Objective To investigate effectiveness of different strategies of autologous blood transfusion, in order to promote development of autologous blood transfusion in medical institutions, and to ensure the safety of clinical transfusion. Methods From January 2014 to July 2016, a total of 88 patients undergoing orthopedic surgery who received autologous blood transfusion in General Hospital of Beijing Military Region or Dalian Municipal Central Hospital, were randomly selected as research objects by simple random sampling method. A simple random grouping method was used to classify the patients into intraoperative salvaged autotransfusion group (n=43), stored autologous whole blood transfusion group (n=25), and stored autologous red blood cells transfusion group (n=20). A total of 42 patients undergoing orthopaedic surgery who received allogeneic blood transfusion were randomly selected from above hospital during the same period by simple random sampling method, and they were included in control group (n=42). The data including patients′ red blood cell count, hemoglobin (Hb) level, hematocrit (HCT) and platelet count were collected and analyzed in different time points which were before blood collection/surgery, the first day after blood transfusion, the fourth day after blood transfusion. And days of hospitalization, volume of bleeding in the operation, infusion volume of allogeneic blood in each group were also collected and analyzed. Statistical methods were used to compare the differences of the above indexes among 4 groups. Results ① There were no statistically significant differences in red blood cell count, Hb level, HCT, platelet count among patients of 4 groups before blood collection/surgery (P>0.05). ② There were no statistically significant difference in red blood cell count, Hb level, HCT among patients of 4 groups on the first day after blood transfusion. But there was significant differences in platelet count among 4 groups (F=4.157, P=0.008). And platelet count of patients in stored autologous whole blood transfusion group was the highest, as (196.0±43.80)×109/L. Among them, compared with control and intraoperative salvaged autotransfusion groups respectively, the differences were statistically significant (P=0.004, 0.009). However, compared with stored autologous red blood cells transfusion group, the difference was not statistically significant (P=0.653). ③ There was no statistically significant difference in red blood cell count of patients in 4 groups on the fourth days after blood transfusion (P>0.05). Comparison of Hb level in 4 groups, the difference was statistically significant (F=3.764, P=0.013). Hb level of patients in intraoperative salvaged autotransfusion group was the highest [(115.6±23.8) g/L], which compared with stored autologous transfusion and control groups respectively, the differences were statistically significant (P=0.006, 0.022), but there was no statistically significant that compared with preoperative autologous red blood cells group (P=0.878). Comparison of HCT in these 4 groups, the difference was statistically significant (F=3.915, P=0.011). The HCT of patients in the stored autologous red blood cells transfusion group was the highest [(34.4±4.8)%] among 4 groups, which compared with control group, the difference was statistically significant (P=0.012); but compared with stored autologous whole blood transfusion and intraoperative salvaged autotransfusion groups respectively, the differences were not statistically significant (P=0.059, 0.819). ④ There were no statistically differences observed in bleeding volume and allogeneic blood transfusion volume in the operation among 4 groups (P>0.05). Hospitalization days were compared, and the difference was statistically significant (χ2=11.990, P=0.007). Among them, patients in control group had the highest hospitalization days [14.5 d(9.5-16.0 d)], which compared with stored autologous whole blood transfusion group, the difference was statistically significant (P=0.007); compared with stored autologous red blood cells transfusion and intraoperative salvaged autotransfusion group respectively, the differences were not statistically significant (P=0.09, 0.944). Conclusions For the selection of auto logous blood infusion strategies in patients undergoing elective surgery in clinical, preferred to use stored autologous red blood cells transfusion, followed by stored autologous whole blood transfusion and intraoperative salvaged autotransfusion. When autologous blood transfusion is not available, allogeneic blood transfusion could be used. Therefore, clinicians need to change their ideas to reduce the rate of allogeneic blood transfusion gradually, and to develop the autologous blood transfusion extensively and effectively, so as to ensure the safety of clinical blood transfusion. Key words: Blood transfusion, autologous; Blood component transfusion; Apheresis red blood cells; Allogeneic transfusion
Read full abstract