Burch-Schneider Antiprotrusio Cage Research Articles

The modern Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage for the treatment of acetabular defects: is it still an option? A systematic review.

A number of papers have been published about the clinical performance of modern rough-blasted titanium Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cages (BS-APCs) for the treatment of acetabular bone defects. However, no systematic review of the literature has been published to date. The US National Library of Medicine (PubMed/MEDLINE), EMBASE, and the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews were queried for publications using keywords pertinent to Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage, revision THA, and clinical outcomes. 8 articles were found to be suitable for inclusion in the present study in which 374 cases (370 patients) had been treated with modern BS-APCs. Most acetabular bone defects were type 3 according to the Paprosky classification (type 2C: 18.1%, 3A: 51%, and 3B: 28.9%). The overall re-revision rate for the 374 acetabular reconstructions with modern BS-APCs was 11.5% (43 cases). The short-term survival rate of the modern BS-APC construct was 90.6% (339 out of 374 cases), while the mid-term survival rate was 85.6% (320 out of 374 cases), and the long-term survival rate 62% (54 out of 87 cases). The most common reasons for revision were aseptic loosening (5.6%), periprosthetic joint infection (3.8%), dislocation (2.7%), and acetabular periprosthetic fracture (1.9%). There was moderate quality evidence to show that the use of modern rough blasted titanium BS-APCs in cases of acetabular bone loss has an unacceptably high failure rate (38%). Given that antiprotrusio cages do not provide any biological fixation, we would not recommend the routine use of modern BS-APCs in complex revision THA cases. By contrast, the satisfactory short- to mid-term outcome of modern BS-APCs in combination with their low cost compared to highly porous acetabular implants, make us feel that BS-APCs might still be used in selected elderly or low-demand patients without severe superomedial acetabular bone loss.

Primary total hip replacement using Burch-Schneider cages for acetabular fractures.

Osteoporotic acetabular fractures are common and pose a difficult technical challenge for the trauma surgeon. Acute total hip arthroplasty (THA) using a Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage with immediate postoperative weight-bearing is a method to approach these injuries. This case series reports our outcomes of acute THA using Burch-Schneider cages for acetabular fractures from a UK major trauma centre based on length of stay, radiological outcome, complications and outcome scores. Data were collected from all patients who underwent acute THA with a Burch-Schneider cage for acetabular fractures between June 2006 and August 2015. Patients were followed up clinically, radiologically, and using Oxford Hip Scores (OHS). 20 patients with a median age of 73 (range 60-90 years) were identified. All patients were independent walkers at follow-up, and had achieved radiological union. There were no dislocations, subsidence, revision or deep infections. Significant complications include 1 perioperative death as a result of complications arising from pre-existing pulmonary fibrosis; 1 deep vein thrombosis; 1 intraoperative arterial injury to the superior gluteal artery; and 1 leg-length discrepancy. Mean length of stay was 10 days. The mean OHS was 37/48 at a mean follow-up of 26 months. This case series further validates the use of Burch-Schneider cages with primary THA in acute acetabular fractures.

Total Hip Arthroplasty for Periacetabular Metastatic Disease. An Original Technique of Reconstruction According to the Harrington Classification

BackgroundPeriacetabular metastatic disease requires complex acetabular reconstruction. The complication rate for these frail patients is high. Various cement-rebar reinforced techniques allowing cemented total hip arthroplasty (THA) have been described. The optimal procedure has not yet been identified. MethodsA continuous series of 131 THAs performed in 126 patients with periacetabular metastatic disease was prospectively included in this study. After bone metastasis curettage and cementation, an original technique of acetabular reconstruction was performed using a dual mobility cup cemented into an acetabular reinforcement device (ie, Kerboull cross-plate or Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage) according to the Harrington classification. Functional outcome for independent ambulation in the community, pain relief, and occurrence of dislocation or mechanical failure of the acetabular reconstruction were assessed. ResultsAt a mean follow-up of 33 ± 17 months, the improvement in the preoperative to postoperative functional outcome and pain relief was significant (P < .001). The dislocation rate was 2%. Two of the 3 cases of dislocation occurred in acetabular reconstructions associated with a proximal femoral arthroplasty. No mechanical failure or aseptic loosening of the acetabular reconstruction was observed. ConclusionThis study emphasized that our original technique combining bone metastasis curettage and cementation, acetabular reinforcement device and cemented dual mobility cup was effective to restore a painless functional independence and ensure a durable acetabular reconstruction able to face to adjuvant radiation therapy and mechanical solicitations for long survivors. In addition, dual mobility cup limited the risk of dislocation in patients undergoing THA for periacetabular metastatic disease.

The midterm and long-term effects of acetabular roof ring and Burch-Schneider anti-protusio cages in acetabular revisions for patients with acetabular bone deficiency.

The purpose of this study was to investigate the mid-term and long-term effects of the acetabular roof ring (ARR) and Burch-Schneider anti-protrusio cage (BSAPC) in acetabular revision for patients with acetabular bone deficiency and acetabular component loosening. Between 1988 and 2007, ARR revisions were performed in 51 patients (25 women; average age: 46.9 years) and BSAPC in 18 patients (16 women; average age: 62.1 years). Grafts were used in all revisions. The patients were evaluated retrospectively. The bone defects were classified according to the classification of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS). Harris Hip Score (HHS) was used for clinical evaluation. Radiolucent lines, implant sizes, osseointegration, and heterotopic ossification in the 3 regions defined by DeLee and Charnley were evaluated radiologically. The success rate of ARR revisions after an average follow-up of 8.93±4.10 years (range: 4-23 years) was 87.9%, and the cumulative survival rate at year 10 postoperatively was 91%. Average HHS score increased to 83.70±8.98 postoperatively, from 40.10±2.49 preoperatively (p<0.01). The success rate of BSAPC revisions after an average follow-up of 7.06±2.39 years (range: 4-12 years) was 83.3%, and the cumulative survival rate was 78%. Average HHS score increased from 42.55 preoperatively to 73.86 postoperatively (p<0.01). All failures of ARR revisions occurred in type 3 defects (p<0.05). In 40 of the 47 patients in which an allograft was used, osseointegration occurred. No statistically significant difference was found between the increase in HHS scores of patients who underwent femoral component revision with acetabular revision and those who did not (p=0.06). Patients who underwent more than 1 revision had statistically significantly higher failure rates in comparison to patients undergoing revision for the first time (p=0.008). The mid-term and long-term results of the use of ARR and BSAPC with allografts in bone deficient acetabular revisions are satisfactory. The implants facilitate graft osseointegration, increase the bone stock, and make future revisions easier. ARR should be preferred in type 1 and type 2 acetabular bone defects, while BSAPC should be preferred in type 3 and 4 defects.

Acetabular reconstruction with the Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage and bulk allografts: minimum 10-year follow-up results.

Reconstruction of severe pelvic bone loss is a challenging problem in hip revision surgery. Between January 1992 and December 2000, 97 hips with periprosthetic osteolysis underwent acetabular revision using bulk allografts and the Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage (APC). Twenty-nine patients (32 implants) died for unrelated causes without additional surgery. Sixty-five hips were available for clinical and radiographic assessment at an average follow-up of 14.6 years (range, 10.0 to 18.9 years). There were 16 male and 49 female patients, aged from 29 to 83 (median, 60 years), with Paprosky IIIA (27 cases) and IIIB (38 cases) acetabular bone defects. Nine cages required rerevision because of infection (3), aseptic loosening (5), and flange breakage (1). The average Harris hip score improved from 33.1 points preoperatively to 75.6 points at follow-up (P < 0.001). Radiographically, graft incorporation and cage stability were detected in 48 and 52 hips, respectively. The cumulative survival rates at 18.9 years with removal for any reason or X-ray migration of the cage and aseptic or radiographic loosening as the end points were 80.0% and 84.6%, respectively. The use of the Burch-Schneider APC and massive allografts is an effective technique for the reconstructive treatment of extensive acetabular bone loss with long-lasting survival.

Design and Manufacturing Preparation of a Patient Specific Acetabular Cage

Total hip arthoplasty or hip replacement is today a common and highly successful a surgical procedure. However, in the revision artoplasty the procedure is more complicated, as standard devices have to be adapted to different shapes of acetabular defects, which are patient specific especially when they are bigger and wider spread. This kind of big defects, sever acetabular defects, pelvic discontinuity, defects resulted from tumor problems, protrusion, can usually be addressed with a standard Burch-Schneider Antiprotrusio Cage or a Mueller Ring in order to restore the mechanics and the true center of the hip. This paper proposes a design process and manufacturing preparation for a patient specific acetabular cage. The design is intended to fix problems that standard cages sometimes do not resolve, for example insufficient fixation due to the fact that the inferior flange did not engage the ischium, problems of bone graft resorption and in the same time tries to remain an affordable solution. The design process uses as input information the 3D reconstruction of the patient hip from CT scan. Important parameters like the position of the true center of rotation, acetabular anteversion and inclination are determined and calculated. Other parameters, such as number of fixing screws and their designated holes or the amount of bone to be covered with the custom acetabular cage (fixation surface), are proposed by orthopaedic specialist. The design methodology relays on commercial software, such as Solid Works for CAD, 3D Doctor for 3D bone reconstruction from the CT scans or other software for different file transformations. The model was optimized to be produced through direct metal laser-sintering (DMLS). Regarding the results, the particular implant was designed and optimized for fabrication and it is available to be produced. During the design process, although a systematized process was undertaken and implemented, some activities could not be done in systematic, repeatable way. Nevertheless, a design process strategy was established, so that the design would match the requirements of such implant and also a requirements list for the type and form of information needed for this kind of design. Also, we concluded that using software to automate some of the operations that were done manually by the operator would help decrees the design time and improve the repeatability of the process.

The Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage: medium follow-up results

With the development of hip prosthesis, younger patients may need more than one revision surgery, with less bone stock available in each subsequent surgery. We retrospectively reviewed the hip revision surgeries in which a Burch-Schneider device has been used. Patients were classified according to the Paprosky score. Functional and clinical evaluation was assessed by the Merlé-Daubigné score. Radiolucencies were assessed by Gill's criteria. Sixteen patients with a mean age of 66.1 years were reviewed at a mean follow-up of 60.7 months. According to Paprosky classification, 18.7% were grade IIb, 56.3% grade IIIa and 25% grade IIIb. The mean Merlé-Daubigné score improved from 10 to 15 points. Radiologically, 12 patients had no radiolucencies, two had grade I radiolucencies and two had grade III radiolucencies. In greater than 50% of acetabular defects, the Burch-Schneider seems to be useful providing clinical and functional improvement. Immediately, non-progressive radiolucencies are not associated with implant loosening at the end of follow-up. The ischial flap should be inserted inside the ischial portion of the acetabulum.

A Minimum of 10-Year Follow-Up of the Burch-Schneider Cage and Bulk Allografts for the Revision of Pelvic Discontinuity

Eighteen consecutive hips with pelvic discontinuity and associated periprosthetic bone deficiency were treated with bulk allografts and Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage. Clinical and radiographic follow-up was performed at an average of 13.5 (range, 10.5-16.6) years. Three cages required re-revision because of infection (1) and aseptic loosening (2). Average Harris hip score improved from 31.9 to 77.0 points (P < .001). A severe resorption of the bone graft occurred in 2 hips. The stability of the cage was detected in 13 cases. The cumulative survival rate at 16.6 years with acetabular revision for any reason, radiographic loosening, or unhealing of the discontinuity as the end point was 72.2%. The use of Burch-Schneider cage and bulk allografts is an effective technique for the treatment of pelvic discontinuity.

The Burch-Schneider Cage: 9-Year Survival in Paprosky Type 3 Acetabular Defects. Clinical and Radiological Follow-Up

Revision hip arthroplasty in cases with severe acetabular deficiency represents a technical challenge. The aim of this study was to determine: 1. The 9-year survival of the Burch Schneider anti-protrusio cage (BS-APC) in severe acetabular defects. 2. The migration of the cage and correlation of this with functional outcome. 3. The anticipated functional outcome users can expect in a district general hospital setting in the management of severe acetabular defects. A single-surgeon consecutive series of 30 complex acetabular reconstructions using the BS-APC was retrospectively reviewed. Clinical and radiological follow up at 5-9 years was obtained. Survival was established with revisions and further surgery as different end-points. A radiological analysis using ein bilt roentgen analyse (EBRA) was performed. At a mean follow-up of 85 months (range: 64-118) 26 patients (87%) were alive. Nine-year survival was 95% for revision of BS-APC as an end-point and 92% with any cause of further surgery as an end-point. The mean Oxford Hip Score was 34.5 and UCLA activity score was 4.4. All cases demonstrated evidence of significant migration, but no screws were found to be broken. There was no correlation between cup migration and Oxford hip score (p=0.07). Our non-specialist centre experience suggests the BS-APC should not be dismissed as a reconstruction option in the most severe acetabular defects.

Load Dispersion Effects of Acetabular Reinforcement Devices Used in Revision Total Hip Arthroplasty: A Simulation Study Using Finite Element Analysis

Several types of acetabular reinforcement devices are used to prevent the collapse of grafted bone in revision total hip arthroplasty. However, it remains unclear how the stress is reduced by different devices. We used finite element analysis to evaluate 4 types of acetabular reinforcement devices: Kerboull-type device, Burch-Schneider anti-protrusio cage, Mueller ring, and Ganz ring. The control was a socket fixed with bone cement without any reinforcement devices. The stress distribution on the inner surface of each socket was calculated by binarization image processing. For all 4 reinforcement devices, the stress was reduced to less than one-half of that in the control. All the devices were useful for preventing the collapse of bulk bone grafts applied to load-bearing defects.

Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage for acetabular revision: a 5- to 13-year follow-up study

Ninety-six acetabular revisions using a Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage (BSAC) in 91 patients (53 women and 38 men), were evaluated retrospectively with a mean follow-up of 8.1 years (range 5-13 years). The mean age at surgery was 67.3 years (range 35-85 years). There were 3 re-revisions: 1 because of aseptical loosening and 2 because of deep infection. The Kaplan-Meier survivorship rate, with aseptic component loosening as the criterion of failure, was 92.4% (95% confidence interval, 85.1%-99.8%) at 13 years. Clinical evaluation of the surviving patients showed an increase in mean Merle d?Aubigné-Postel hip score of 8.8 points before surgery, to 15.1 points at the time of the last follow-up. Radiographic evaluation determined that 3 cages were considered definitely loose. The rotation centre of the hip was lowered an average of 4.3 mm and lateralised an average of 1.3 mm in this series. In the most severe cases (Paprosky 2C, 3A, and 3B), the hip centre was lowered 7.8 mm and lateralised 0.8 mm. The Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage long-term survival rate compares favourably with that for other devices. Acetabular reconstruction allows anatomic positioning of the cups and promotes good final results.

Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage for acetabular revision: a 5- to 13-year follow-up study

Ninety-six acetabular revisions using a Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage (BSAC) in 91 patients (53 women and 38 men), were evaluated retrospectively with a mean follow-up of 8.1 years (range 5-13 years). The mean age at surgery was 67.3 years (range 35-85 years). There were 3 re-revisions: 1 because of aseptical loosening and 2 because of deep infection. The Kaplan-Meier survivorship rate, with aseptic component loosening as the criterion of failure, was 92.4% (95% confidence interval, 85.1%-99.8%) at 13 years. Clinical evaluation of the surviving patients showed an increase in mean Merle d?Aubigné-Postel hip score of 8.8 points before surgery, to 15.1 points at the time of the last follow-up. Radiographic evaluation determined that 3 cages were considered definitely loose. The rotation centre of the hip was lowered an average of 4.3 mm and lateralised an average of 1.3 mm in this series. In the most severe cases (Paprosky 2C, 3A, and 3B), the hip centre was lowered 7.8 mm and lateralised 0.8 mm. The Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage long-term survival rate compares favourably with that for other devices. Acetabular reconstruction allows anatomic positioning of the cups and promotes good final results.

Total hip arthroplasty revision in elderly people with cement and Burch–Schneider anti-protrusio cage

Total hip arthroplasty revision is increasingly becoming a common procedure, but the acetabular bone loss and the advanced age of the patients make revision procedures extremely complex and technically demanding. The aim of the present work is to examine the clinical and radiological results of the Burch-Schneider anti-protrusio cage (APC) implanted in revision hip arthroplasty with severe acetabular bone deficiency in elderly people. Between February 1994 and November 2005, a total of 60 revision operations of acetabular components were performed in 60 select patients (42 females and 18 males), using the Burch-Schneider APC. The indication for the Burch-Schneider APC use was massive pelvic bone loss with migration of the prosthesis cup and high-grade acetabular defects (type III or IV AAOS). The mean age at the time of surgery was 82 years (range 78-85 years). Polymethylmetacrylate cement (PMMA) was used to fill bony deficiencies in all the procedures. No graft was used. The average Harris Hip Score had improved from 28.2 preoperatively to 82.5 points at the time of follow-up. According to the classification of Gill et al., we have seen no Burch-Schneider cages definitely loose or probably. Only one acetabular component has been revised (for recurrent dislocation). Acetabular reconstruction with the use of cement and an acetabular support ring appears to have a useful role in the treatment of severe acetabular bony deficiency in elderly patients and may provide a definitive reconstruction.

The Effectiveness of the Burch-Schneider Antiprotrusio Cage for Acetabular Bone Deficiency: Five to Twenty-one Years' Follow-up

From 1985 to 2001, the Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage (B-S APC) was implanted in 57 cases (55 patients) with massive acetabular deficiency. The B-S APC survived until the last review 5 to 21 years after operation in 89.5% of the cases, produced substantial pain relief, and increased range of hip motion and walking capacity. The 10.5% failure rate was due to aseptic loosening in 2 cases and mechanical failure in 4 cases. It appears that application of the B-S APC in extensive acetabular deficiency presents a durable solution provided that proper indications and technique are used.

Reconstruction of Severe Acetabular Bone-Deficiency: The Burch-Schneider Antiprotrusio Cage in Primary and Revision Total Hip Arthroplasty

Ninety Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cages in 87 patients implanted in primary and revision total hip arthroplasty were analyzed. Sixty-seven hips (64 patients) could be examined clinically and radiologically after an average of 50.3 months (minimum 23.6, maximum 131.0 months). Twenty patients (20 hips) died in interim and 3 patients (3 hips) were not available for follow-up. Of the 90 Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cages, 4 had to be removed and 8 further cages were considered definitely loose. The survival rate is 93.4% (95% confidence interval, 74.3%-96.7%) after 131 months if the endpoint “cage explantation” is used. The average Harris Hip Score was improved from 28.2 preoperatively to 73.5 points at the time of follow-up. Radiolucent lines were often found in the Charnley/DeLee's zones II and III. In contrast, osteolyses were seldom seen.

Revision cup arthroplasty using Burch-Schneider anti-protrusio cage.

From 1986 until 1995 we used the Burch-Schneider anti-protrusio cage in 31 patients (33 hips) and followed the patients for 5 years. Five patients died within the 5-year follow-up. Clinical outcome listed an average Harris hip score of 71/70/66 points after 1, 2 and 5 years respectively. One patient had a revision due to late-onset haematogenous infection. We found cup migration in nine patients. Migration was self-limiting in three cases and in two there was no bony graft ingrowth. Screw breakage was seen in one case. All migrated cages showed a higher rotational centre than cages without migration.

Reconstruction of segmental defects during revision procedures of the acetabulum with the Burch-Schneider anti-protrusio cage

Abstract: Sixty-three Burch-Schneider rings in 62 patients with segmental or combined defects were followed up after a mean of 5.45 years. The mean Harris hip score was 74.9 points. Aseptic loosening occurred in 3 cases, and septic loosening occurred in 2 cases. All cases of aseptic loosening had Paprosky stage IIIb defects and defects of the posterior column. Radiologic migration analysis showed increased migration with increase in the Paprosky defect stage, defects of the posterior column, and cranial defects. The cage has the lowest migration and loosening rate in cases with medial defects or anterior column defects. Surgical treatment of defects of the posterior column is associated with an increased rate of aseptic loosening, whereas implantation with cranial defects shows a higher migration rate with no significant increase in loosening.

The Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage in acetabular revision surgery: A mean follow-up of 12 years

A total of 38 acetabular revisions using a Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage in 37 patients (18 women and 19 men), with a mean age at surgery of 75 years (range, 55–88 years), were evaluated retrospectively with a mean follow-up of 12 years (range, 8–21 years). In 2 cases with total hip dislocation and in 1 case with a deep infection, revision of the antiprotrusio cages was required. Defining every revision of the antiprotrusio cage as the endpoint of survivorship, the antiprotrusio cage showed a survival rate of 92% after 21 years. Clinical evaluation of the surviving patients showed a mean Harris hip score of 76 points (range, 20–96). Radiologic evaluation revealed that 1 antiprotrusio cage was loose and that 4 femoral stems were loose. The Burch-Schneider antiprotrusio cage compares favorably with other devices with regard to long-term implant survival rate.

Revision arthroplasty using an anti-protrusio cage for massive acetabular bone deficiency.

Revision hip arthroplasty in patients with massive acetabular bone deficiency has generally given poor long-term results. We report the use of an 'anti-protrusio cage', secured to the ischium and ilium, which bridges areas of acetabular bone loss, provides support for the acetabular socket, and allows pelvic bone grafting in an environment protected from excessive stress. Forty-two failed hip arthroplasties with massive acetabular bone loss were revised with the Burch-Schneider anti-protrusio cage and evaluated after two to 11 years (mean five years). There was failure due to sepsis in five hips (12%) and aseptic loosening in five (12%); the remaining 32 hips (76%) showed no evidence of acetabular component failure or loosening.