T HE October, 1954, number of Geographical Review included an article on third voyage of Columbus by Professor Arthur Davies, entitled 'Miraculous' Discovery of South America by Columbus.' Professor Davies advances thesis that Columbus was guided on this I498 expedition by some knowledge of a previous Portuguese discovery of Brazil and mainland Caribbean area, and that was specifically directed by Pedro de Ledesma, a young Spaniard previously in Portuguese service, whom engaged at on his outward voyage, in June, I498. Before examining Professor Davies' argument, let me say that I have no quarrel with thesis if it can be supported by convincing evidence. I do not, however, consider his evidence convincing: I am unable to derive any such meaning as does from sources on which any study of Columbus' third voyage must be based. Entirely ignored, moreover, are various important secondary writings that would have cleared up some of mysteries author seeks to resolve. Thus, in spite of efforts of Washington Irving, Alexander von Humboldt, John Boyd Thacher, Roberto Almagila, and Samuel E. Morison, article opens with statement that the third voyage of Columbus, in I498, has never been critically examined.2 As evidence that Columbus might have learned of a previous Portuguese discovery of South America at Madeira, where Ledesma joined his expedition, Davies says, Madeira was Portuguese outpost for Atlantic explorations,3 inference presumably being that those residing there were in a position to know of matters that others did not. So far as statement has any meaning, it is more untrue than true. is too close to mainland Portugal to have been of much use as an outpost. The Corte-Reals used Azores as their starting point for America, and Vasco da Gama bypassed and halted at Cape Verdes before entering South Atlantic.4 It is also a fact that Da Gama, on his return, used Cape Verdes as main stop to break journey. Davies is aware that, even for Columbus in I498, Cape Verdes were point from which real exploring part of voyage began. The author gets himself into a tangle when dealing with Columbus' route southwestward from Cape Verdes. He cites Jane, who translates Las Casas correctly as saying that Admiral ordered course to be set for southwest, for then he would be in a line east-and-west with sierra of Loa [Sierra Leone] and cape of Santa Ana in Guinea, which is under equinoctial line . .5 Under equinoctial
Read full abstract