The theory of gap regeneration dynamics proposes that different species of tree partition canopy gaps because they are preferentially adapted to a particular gap size class. A variety of gap sizes would therefore favour the regeneration of a range of species. The theory has been used to explain the extraordinarily high tree species diversity of tropical rain forests. A test was mounted in lowland evergreen dipterocarp rain forest in the Danum Valley, Sabah, East Malaysia by the creation of ten, artificial canopy gaps ranging in size from 10 m 2 to 1500 m 2 (6 to 30% canopy openness). The responses of established populations of seedlings of three dipterocarp species ( Hopea nervosa , Parashorea malaanonan and Shorea johorensis ) with contrasting silvicultural reputations were monitored for 40 months in these gaps and under closed forest. There were significant differences in survival and growth under closed forest between these three species. However, in gaps, the most important determinant of seedling survival and growth was seedling size at the time of gap creation, regardless of species. An ability to persist for long periods under closed forest and slowly accumulate growth may bestow an enormous size advantage on seedlings when gaps occur. Generalizations on the regeneration dynamics of dipterocarp rain forests need to be modified in the light of this result. Further observations for several years are important to see whether forest recovery eventually converges on predictions from the original paradigm.