Almost 20 years has elapsed since the introduction of the Children Act 2004 following the tragic death of Victoria Climbie in February 2000. evaluate the impact of the Act

Answer from top 10 papers

The Children Act 2004 was introduced in response to the death of Victoria Climbie, aiming to improve child protection and welfare in the UK. An evaluation of its impact reveals a complex picture. While some studies indicate progress, such as the audit in a tertiary hospital in the UK, which aimed to measure compliance with the Laming recommendations, showing adherence to certain recommendations (Muda & Alwi, 2011), other research highlights ongoing challenges. For instance, general practice has experienced an increase in bureaucratic demands, potentially detracting from effective child safeguarding (Fitzpatrick, 2011). Moreover, the literature suggests that while safeguarding policies have been implemented, there is a need for further education and training among healthcare professionals, including paramedics, to ensure children's safety (Brady, 2012; Patrick et al., 2020).
Contradictions and interesting facts emerge when considering the broader implications of the Act and similar legislation. For example, despite the implementation of the Child Protection Act in Taiwan, the in-hospital death proportion of physically abused children did not significantly change post-implementation (Douglas, 2016). Additionally, in the United States, amendments to child welfare legislation did not result in a substantial increase in referrals to developmental services for children involved in substantiated cases of abuse (Chou et al., 2019). Furthermore, while certain child welfare services have been shown to protect against fatal child maltreatment, the effectiveness varies by maltreatment type, and further research is needed (Welch & Bonner, 2013).
In summary, the Children Act 2004 has had a mixed impact on child protection. While there are indications of improved compliance with safeguarding recommendations in healthcare settings (Muda & Alwi, 2011), challenges persist in the form of bureaucratic pressures (Fitzpatrick, 2011) and the need for enhanced training (Brady, 2012; Patrick et al., 2020). Additionally, similar legislation in other countries has not always led to the desired outcomes, as seen in Taiwan (Douglas, 2016) and the United States (Chou et al., 2019). The effectiveness of child welfare services in preventing fatal maltreatment also requires further investigation (Welch & Bonner, 2013). Overall, while the Act represents a significant legislative effort to protect children, its impact is nuanced and indicates the need for ongoing evaluation and refinement of child protection measures.

Source Papers

Care and Protection against Child Abuse: With Special Reference to Malaysia Child Act 2001

All children have the right to live in an environment free from abuse and neglect. The safety of children is the paramount concern that must guide child protection efforts. It is in this context that reference of this paper will be made to The Child Act 2001, the key outcome of Malaysia’s ratification of the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) which forms part of the protective legal environment for children in the country. Initiatives have been introduced under this Act to safeguard children from abuse, neglect and violence such as incest which has been criminalized by the Penal Code and the Domestic Violence Act which protects the child against violence within family. This Act was introduced to consolidate and amend the laws relating to the care, protection and rehabilitation of children. With the Act beforehand, numbers of child abuse cases are still alarming. Therefore, this article is an attempt to give an overview of care and protection provided under the Child Act 2001 towards children who are being the victims of abuse. The main purpose of this article is to evaluate the extent of the protection and care given under the Act to safeguard the children in the social justice system in Malaysia. At the end of the paper some areas are identified for further improvement and future amendment.

Open Access
Can child safeguarding training be improved?: findings of a multidisciplinary audit.

Child protection has become a very poignant subject in the UK. The Laming report into the death of Victoria Climbié led to the implementation of multidisciplinary safeguarding policies and training for healthcare professionals, social services staff and police. However, many dental practitioners, as well as other healthcare professionals, have little confidence when reporting their concerns and reducing the 'gap' between suspicion and reporting (Laming in The victoria climbie inquiry: report of an inquiry by Lord Laming, 2003. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-victoria-climbie-inquiry-report-of-an-inquiry-by-lord-laming ). Our audit aimed to identify and address the barriers of reporting safeguarding concerns amongst the hospital team. Questionnaires were distributed to staff at Surrey and Sussex Healthcare National Health Service Trust with a valid Safeguarding Children Level 3 certificate in order to assess their knowledge of safeguarding children. Changes to traditional safeguarding training (Group 1) were implemented to include a broader range of speakers, each speaking for shorter times with more personal and focused presentations (Groups 2 and 3). Three cohorts of participants were assessed including healthcare assistants, nurses, dentists, and doctors. Group 1 (n = 100) reported 64% experience of reporting compared with group 2 (n = 100) 43% and group 3 (n = 76) 51%. Confidence was higher in those with more experience in child protection. The most common barrier was the uncertainty of diagnosis. More barriers to reporting existed in the new style of training in groups 2 and 3. The scenarios were answered with appropriate concern and reporting by groups 1 and 2, however, less for group 3. Experienced and trained practitioners are more likely to refer children to child protection teams when they have concerns of abuse or neglect. Personalising training was shown to be less effective and the focus should be more on diagnosis and local protocols. Early training from undergraduate level was a unanimous request. Focused training on diagnosis and local protocols, accompanied by bespoke teaching for specific specialties would be the most constructive tool for safeguarding children. Exploring modern methods such as simulation-based training could be effective. Structured forms and local policies that are familiar to clinicians prevent omissions and encourage professional awareness.

Open Access
Evaluation of the effect of the child protection act on serious child physical abuse in Taiwan

BackgroundFew studies have examined the effects of the Child Protection Act on child maltreatment in Taiwan. ObjectiveThis study estimated the secular trends in the incidence rate of physical abuse of children requiring hospitalization between 1996 and 2013, and the subsequent in-hospital death proportion before and after implementation of the Act in 2003. Participants and settingThe cases were children younger than 12 years old who were hospitalized due to child abuse, shaken-baby syndrome, neglect, or homicide between 1996 and 2013. A comparison group consisted of children requiring hospitalization for other reasons. We used the National Health Insurance database to identify patients. MethodsThe Joinpoint Regression Program was used to estimate temporal trends in the standardized incidence rates. ResultsBetween 1996 and 2013, 2050 children required hospitalization for physical abuse. Before 2005, the annual percent change increased by 9.40 [95% confidence interval (CI), 4.98–14.00] per year, and after 2005 the annual percent change was –4.80 (95% CI, –9.53–0.17) per year. Among the 2050 physically abused children requiring hospitalization, 83 (4%) died in hospital. The in-hospital death proportion was 2.62% before 2003 and 4.90% after 2003, and the ratio of these two proportions was 1.43 (95% CI, 0.80–2.58). ConclusionsThe trend in the incidence of hospitalization of children due to physical-abuse-related injuries started to decline 2 years after implementation of the Child Protection Act. However, the proportion of children who died in hospital as a result of physical abuse requiring hospitalization did not change.

Fatal child neglect: Characteristics, causation, and strategies for prevention

Research in child fatalities because of abuse and neglect has continued to increase, yet the mechanisms of the death incident and risk factors for these deaths remain unclear. The purpose of this study was to systematically examine the types of neglect that resulted in children's deaths as determined by child welfare and a child death review board. This case review study reviewed 22 years of data (n=372) of child fatalities attributed solely to neglect taken from a larger sample (N=754) of abuse and neglect death cases spanning the years 1987–2008. The file information reviewed was provided by the Oklahoma Child Death Review Board (CDRB) and the Oklahoma Department of Human Services (DHS) Division of Children and Family Services. Variables of interest were child age, ethnicity, and birth order; parental age and ethnicity; cause of death as determined by child protective services (CPS); and involvement with DHS at the time of the fatal event. Three categories of fatal neglect – supervisory neglect, deprivation of needs, and medical neglect – were identified and analyzed. Results found an overwhelming presence of supervisory neglect in child neglect fatalities and indicated no significant differences between children living in rural and urban settings. Young children and male children comprised the majority of fatalities, and African American and Native American children were over-represented in the sample when compared to the state population. This study underscores the critical need for prevention and educational programming related to appropriate adult supervision and adequate safety measures to prevent a child's death because of neglect.