What are the limits of quantum algorithms?

Answer from top 10 papers

Quantum algorithms are theoretically capable of solving certain problems much faster than classical algorithms, leveraging phenomena like superposition and entanglement (Molina et al., 2023; Motta & Rice, 2021; Russell & Stepney, 2014). However, there are fundamental limits to computation imposed by physical constraints, such as the speed at which a quantum computer can transition between states, which is constrained by the physical laws of motion and can be analyzed using the theory of Finsler metrics on Lie groups (Hadfield, 2018). Additionally, the current Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era is characterized by quantum processors that lack quantum error correction and are limited in scalability, affecting the implementation of quantum algorithms (Riandari et al., 2021).
Theoretical limits provide an upper bound on the performance of algorithms, and practical limitations are also present due to the nascent state of quantum hardware and the need for software co-design to understand and advance capabilities (Emani et al., 2021). Moreover, while quantum computing offers significant advantages in certain fields, it is not yet near commercialization, and researchers must contend with challenges such as noise, error rates, and the need for error mitigation techniques (Riandari et al., 2021; Russell & Stepney, 2014). Theoretical models like Instantaneous Quantum Computing Algorithms (IQCA) propose to extend beyond current quantum limits, but these are still largely conceptual and require further development (Yang & Zhong, 2023).
In summary, while quantum algorithms hold promise for computational speedups, their limits are defined by both theoretical and practical constraints, including physical laws, the current state of quantum hardware, and the presence of noise in quantum systems. These limitations must be addressed through ongoing research and development to realize the full potential of quantum computing (Emani et al., 2021; Hadfield, 2018; Riandari et al., 2021; Yang & Zhong, 2023).

Source Papers

Noise in digital and digital-analog quantum computation

Abstract Quantum computing uses quantum resources provided by the underlying quantum nature of matter to enhance classical computation. However, the current Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era in quantum computing is characterized by the use of quantum processors comprising from a few tens to, at most, a few hundreds of physical qubits without implementing quantum error correction techniques. This limits the scalability in the implementation of quantum algorithms. Digital-analog quantum computing (DAQC) has been proposed as a more resilient alternative quantum computing paradigm to outperform digital quantum computation within the NISQ era framework. It arises from adding the flexibility provided by fast single-qubit gates to the robustness of analog quantum simulations. Here, we perform a careful comparison between the digital and digital-analog paradigms under the presence of noise sources. The comparison is illustrated by comparing the performance of the quantum Fourier transform and quantum phase estimation algorithms under a wide range of single- and two-qubit noise sources. Indeed, we obtain that when the different noise channels usually present in superconducting quantum processors are considered, the fidelity of these algorithms for the digital-analog paradigm outperforms the one obtained for the digital approach. Additionally, this difference grows when the size of the processor scales up, making DAQC a sensible alternative paradigm in the NISQ era. Finally, we show how to adaptthe DAQC paradigm to quantum error mitigation techniques for canceling different noise sources, including the bang error.

Open Access
Quantum computing at the frontiers of biological sciences.

The search for meaningful structure in biological data has relied on cutting-edge advances in computational technology and data science methods. However, challenges arise as we push the limits of scale and complexity in biological problems. Innovation in massively parallel, classical computing hardware and algorithms continues to address many of these challenges, but there is a need to simultaneously consider new paradigms to circumvent current barriers to processing speed. Accordingly, we articulate a view towards quantum computation and quantum information science, where algorithms have demonstrated potential polynomial and exponential computational speedups in certain applications, such as machine learning. The maturation of the field of quantum computing, in hardware and algorithm development, also coincides with the growth of several collaborative efforts to address questions across length and time scales, and scientific disciplines. We use this coincidence to explore the potential for quantum computing to aid in one such endeavor: the merging of insights from genetics, genomics, neuroimaging and behavioral phenotyping. By examining joint opportunities for computational innovation across fields, we highlight the need for a common language between biological data analysis and quantum computing. Ultimately, we consider current and future prospects for the employment of quantum computing algorithms in the biological sciences.

Open Access
Quantum computing for production planning

This research investigates the potential of quantum computing in production planning and addresses the limitations of conventional computing approaches. Traditional methods have been partially effective, but they struggle to solve complex optimization problems, accurately predict demand, and manage supply chains efficiently. The unique computational capabilities of quantum computing offer promising solutions to surmount these obstacles and revolutionize production planning processes. This study seeks to bridge the gap between quantum computing and production planning by analyzing the benefits, limitations, and challenges of its applicability in this field. It proposes customized algorithms and methodologies for leveraging quantum computation to enhance production planning efficiency, cost reduction, and decision-making processes. The research demonstrates the potential of quantum algorithms to minimize total production costs while appeasing demand and resource constraints through a numerical example and mathematical formulation. The results emphasize the advantages of quantum computing in terms of cost reduction, enhanced efficiency, and scalability. Comparisons with conventional methods illuminate the benefits and drawbacks of quantum computing in production planning. This research contributes to the development of novel strategies to improve production planning efficiency, lower costs, and enhance decision-making processes, allowing organizations to leverage quantum computing for optimized production operations

Open Access
Simulating Noisy Quantum Circuits for Cryptographic Algorithms

The emergence of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers has important consequences for cryptographic algorithms. It is theoretically well-established that key algorithms used in cybersecurity are vulnerable to quantum computers due to the fact that theoretical security guarantees, designed based on algorithmic complexity for classical computers, are not sufficient for quantum circuits. Many different quantum algorithms have been developed, which have potentially broad applications on future computing systems. However, this potential depends on the continued maturation of quantum hardware, which remains an area of active research and development. Theoretical limits provide an upper bound on the performance for algorithms. In practice, threats to encryption can only be accurately be assessed in the context of the rapidly evolving hardware and software landscape. Software co-design refers to the concurrent design of software and hardware as a way to understand the limitations of current capabilities and develop effective strategies to advance the state of the art. Since the capabilities for classical computation currently exceed quantum capabilities, quantum emulation techniques can play an important role in the co-design process. In this paper, we describe how the {\em cuQuantum} environment can support quantum algorithm co-design activities using widely-available commodity hardware. We describe how emulation techniques can be used to assess the impact of noise on algorithms of interest, and identify limitations associated with current hardware. We present our analysis in the context of areas of priority for cybersecurity and cryptography in particular since these algorithms are extraordinarily consequential for securing information in the digital world.

Preliminary study for developing instantaneous quantum computing algorithms (IQCA)

Since the mid-1990s theoretical quadratic exponential and polynomial Quantum Computing (QC) speedup algorithms have been discussed. Recently the advent of relativistic information processing (RIP) introducing a relativistic qubit (r-qubit) with additional degrees of freedom beyond the current Hilbert space Bloch 2-sphere qubit formalism extended theory has appeared. In this work a penultimate form of QC speedup – Instantaneous Quantum Computing Algorithms (IQCA) is proposed. Discussion exists on passing beyond the quantum limits of locality and unitarity heretofore restricting the evolution of quantum systems to the standard Copenhagen Interpretation. In that respect as introduced in prior work an ontological-phase topological QC avails itself of extended modeling. As well-known by EPR experiments instantaneous connectivity exists inherently in the nonlocal arena. As our starting point we utilize Bohm’s super-implicate order where inside a wave packet a super-quantum potential introduces nonlocal connectivity. Additionally EPR experiments entangle simultaneously emitted photon pairs by parametric down-conversion. Operating an IQCA requires a parametric up-conversion cycle an M-Theoretic Unified Field Mechanical (MUFM) set of topological transformations beyond the current Galilean Lorentz-Poincairé transforms of the standard model (SM). Yang-Mills Kaluza-Klein (YM-KK) correspondence is shown to provide a path beyond the semi-quantum limit to realize the local-nonlocal duality required to implement IQCA.

Open Access