Reviews 285 photographs show and notes explain the changes caused by a massive flash flood in early June, 1965. This flood rerouted the river and overnight formed a major rapid. Moreover, the accompanying notes point out the various geo logic formations visible in the frames as well as changes in vegetation, streambed deposition or erosion, and, in some cases, man-made intrusions like powerlines , reservoirs and buildings. In tandem, the images and notes provide much food for the student of western landscapes. In working from the original plates, Stephens and the U.S.G.S. cartog raphers, thanks to retouching and modern developing techniques, have made the originals appear better than ever before. Certainly in their own day, Beaman and Hillers never obtained images as crisp and clear as these. And besides the originals appearing in their bast light, Stephens’s black and white photographs are themselves first-rate. The over-all excellence of the original photographs and their importance in the history of photography is a point wellmade by the authors and by Bruce Babbitt in his Foreword. Beaman and Hillers especially deserve more recognition as giants of early western photog raphy, in the same company as Timothy O’Sullivan and W. H. Jackson. JIM ATON Southern Utah State College Crossing Open Ground. By Barry Lopez. (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1988. 208 pages, $17.95.) In the long history ofwriters who have crossed open ground and attempted to evoke the mystery and life there, Barry Lopez is certainly distinguishing himself as one of the best. In the twelve years since Desert Notes appeared, Lopez has published six books, most notably Of Wolves and Men and Arctic Dreams. Unbeknownst to some of his readers, during this same period Lopez has also published frequently in magazines such as Harper’s, Outside, Science, Antaeus, and Orion Nature Quarterly. Crossing Open Ground collects the best of those pieces, and enhances Lopez’s standing as one of our finest writers. These fourteen essays cover a wide range of subjects—sperm whales, stone horses, the Anasazi, children in the woods and so on—and mostly occur in the West. Despite the diversity of subject matter, each piece argues in some way that what’s being observed is both precious and mysterious. Thus, behind every sharp observation, every luminous metaphor, stands the notion that landscape and its inhabitants are infinitely more complex than anyone will ever know. And that in itself, Lopez would say, should inculcate in us a sense of awe, respect and humility. Moreover, this writer understands both the power of language (and he uses it extraordinarily well) and its inadequacy finally to grasp it all. When he says, “I had no finished answer,” after a long and fine discussion of the ethics of killing seals to study them, no shame hangs on those words. 286 Western American Literature While Lopez’s writing has earned considerable attention in this country— the Burroughs award for Of Wolves and Men, the American Book Award for Arctic Dreams, and recently a Guggenheim—perhaps other parts of the literary world should stand up and take notice of this writer and his kind of writing. For example, Nobel committees have for too long defined literature as largely poetry, fiction and drama. Why not acknowledge a non-fiction prose writer, especially one who begins with the idea that mankind’s future is indissolubly linked with the intricate fabric of landscape? Picking a Lopez or a Laurens van der Post or a Peter Matthiessen would only enhance, for this reader, the stature of such an award. Besides calling attention to an oft-neglected genre of writing, such recognition might help change, in parts of the world at least, a fundamental attitude of arrogance toward anything not strictly human. That thought would indeed comfort the author of Crossing Open Ground as he contemplates such acts as the killing of seals. JIM ATON Southern Utah State College Bison Books. University of Nebraska Press. Betzinez, Jason, with Wilbur Sturtevant Nye. I Fought With Geronimo. $19.95/$7.95. Gay, E. Jane. With the Nez Perces: Alice Fletcher in the Field, 1889-92. $7.95. Mattes, Merrill J. The Great Platte River Road...
Read full abstract