Uninsured Maternity Patients in Calgary: Local Trends and Survey of Health Care Workers.

Abstract

Uninsured maternity patients comprise a small but complex group of patients and include marginalized Canadians, undocumented immigrants, visitors, and non-Canadians seeking health care and/or citizenship for their newborn. This is the first Canadian study to quantify these patients and to review health care providers' perspectives and practices of care. Data for all deliveries in Calgary, Alberta over a 4-year period (2013-2016) were analyzed. All Calgary anaesthesiologists, family physicians, midwives, neonatologists, obstetricians, and pediatricians were surveyed about their care of these patients, ethical perspectives, and knowledge of liability protection when providing such care. This study found a trend of uninsured deliveries in Calgary (from 0.5% in 2013 to 0.8% in 2016; P < 0.0001) that is accounted for by non-Canadian patients. Midwives and physicians agree on provision of emergency care but not preventive care. Across medical specialties, fewer caregivers felt obliged to care for non-Canadian patients seeking citizenship for their newborn. Among physicians, 61% were aware of the Canadian Medical Protective Association's guidelines on liability coverage for non-Canadian patients, and only 28% consistently protected themselves legally. There is large variation regarding whether physicians bill for services when the patient is uninsured. In Calgary, the study observed an increase in numbers of uninsured maternity patients. Differing ethical perspectives on the care of these patients may lead to conflict within health care teams because of differences on ethical perspectives of care among team members. Health care providers require education to understand the implications and challenges of obstetrical care of non-Canadians.