Water-based foam (WBF) depopulation is currently being researched as an alternative for rapid destruction of swine populations under emergency circumstances. Appropriate guidelines are needed to maintain method reliability and depopulation efficacy while minimizing animal distress under field conditions. Finisher pigs were depopulated using WBF with a 7.5-minute dwell time in two trials to evaluate the effect of; trial 1) foam fill level (1.5, 1.75, or 2.0 times the pig's head height) and trial 2) foam fill rate (slow, medium, or fast) on aversive pig responses (surface breaks, vocalization, and escape attempts) and time to cessation of cardiac activity. Activity and cardiac activity were recorded using subcutaneous bio-loggers for swine in trial 2. The average time to cessation of movement (COM) from the start of foam filling was compared for the foam fill rate groups using a generalized linear mixed effect model under Poisson distribution. Foam rate group was used as an independent variable, and replicates as a random effect. For trial 1, the average (mm:ss±SD) time to fill completion was 01:18±00:00, 00:47±00:05, and 00:54±00:05, for 1.5, 1.75, and 2.0 times the pig's head height, respectively. For trial 2, the average time to fill completion was 03:57±00:32, 01:14±00:23 and 00:44±00:03, and the average time (mm:ss±SE) to COM was 05:22±00:21, 03:32±00:14, and 03:11±00:13 for slow, medium, and fast fill rate groups, respectively. A higher number of aversive pig responses were observed for the lowest foam fill level and slowest foam fill rate compared to increased fill levels and faster fill rates. For trial 2 the median (mm:ss ±IQR) time to fatal arrhythmia was 09:53±02:48, 11:19±04:04, and 10:57±00:47 post-foam initiation for fast, medium, and slow foam rate groups, respectively. Time to cessation of cardiac activity was significantly shorter for the fast foam rate group compared to medium and slow foam rates groups (P=0.04). For both trials, vocalizations were absent, and all pigs were unconscious following the 7.5-minute dwell time and no pigs needed a secondary euthanasia method. This WBF study showed that slower fill rates and low foam fill levels may extend the time until cessation of cardiac activity in swine during depopulation. A conservative recommendation with consideration of swine welfare during an emergency scenario would be a minimum foam fill level twice the pig's head height and a foam fill rate capable of covering pigs in foam within 60s to minimize aversive responses and expedite cessation of cardiac activity.
Read full abstract