator and with an operator mutant. Binding of dimeric Ss-LrpB to all three target sites is accompanied by the formation of globular complexes, in which the protein induces strong DNA deformations. Furthermore, DNA contour length foreshortening of these complexes indicates DNA wrapping, with about 100 bp being condensed. The average bending angle is 260 degrees . The establishment of protein-protein contacts between Ss-LrpB dimers in these globular complexes will contribute to the cooperativity of the binding. The profound remodeling of the control region is expected to have a strong impact on gene expression and might constitute the key element in the autoregulatory process.

Modulating DNA bending affects NodD-mediated transcriptional control in Rhizobium leguminosarum

Rhizobium leguminosarum NodD binds to the nod box of the inducible nod gene nodA as a V-shaped tetramer and bends the nod box. In this work, we show that the nod gene inducer naringenin decreased gel mobility of nod box DNA–NodD complexes by sharpening the NodD-induced DNA bend, which correlated with nodA transcription activation. NodD can induce different DNA bends when the distance between the two half-sites of the nod box was modified, which severely affected NodD-mediated transcriptional control. One or two base pairs were deleted from, or inserted into, the two half-sites of the nod box of nodA. Circular permutation assays showed that such distance modulations allowed NodD to induce relaxed or sharpened DNA bending. In the case of 1 bp deletion, where the DNA bends were more relaxed than in the wild type, nodA transcription was repressed both in the absence and in the presence of inducer naringenin. In the cases of 1 and 2 bp insertion, where the DNA bends were much sharper than in wild type in the absence or presence of the inducer naringenin, nodA transcription was initiated constitutively with no requirement for the inducer naringenin or, even, the NodD regulating protein.

A precise DNA bend angle is essential for the function of the phage 29 transcriptional regulator

Bacteriophage φ29 protein p4 is essential for the regulation of the switch from early to late phage transcription. The protein binds to two regions of the phage genome located between the regulated promoters. Each region contains two inverted repeats separated by 1 bp. We used circular permutation assays to study the topology of the DNA upon binding of the protein and found that p4 induced the same extent of bending independent of the topology of the binding region. In addition, the results revealed that the p4-induced bending is not dependent on the affinity to the binding site but is intrinsic to p4 binding. Independent binding sites were identified through the characterization of the minimal sequence required for p4 binding. The protein has different affinity for each of its binding sites, with those overlapping the A2c and A2b promoter cores (sites 1 and 3), having the highest affinity. The functionality of the p4 binding sites and the contribution of p4-mediated promoter restructuring in transcription regulation is discussed.

Inducing and modulating anisotropic DNA bends by pseudocomplementary peptide nucleic acids.

DNA bending is significant for various DNA functions in the cell. Here, we demonstrate that pseudocomplementary peptide nucleic acids (pcPNAs) represent a class of versatile, sequence-specific DNA-bending agents. The occurrence of anisotropic DNA bends induced by pcPNAs is shown by gel electrophoretic phasing analysis. The magnitude of DNA bending is determined by circular permutation assay and by electron microscopy, with good agreement of calculated mean values between both methods. Binding of a pair of 10-meric pcPNAs to its target DNA sequence results in moderate DNA bending with a mean value of 40-45 degrees, while binding of one self-pc 8-mer PNA to target DNA yields a somewhat larger average value of the induced DNA bend. Both bends are found to be in phase when the pcPNA target sites are separated by distances of half-integer numbers of helical turns of regular duplex DNA, resulting in an enhanced DNA bend with an average value in the range of 80-90 degrees. The occurrence of such a sharp bend within the DNA double helix is confirmed and exploited through efficient formation of 170-bp-long DNA minicircles by means of dimerization of two bent DNA fragments. The pcPNAs offer two main advantages over previously designed classes of nonnatural DNA-bending agents: they have very mild sequence limitations while targeting duplex DNA and they can easily be designed for a chosen target sequence, because their binding obeys the principle of complementarity. We conclude that pcPNAs are promising tools for inducing bends in DNA at virtually any chosen site.

Isomerization and apparent DNA bending by π, the replication protein of plasmid R6K

Plasmid R6K-encoded π protein has multiple regulatory functions in replication and transcription. These functions rely, in part, on a complex set of interactions between monomers and dimers of the protein and distinct DNA targets, the direct and inverted repeats (DRs, IRs). In the work described here, we examine the isomerization and DNA bending properties of π using electrophoretic mobility shift assays and circular permutation assays. Our data suggest that π dimers can bend IRs, and dimer subunits seem to readily associate in head-to-head and head-to-tail fashion. The ability of π to bend DRs is also reexamined using techniques that allow us to discriminate between bending induced by its different isomeric forms. We find that both monomers and dimers bend a single DR to similar degrees while results with 2DRs are more complex. The significance of the bending data in regard to a possible mechanism for replication initiation by π protein is discussed.

Sequence-dependent bending in plasmid pUC19.

The circular permutation assay has been used to characterize sequence-dependent bending in plasmid pUC19 (2686 bp). Linear, permuted sequence isomers of pUC19 exhibit different mobilities in large-pore polyacrylamide gels, suggesting that the plasmid contains two sequence-dependent bends, one located at approximately 806 bp, close to the start site of transcription, and the other at approximately 2617 bp, near the promoter of the ampicillin resistance gene. The mobility patterns are independent of the buffer in which the gels are cast and run, independent of pH over the range 6.5-8.6, and independent of the presence or absence of various monovalent ions added to the buffer, suggesting that the maxima in the mobility patterns correspond to stable bends in the helix backbone, not anisometric flexibility. Although the mobility patterns are unchanged when Ba(++) or Zn(++) ions are added to the buffer, several of the sequence isomers exhibit multiple sharp sub-bands in solutions containing Mg(++) or Ca(++) ions, indicating the presence of multiple conformational isomers. In addition, the mobility maximum near the start site of transcription is shifted by approximately 100 bp in the presence of Ca(++) ions, suggesting that the location of the actual bend center is somewhat variable, depending on the ionic composition of the surrounding medium. The number of maxima observed in the mobility pattern can be increased by adding a bend from another plasmid, such as Litmus 28; the number of maxima can be decreased by removing one of the bends in pUC19 by restriction enzyme digestion and religation. Hence, the number of maxima in the mobility pattern is an accurate indication of the number of stable, sequence-dependent bends present in the plasmid. The combined results indicate that the circular permutation assay in large-pore polyacrylamide gels is a reliable method of detecting and analyzing sequence-dependent bends in kilobase-sized DNA molecules.

Analysis of DNA bending by transient electric birefringence

Transient electric birefringence has been used to analyze DNA bending in six restriction fragments containing 171, 174, 207, 263, 289, and 471 bp in three different low ionic strength buffers. The target fragments contain sequences corresponding to the apparent bend centers in pUC19 and Litmus 28, previously identified by the circular permutation assay (Strutz, K.; Stellwagen, N. C. Electrophoresis 1996, 17, 989-995). The target fragments migrate anomalously slowly in polyacrylamide gels and exhibit birefringence relaxation times that are shorter than those of restriction fragments of the same size, taken from nonbent regions of the same plasmids. Apparent bend angles ranging from 30 degrees to 41 degrees were calculated for the target fragments by tau-ratio method. The bend angles of four of the target fragments were independent of temperature from 4 degrees C to 20 degrees C, but decreased when the temperature was increased to 37 degrees C. The bend angles of the other two target fragments were independent of temperature over the entire range examined, 4 degrees -37 degrees C. Hence, the thermal stability of sequence-dependent bends in random-sequence DNA is variable. The bend angles of five of the six target fragments were independent of the presence or absence of Mg2+ ions in the solution, indicating most of the target fragments were stably bent or curved, rather than anisometrically flexible. Restriction fragments containing 219 and 224 bp, with sequences somewhat offset from the sequence of the 207 bp fragment, were also studied. Comparison of the tau-ratios of these overlapping fragments allowed both the bend angle and bend position to be independently determined. These methods should be useful for analyzing sequence-dependent bending in other random-sequence DNAs.

Functional analysis of TraA, the sex pheromone receptor encoded by pPD1, in a promoter region essential for the mating response in Enterococcus faecalis.

Conjugative transfer of a bacteriocin plasmid, pPD1, of Enterococcus faecalis is induced in response to a peptide sex pheromone, cPD1, secreted from plasmid-free recipient cells. cPD1 is taken up by a pPD1 donor cell and binds to an intracellular receptor, TraA. Once a recipient cell acquires pPD1, it starts to produce an inhibitor of cPD1, termed iPD1, which functions as a TraA antagonist and blocks self-induction in donor cells. In this study, we discuss how TraA transduces the signal of cPD1 to the mating response. Gel mobility shift assays indicated that TraA is bound to a traA-ipd intergenic region, which is essential for cPD1 response. DNase I footprinting analysis suggested the presence of one strong (tab1) and two weak (tab2 and tab3) TraA-binding sites in the intergenic region. Primer extension analysis implied that the transcriptional initiation sites of traA and ipd were located in the intergenic region. Northern analysis showed that cPD1 upregulated and downregulated transcription of ipd and traA, respectively. The circular permutation assay showed that TraA bent a DNA fragment corresponding to the tab1 region, and its angle was changed in the presence of cPD1 or iPD1. From these data, we propose a model that TraA changes the conformation of the tab1 region in response to cPD1 and upregulates the transcription of ipd, which may lead to expression of genes required for the mating response.

Multiple Mechanisms for Pitx-1 Transactivation of a Luteinizing Hormone β Subunit Gene

The pituitary homeobox factor-1 (Pitx-1) transactivates a number of pituitary-specific genes through direct interaction with other specific transcription factors. We demonstrate here that Pitx-1 plays a crucial role in the regulation of the Chinook salmon luteinizing hormone beta gene promoter through a number of novel mechanisms. On the proximal promoter its action involves a synergistic effect with steroidogenic factor-1 (SF-1) alone or in combination with the estrogen receptor; promoter activity being induced by 9- or 35-fold over controls, respectively. Further upstream, a series of four Pitx-1 response elements (located between 1366 and 1506 bp from the transcriptional start site) is also involved in regulating the promoter activity. The two distal sequences have the greatest effect on the basal activity and are also essential for the gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) response. Mammalian two-hybrid assays revealed that Pitx-1 can homodimerize. Moreover, circular permutation assays indicate that binding of Pitx-1 to more than one response element induces conformational changes of the target DNA. This constitutes an additional mechanism through which Pitx-1 can mediate transactivation of this gene, allowing the demonstrated interaction of proximal response elements and distal enhancers, thus facilitating the maximal GnRH response that was seen in the longer promoter constructs. Our research also indicates that Pitx-1 is phosphorylated on three residues when bound to the DNA.

The use of gel and capillary electrophoresis to investigate some of the fundamental physical properties of DNA.

Electrophoresis is a powerful technique which can be used not only for the size-based separation of DNA in slab gels and sieving liquid polymers, but also for the analysis of sequence-dependent variations in DNA conformation and structure. Polyacrylamide gels are useful for conformational analysis, because bent or curved DNA molecules migrate anomalously slowly in this gel medium. Bending is often (but not always) associated with runs of adenine residues (A-tracts) that occur in phase with the helix repeat. The unique structure responsible for DNA bending "melts out" at a temperature considerably below that of strand separation. The circular permutation assay is another polyacrylamide gel-based method of detecting bending. It has usually been applied to small restriction fragments, but can also be used to detect bending in plasmid-sized DNA molecules. The apparent bends in plasmid DNAs tend to be located near biologically important regions of the sequence, such as the origin of replication, the start site of transcription, and the promoters of certain genes. Finally, capillary electrophoresis in free solution (without sieving liquid polymers) can be used to determine the diffusion coefficients of small DNA molecules, detect DNA-buffer interactions, and analyze the sequence dependence of counterion binding. Counterions appear to be preferentially bound to DNA oligomers containing A-tracts, especially the A(n)T(n) sequence motif. Typical examples of these applications of gel and capillary electrophoresis to the study of DNA conformation and structure are described.

Sequence-specific High Mobility Group Box Factors Recognize 10–12-Base Pair Minor Groove Motifs

Sequence-specific High Mobility Group Box Factors Recognize 10–12-Base Pair Minor Groove Motifs

The RAG1 homeodomain recruits HMG1 and HMG2 to facilitate recombination signal sequence binding and to enhance the intrinsic DNA-bending activity of RAG1-RAG2.

V(D)J recombination is initiated by the specific binding of the RAG1-RAG2 (RAG1/2) complex to the heptamer-nonamer recombination signal sequences (RSS). Several steps of the V(D)J recombination reaction can be reconstituted in vitro with only RAG1/2 plus the high-mobility-group protein HMG1 or HMG2. Here we show that the RAG1 homeodomain directly interacts with both HMG boxes of HMG1 and HMG2 (HMG1,2). This interaction facilitates the binding of RAG1/2 to the RSS, mainly by promoting high-affinity binding to the nonamer motif. Using circular-permutation assays, we found that the RAG1/2 complex bends the RSS DNA between the heptamer and nonamer motifs. HMG1,2 significantly enhance the binding and bending of the 23RSS but are not essential for the formation of a bent DNA intermediate on the 12RSS. A transient increase of HMG1,2 concentration in transfected cells increases the production of the final V(D)J recombinants in vivo.

The binding motif recognized by HU on both nicked and cruciform DNA.

The heterodimeric HU protein, highly conserved in bacteria and involved in transposition, recombination, DNA repair, etc., shares similarity with histones and HMGs. HU, which binds DNA with low affinity and without sequence specificity, binds strongly and specifically to DNA junctions and DNA containing single-strand breaks. The fine structure of these specific complexes was studied by footprinting and HU chemically converted into nucleases. The positioning of HUalphabeta on nicked DNA is asymmetrical and specifically oriented: the beta-arm binds the area surrounding the break whereas the alpha-arm lies on the 3' DNA branch. This positioning necessitates a pronounced bend in the DNA at the discontinuous point, which was estimated by circular permutation assay to be 65 degrees. At junctions, HU is similarly asymmetrically positioned in an identical orientation: the junction point plays the role of the discontinuous point in the nicked DNA. The HU binding motif present in both structures is a pair of inclined DNA helices.

DNA bend sites in the human beta-globin locus: evidence for a basic and universal structural component of genomic DNA.

Here we summarize the DNA bend sites in a 66-kb region of the human beta-globin locus. A total of 98 sites were mapped by circular permutation assay along the locus with an average interval of 679.2 +/- 229.6 bp between them. The distribution of the bend sites indicated that although the most frequent distance was about 650-700 bp, there appeared to be preferences at 300-400, 500-550, 800-850, 1,000-1,050, and 1,150-1,200 bp, indicating that these distances are multimers of a 170-bp basic unit. DNA bend sites in the globin-encoding regions indicated that most of their locations relative to the cap sites were conserved during evolution. Insertion of Alu and L1 sequences that occurred at various times and changed the distances of the sites was corrected for the epsilon-, psi beta-, and delta-globin genes. The only exception of the conservation was observed at the duplication junctions of the two gamma-globin genes, which occurred 25-35 MYA. Among the 75 A/A/A (A2N8A2N8A2) sequences found in the 51 bend sites, 59 sequences from 47 sites showed bending profiles by oligonucleotide-based assay. All of these sites were included in the sites predicted by computer analysis based on the distribution of AA and TT dinucleotides. These lines of evidence suggest that these DNA bend sites are one of the basic structural components universally present in genomic DNA.

Localization of curved DNA and its association with nucleosome phasing in the promoter region of the human estrogen receptor α gene

We determined DNA bend sites in the promoter region of the human estrogen receptor (ER) gene by the circular permutation assay. A total of five sites (ERB−4 to −1, and ERB+1) mapped in the 3 kb region showed an average distance of 688 bp. Most of the sites were accompanied by short poly(dA)·poly(dT) tracts including the potential bend core sequence A 2N 8A 2N 8A 2 (A/A/A). Fine mapping of the ERB−2 site indicated that this A/A/A and the 20 bp immediate flanking sequence containing one half of the estrogen response element were the sites of DNA curvature. All of the experimentally mapped bend sites corresponded to the positions of DNA curvature as well as to nucleosomes predicted by computer analysis. In vitro nucleosome mapping at ERB−2 revealed that the bend center was located 10–30 bp from the experimental and predicted nucleosome dyad axes.

Characterization of matrix attachment sites in the upstream region of a tobacco chitinase gene.

The nuclear matrix is thought to partition the genome into functional and structural loop domains, and it has been implicated in several cellular processes, such as the replication and transcription of DNA and the processing of RNA. Therefore, the analysis of scaffold/matrix-associated DNA regions (S/MARs) might enhance our understanding of the functional roles of the higher-order organization of chromatin. In this study, the upstream region between positions -3320 and -1095 of the basic class I chitinase gene, CHN50, was shown to have specific affinity for the tobacco nuclear scaffold. Detailed analysis of nuclear scaffold-DNA binding in vitro revealed that two regions (positions -3320 to -2621 and -2221 to -1371) bound specifically to the nuclear scaffold. These S/MAR elements, designated S/M I and S/M II, are A+T-rich sequences with 75% and 74% A+T residues, respectively, and may include a number of sequence motifs that have frequently been found in other S/MARs. Moreover, S/M II contains a curved DNA sequence with anomalous mobility on polyacrylamide gels. A circular permutation assay revealed that the center of this curved region was located between positions -1767 and -1759. The possible functions and structural features of the S/MAR elements in the upstream region of CHN50 are discussed.

The N-terminal Methionine Is a Major Determinant of the DNA Binding Specificity of MEF-2C

Members of the MEF-2 family of transcriptional regulators positively modulate the activity of basic helix-loop-helix proteins in both myogenic and neurogenic cell lineages. Previous work had shown that MEF-2C(2-117), a protein fragment comprising the dimerization and DNA-binding domains of MEF-2C but lacking the N-terminal methionine, bound to AT-rich DNA sequences with high affinity. MEF-2C(2-117) did not discriminate between different AT-rich sequences. We now report the in vitro DNA binding properties of a MEF-2C fragment containing the N-terminal methionine. Measurements of the apparent dissociation constants of the complexes of GG-MEF-2C(1-117) revealed that different AT-rich sequences are bound with different affinities; in particular MEF site containing DNA (CTATAAATAG) is bound preferentially to DNA containing a SRF site (CATAAATG). Strikingly, when the shorter AT run consisted of six alternating thymines and adenines, almost wild-type affinity was observed. Irrespective of the particular DNA sequence, all circular dichroism spectra of the DNA complexes of GG-MEF-2C(1-117) were superimposable and characterized by an identical maximal ellipticity at 269.5 nm, suggesting similar DNA conformations. Bending analysis by circular permutation assay revealed that on complex formation MEF-2C(2-117) induced cognate DNA to bend by 49 degrees, while heterologous DNA remained unbent. In the presence of the N-terminal methionine, however, all DNA sequences were bent by 70 degrees. The above results suggest an important function for the N-terminal methionine in properly orientating MEF-2C on the DNA.