Congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is reported to be more common in preterm infants than in term infants, especially in sick preterm infants. Though a frequent possibility of transitory thyroidal alterations in this category of neonates, the evolution of CH to transient or permanent forms is unpredictable. We retrospectively analyzed medical records of 28 preterm infants (<37 weeks gestation) who had exhibited a positive screening for CH at birth during the period 2000-2015 followed in our Center. Children were divided into three groups: permanent CH (PCH) with thyroid dysgenesis, PCH with eutopic normal-sized thyroid gland, and transient CH (TCH) with eutopic normal-sized thyroid gland. In all groups we described clinical and biochemical characteristics. Secondly, we analyzed the differences between patients with thyroid dysgenesis and patients with eutopic normal-sized gland and we compared PCH and TCH groups with normal-sized thyroid gland in order to identify clinical or biochemical data for early detection of transient forms. Of all patients, 21.4% showed thyroid dysgenesis while 78.6% presented eutopic normal-sized gland. Infants with thyroid dysgenesis had higher median (IQR) baseline s-TSH and levothyroxine (L-T4) dose per weight at 12 months (12m-dose) than patients with eutopic normal-sized gland. At re-evaluation of the patients with eutopic normal-sized gland, 36% showed PCH and 64% had TCH. The age of the patients at the beginning of L-T4 treatment, gestational age (GA), birth weight, blood thyroid stimulating hormone levels (b-TSH) at first newborn screening (NBS), baseline serum thyroid stimulating hormone (s-TSH), and L-T4 12m-dose were statistically different between the two groups. Our results demonstrate that factors as GA, birth weight, b-TSH levels at first NBS, baseline s-TSH, L-T4 12m-dose and age at the start of the treatment may be considered useful predictive elements for the evolution of CH.