Two-year Investigations on Herbicide-Resistant Silky Bent Grass (Apera spica-venti L. Beauv.) Populations in Winter Wheat—Population Dynamics, Yield Losses, Control Efficacy and Introgression into Sensitive Population

Abstract

In this study, the results of two-year investigations on herbicide resistance in silky bent grass (Apera spica-venti) populations are presented. Two populations of A. spica-venti were sown in a winter wheat field at the Ihinger Hof Research Station near Stuttgart in Germany in October 2008. Whole-plant bioassays conducted with both populations in the greenhouse before the field trial was set up revealed that population A was strongly resistant to acetolactate synthase (ALS)-inhibitors, whereas population B was sensitive to this group of herbicides. Each block was treated with isoproturon, fenoxaprop-P-ethyl, sulfosulfuron and meso-iodosulfuron at the recommended field dose. One treatment remained unsprayed. It was found that the average number of silky bent grass panicles was significantly higher in the second year (2010) with 343 panicles m− 2 in the untreated control compared to 44 panicles m− 2 in the first year (2009). Efficacy of both ALS-inhibitors was significantly reduced in the resistant population compared to the sensitive population. Grass-weed plants surviving treatments with ALS-inhibitors produced the same number of seeds as the untreated plants. It was found that germination rate of seeds from the resistant population was more than threefold higher than from the sensitive population. Grain yield was equal in all treatments and populations in 2009. In 2010, applications of isoproturon and fenoxaprop-P-ethyl resulted in higher grain yields, with a mean of 4.6 t ha− 1 compared to an average of 3.9 t ha− 1 in the plots treated with sulfosulfuron and meso-iodosulfuron and 4.3 t ha− 1 in the untreated plots. However, these differences were not statistically significant. The sensitive population of the second generation (2009/2010) was approximately 20% more tolerant to ALS-inhibitors than the sensitive population of the first generation (2008/2009) which indicates introgression of herbicide resistance traits already after one year. These results clearly show that herbicide resistance to ALS-inhibitors in silky bent grass is likely to spread rapidly causing significant economic losses. Therefore, management strategies need to be developed and tested to prevent and overcome herbicide resistance in European cereal production systems.