Nine moorland sites adjacent to coniferous plantations were surveyed for breeding birds in Sutherland and Co. Durham. Fewer Golden Plover and Dunlin were seen close to plantations than further away. The total number of wader sightings (i.e. Golden Plover, Dunlin, Redshank, Curlew, Lapwing, Snipe, Greenshank and Common Sandpiper combined) followed the same pattern. For Golden Plover and all waders combined, the effect extended up to 400 m from the forestry edge. For Dunlin the effect extended beyond 400 m from the forest edge. On a subset of 5 sites, there was no evidence for vegetation changes which might account for these patterns. However, this failure to detect changes in the vegetation may be due to the methods used. Comparisons are made with earlier studies, and possible mechanisms are discussed. Changes in bird numbers with distance from the forest edge could be due to the way sites are selected for forestry, or due to 'edge effects'. A study suggesting that map-derived variables, which could have been influenced by afforestation, change with distance from the forest edge is consistent with the first of these hypotheses. Studies suggesting changes in vegetation, in association with afforestation, are consistent with the second. Further research is necessary to investigate the relative importance of these 2 possible mechanisms. This research should be carried out before further forestry developments near important areas for nature conservation.
Read full abstract