Wi-Fi as Public Utility or Public Park? Metaphors for Planning Local Communication Infrastructure

Abstract

The spaces of cities are increasingly virtual, and planners and managers are faced with the challenge of integrating the infrastructure that supports these spaces into their existing city plans. In North America, many community and municipal Wi-Fi networks developed as a response to limited provision of internet access, suggesting that such local networks - as provided by local governments or community organizations - should be considered services. This paper argues that the metaphors for understanding communication networks should be expanded from the metaphor of the public utility that understands Wi-Fi as similar to water or electricity, to include the public park metaphor that introduces the potential for the internet to act as a good, while acknowledging that Wi-Fi zones may depend on limited bandwidth resources. Although limited, these resources provide potential for applications that increase benefit, such as location-specific services or community media. Additionally, the public park metaphor describes how Wi-Fi networks can operate as playful spaces inspiring greater innovation. Case studies of a municipal and community Wi-Fi network from Canada demonstrate how such metaphors provide ways of framing the potential outcomes of Wi-Fi services. This paper discusses how the public service and public park metaphors for Wi-Fi networking can be applied to Fredericton's Fred-eZone project, North America's first municipally owned free Wi-Fi network, and Montreal's volunteer-designed Ile Sans Fil project.