Little is left today of the work to which Alexandre Lenoir devoted twenty-six years of his life, his Musee des monuments francais. Nevertheless, visitors to the Ecole des Beaux-arts in Paris will see, on entering the first courtyard, a section of the facade of the chatteau of Anet attached to the wall at the right, and until recently three bays of the facade of the chatteau of Gaillon formed a screen between this courtyard and the cour d'honneur in front of the main school building. The walls of the court itself are encrusted with bits of sculpture, and other pieces could, at least a few years ago, be found in the rather ragged garden, lying forlornly in the grass. These are, or were, the remnants of what seems to have been the Revolution's most popular cultural institution, and the reasons for its popularity are important for an understanding of the effects of the Revolution on the French mentality. Lenoir and his museum have received little serious attention from students of history or the arts, though these students have sometimes referred to them in passing, often in tones of disparagement. The museum is frequently dismissed as a popular attraction without serious artistic organization or merit, and critics have claimed that many of its exhibits were denatured by careless or deceptive reconstruction or restoration. Lenoir himself is criticized as having been careless in dating and attribution, having practiced outright deceit, and having been more interested in attracting crowds than in the preservation of art. He is accused of having been ignorant of art, even uninterested in it, and of having caused great destruction through his plundering of France's monuments and his
Read full abstract