Rise and Fall of the American Temperance Movement
Answer from top 10 papers
The American temperance movement, which sought to reduce the consumption of alcohol, experienced both a rise and a subsequent fall. Historians have traditionally viewed this movement as predominantly driven by white evangelicals, but recent scholarship has highlighted the significant contributions of Black Americans to the temperance cause, challenging the narrative of a white-led movement and recognizing the multifaceted nature of Black activism within it (Owens, 2011). Additionally, cognitive-behavioral factors, such as attribution bias and scapegoat theory, have been identified as contributing to the movement's eventual failure during National Prohibition, as reformers largely ignored the context of alcohol consumption and targeted alcohol itself as the main source of social issues (Crafts, 2016).
Interestingly, the temperance movement's impact on crime rates was complex, with evidence suggesting that while criminalizing alcohol markets reduced some forms of violence, it also increased systemic violence, particularly among young adults in urban areas with large immigrant populations (Hoyer, 2022; Imraz et al., 2022). This unintended consequence underscores the multifaceted outcomes of the temperance movement's policies.
In summary, the rise and fall of the American temperance movement were influenced by a diverse coalition of activists, including overlooked contributions from Black Americans, and were marked by cognitive biases among its proponents. The movement's policies had varied effects on society, including shifts in crime dynamics. These findings contribute to a more nuanced understanding of the temperance movement's legacy and the complexities of social reform movements (Crafts, 2016; Hoyer, 2022; Imraz et al., 2022; Owens, 2011).
Source Papers