Book Reviews Oliver Ayers. Laboured Protest: Black Civil Rights in New York City and Detroit During the New Deal and Second World War. New York and Abingdon: Routledge, 2019. Pp. 290. Abbreviations. Bibliography. Index. Cloth: $149.95. America’s memory of the civil rights movement remains hotly contested, twisted by politics, and historiographically debated. While scholars agree that the movement predated Martin Luther King Jr., where, when, and why remain elusive. Recent scholarship, inspired by Jacqueline D. Hall’s “long” civil rights thesis, has made bolder claims about the early period of protest. Laboured Protest revisits the foundational New Deal and wartime era for civil rights, labeling it “less powerful” and “more fragile” than previously thought. Ayers—history lecturer at the New College of Humanities, London—argues that the 1930s and 1940s were not just a period of origins. Instead, the experiences highlighted the need for a specific recipe of broad-based and coordinated national activism. It was the unfulfilled promises of the foundational period that laid the groundwork for future successes (p. 276). Ayers builds Laboured Protest on four principles. First, he returns to the beginning of the New Deal (1933) until the end of the Second World War (1945) bringing into focus the fault lines that hindered the movement as forces on the left converged. Second, he focuses on two case studies, New York City and Detroit—the “race” capital and “labour” capital, respectively—to marry the local and national dimensions of the movement. When and where only take the story so far, Ayers argues; whom defines the story. Laboured Protest’s third principle focuses on those affected, how black workers experienced and articulated the problems they faced in employment (p. 8). Finally, there is the central role of the achievements of the New Deal and wartime civil rights protest. By tracing the contours of black protest from the Great Depression, Ayers presents a period of “‘laboured protest” in which collaborative protest was undermined by personal, political, and generational differences. Behind the statistics that defined the losses and gains of the period lie thousands of individual stories. Ayers brings to light the impact of “laboured protest” on the lives of the very individuals who were given the “grand runaround” during this formative era. For example, Loretta Royal reported that her attempts to obtain employment were thwarted due to segregated housing; “a Harlem address is a dead giveaway” (p. 149). Executive order 8802 only inflamed the problem as the states became intolerant of wartime dissent. The Ford strike of 1941 showed the generational, political, and personal differences of the protest in Detroit. 154 The Michigan Historical Review Many black workers were reluctant to jettison their “hard-won” relationship with Ford where many younger workers sought to even the playing field (p. 120). The fractious nature of protest at both local and national levels tackled practical questions of funding, tactics, and leadership; powerful countervailing political forces revealed the deepseated dilemma about how best to tackle discrimination in employment. That returning black soldiers had a platform to lament the circumstances represented marked change from the pre-New Deal era. Ayers points out that the fight for fair employment was one of the most important consequences of the period. Laboured Protest as such muddies the historiographical waters, by illuminating the much-contested landscape of the New Deal and wartime years in tandem to show that the specific recipe of broad-based and coordinated activism needed to make headway was both sporadic and fleeting. Despite a somewhat nauseating number of acronyms that flood the pages, there is a marvelous amount of detail in an effortlessly told story about the energetic campaigning of an ultimately more complex and diverse movement towards fair employment. Gillian Macdonald Central Michigan University Barbara J. Barton. Manoomin: The Story of Wild Rice in Michigan. East Lansing: Michigan State University Press, 2018. Pp. 224. Appendices. Bibliography. Illustrations. Index. Notes. Paper: $29.95. Barbara J. Barton, an endangered-species biologist, argues that there were large beds of wild rice along the coastlines of the Great Lakes and inland waters of current-day Michigan before the arrival of Europeans. Manoomin, titled after the word in Anishinaabemowin for wild rice, begins by establishing...
Read full abstract