Transferability and Reproducibility of the HepaRG CometChip Assay

The use of single cell gel electrophoresis (SCGE) has recently been applied to plant systems. We optimized the experimental conditions for SCGE analysis using nuclei isolated from different tissues of intact plants. Concentration-response curves of genomic DNA migration were analyzed in intact plants treated with the monofunctional alkylating agents ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU), and N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU). These data were used to calibrate SCGE tail moment values to induced somatic mutation in plant leaves. We used a genotoxicity index to compare genomic DNA damage and the induction of somatic mutation in the leaf tissues. The rank order of the genotoxic potency of these alkylating agents assayed by SCGE was MNU >> MMS > ENU > EMS. The rank order for the mutagenic potency of these agents was MNU >> ENU congruent with MMS > EMS. The data demonstrate the utility of SCGE analysis in plant systems. The use of SCGE will permit a larger range of plants for use as in situ environmental monitors. Also, this approach may be used to search for crop plant germplasm accessions with enhanced genomic stability. We investigated whether the intragenomic distributions of DNA damage induced by these alkylating agents were uniform and random. When a plot of the ratio of the %tail DNA and tail length versus the concentration of the test mutagen was generated, the induced SCGE data deviated from a random distribution of genomic DNA damage.

Genotoxicity testing is critical for predicting adverse effects of pharmaceutical, industrial, and environmental chemicals. The comet assay is a commonly used approach for detecting DNA damage that is based on the underlying principle that damaged DNA migrates more readily than undamaged DNA when electrophoresed in agarose. We previously developed a higher-throughput version of the comet assay (Wood DK, PNAS 2010). For the “CometChip” assay, cells are loaded into an array of agarose microwells to create a cell microarray. The CometChip can be fully automated, making the assay more than 1000X faster, while improving reproducibility. While effective for detecting single-strand breaks, abasic sites, and alkali-sensitive sites, the alkaline comet assay is not effective for detection of carcinogenic bulky DNA lesions that do not impact DNA mobility and that require metabolic activation. To overcome this, we use DNA replication inhibitors (hydroxyurea and 1-β-d-arabinofuranosyl cytosine) shown to trap single-strand breaks that are formed during nucleotide excision repair, which normally removes bulky lesions. Thus, comet-undetectable bulky lesions are converted into comet-detectable single-strand breaks. Together with HepaRG™ cells that recapitulate in vivo metabolic capacity, we have thus created the “HepaCometChip,” which provides a more broadly effective approach for detection of DNA damage. In addition to genotoxicity testing, the microwell array has also been harnessed for use in a cell survival assay. For the “MicroColonyChip” (Ngo LP, Cell Reports 2019), cells are loaded into the agarose microwell array and allowed to grow to form microcolonies. Differences in cell survival can be detected by changes in the distribution of colony sizes, a novel metric for cell survival quantitation. The assay is as sensitive as the traditional “gold standard” colony-forming assay, yet it takes days instead of weeks to complete. Parallel studies of genotoxicity and cytotoxicity can thus be performed using a shared microwell platform. These tools have broad utility, including studies of microbe-induced DNA damage. Examples of S. pneumoniae and E. coli microbial product-induced double-strand breaks and interstrand crosslinks contribute to an emerging paradigm wherein pathogen-induced DNA damage has the potential to promote disease. Citation Format: Le P. Ngo, Prashant Rai, Matthew R. Wilson, Carole Swartz, John Winters, Yang Su, Jing Ge, Tze-Khee Chan, Emily P. Balskus, Vincent Chow, Les Recio, Leona D. Samson, Bevin P. Engelward. Novel cell microarray technologies for studies of DNA damage and cell survival and applications for studies of microbe-induced DNA damage [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference on Environmental Carcinogenesis: Potential Pathway to Cancer Prevention; 2019 Jun 22-24; Charlotte, NC. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Can Prev Res 2020;13(7 Suppl): Abstract nr IA20.

The in vivo comet assay can evaluate the genotoxic potential of a chemical in theoretically any tissue that can be processed to a single cell suspension. This flexibility enables evaluation of point‐of‐contact tissues using a relevant route of test material administration; however, assessing cytotoxicity is essential for the interpretation of comet results. Histopathological evaluation is routinely utilized to assess cytotoxicity, but temporal‐ and cell‐specific considerations may compromise applicability to the comet assay. In the present study, 1,1′‐methylenebis(4‐isocyanatobenzene) (4,4'‐MDI) was administered to rats for 6 h by nose‐only inhalation, and the comet assay was conducted to evaluate genotoxicity in the site‐of‐contact tissue (bronchoalveolar lavage cells) and distal tissues (liver and glandular stomach). Given the reactive nature of MDI, cellular and molecular metrics at the site‐of‐contact‐ including inflammation, macrophage activation, apoptosis/necrosis, and oxidative stress‐ were used to set appropriate exposure concentrations, in addition to the standard systemic measures of toxicity. In the range‐finding study, a concentration of 4 mg/m3 was considered the maximum noninflammatory concentration; hence target concentrations of 2, 5, and 11 mg/m3 were selected for the comet study. In the lung lavage, MDI exposure substantially increased total protein and β‐glucuronidase, along with cellular apoptosis. Although MDI did not increase the comet assay response (% tail DNA) in any of the tissues examined, the positive control (ethyl methanesulfonate, EMS) significantly increased % tail DNA in all tissues. In total, these data indicate that appropriate cellular and molecular measurements may facilitate dose selection to discern cellular status in the comet assay.

There is increased interest in the in vivo comet assay in rodents as a follow-up approach for determining the biological relevance of chemicals that are genotoxic in in vitro assays. This is partly because, unlike other assays, DNA damage can be assessed in this assay in virtually any tissue. Since background levels of DNA damage can vary with the species, tissue, and cell processing method, a robust historical control database covering multiple tissues is essential. We describe extensive vehicle and positive control data for multiple tissues from rats and mice. In addition, we report historical data from control and genotoxin-treated human blood. Technical issues impacting comet results are described, including the method of cell preparation and freezing. Cell preparation by scraping (stomach and other GI tract organs) resulted in higher % tail DNA than mincing (liver, spleen, kidney etc) or direct collection (blood or bone marrow). Treatment with the positive control genotoxicant, ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) in rats and methyl methanesulfonate in mice, resulted in statistically significant increases in % tail DNA. Background DNA damage was not markedly increased when cell suspensions were stored frozen prior to preparing slides, and the outcome of the assay was unchanged (EMS was always positive). In conclusion, historical data from our laboratory for the in vivo comet assay for multiple tissues from rats and mice, as well as human blood show very good reproducibility. These data and recommendations provided are aimed at contributing to the design and proper interpretation of results from comet assays.

Mammalian nucleotide excision repair (NER), known for its broad substrate specificity, is responsible for removal of bulky lesions from DNA. Over 30 proteins are involved in NER, which includes two distinct pathways: global genome NER and transcription-coupled repair. The complexity of these processes, the use of extended DNA substrates, and the presence of bulky DNA lesions induced by chemotherapy have driven researchers to seek more effective methods by which to assess NER activity, as well as to develop model DNAs that serve as efficient substrates for studying lesion removal. In this work, we conducted a comparative analysis of model DNAs containing bulky lesions. One of these lesions, N-[6-{5(6)-fluoresceinylcarbamoyl}hexanoyl]-3-amino-1,2-propanediol (nFluL), is known to be efficiently recognized and excised by NER. The second lesion, N-[6-{5(6)-fluoresceinylcarbamoyl}]-3-amino-1,2-propanediol (nFluS), has not previously been tested as a substrate for NER. To evaluate the efficiency of lesion excision, a 3'-terminal labeling method was employed to analyze the excision products. The results showed that nFluS is removed approximately twice as efficiently as nFluL. Comparative analyses of the effects of nFluL and nFluS on the geometry and thermal stability of DNA duplexes - combined with spectrophotometric and spectrofluorimetric titrations of these DNAs with complementary strands - were performed next. They revealed that the absence of an extended flexible linker in nFluS alters the interaction of the bulky fluorescein moiety with neighboring nitrogenous bases in double-stranded DNA. This absence is associated with the enhanced efficiency of excision of nFluS, making it a more effective synthetic analog for studying bulky-lesion removal in model DNA substrates.

Detection of DNA strand breaks in brown trout ( Salmo trutta) hepatocytes and blood cells using the single cell gel electrophoresis (comet) assay

Genotoxicity testing is critical for predicting adverse effects of pharmaceutical, industrial, and environmental chemicals. The alkaline comet assay is an established method for detecting DNA strand breaks, however, the assay does not detect potentially carcinogenic bulky adducts that can arise when metabolic enzymes convert pro-carcinogens into a highly DNA reactive products. To overcome this, we use DNA synthesis inhibitors (hydroxyurea and 1-β-d-arabinofuranosyl cytosine) to trap single strand breaks that are formed during nucleotide excision repair, which primarily removes bulky lesions. In this way, comet-undetectable bulky lesions are converted into comet-detectable single strand breaks. Moreover, we use HepaRG™ cells to recapitulate in vivo metabolic capacity, and leverage the CometChip platform (a higher throughput more sensitive comet assay) to create the ‘HepaCometChip’, enabling the detection of bulky genotoxic lesions that are missed by current genotoxicity screens. The HepaCometChip thus provides a broadly effective approach for detection of bulky DNA adducts.

Genotoxicity of polyvinylpyrrolidone-coated silver nanoparticles in BEAS 2B cells

New applications of the Comet assay: Comet-FISH and transcription-coupled DNA repair.

Liver-on-chip model and application in predictive genotoxicity and mutagenicity of drugs

Looking at the development status of Nigeria and other developing nations, most low-income and rural households often use coal as a source of energy which necessitates its trade very close to the communities. Moreover, the effects of exposure to coal mining activities are rarely explored or yet to be studied, not to mention the numerous street coal vendors in Nigeria. This study investigated the oxidative stress levels in serum and urine through the biomarker 8-OHdG and DNA damage via single cell gel electrophoresis (alkaline comet assay). Blood and urine levels of 8-OHdG from 130 coal vendors and 130 population-based controls were determined by ELISA. Alkaline comet assay was also performed on white blood cells for DNA damage. The average values of 8-OHdG in serum and urine of coal vendors were 22.82 and 16.03ng/ml respectively, which were significantly greater than those detected in controls (p < 0.001; 15.46 and 10.40ng/ml of 8-OHdG in serum and urine respectively). The average tail length, % DNA in tail and olive tail moment were 25.06 μm, 18.71% and 4.42 respectively for coal vendors. However, for controls, the average values were 4.72 μm, 3.63% and 1.50 for tail length, % DNA in tail and olive tail moment respectively which were much lower than coal vendors (p < 0.001). Therefore, prolonged exposure to coal dusts could lead to higher serum and urinary 8-OHdG and significant DNA damage in coal vendors observed in tail length, % DNA in tail, and olive tail moment by single cell gel electrophoresis. It is therefore established that coal vendors exhibit a huge risk from oxidative stress and assessment of 8-OHdG with single cell gel electrophoresis has proven to be a feasible tool as biomarkers of DNA damage.

BackgroundIndividual susceptibility to endogenous and/or exogenous DNA damage depends on DNA repair efficiency and can be evaluated using the comet assay with bleomycin as genotoxic agent. The aim of the study was to evaluate baseline and bleomycin-induced DNA damage and DNA repair capacity in peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) of endometrial cancer (EC) patients considering a family history of cancer.MethodsDNA damage was analyzed in PBLs of 45 EC patients compared to a control group of 10 healthy women, using the comet assay. The level of DNA damage was determined by the% tail DNA.ResultsThe level of baseline DNA damage in PBLs of EC patients was significantly higher (% DNA in tail 9.31 ± 15.32) than in healthy women (% DNA in tail 3.41 ± 4.71) (P <0.01). PBLs of EC patients repaired less bleomycin-induced DNA damage (removed% DNA in tail 63.94 ± 20.92) than PBLs of healthy individuals (removed% DNA in tail 80.24 ± 3.03) (P <0.001). Efficiency of DNA repair in PBLs of EC patients depended on the family history of cancer. The amount of restored damaged DNA was significantly lower (removed% DNA in tail 36.24 ± 14.05%) in EC patients with a family history of cancer compared to patients with sporadic EC (removed% DNA in tail 64.91 ± 19.36%) (P <0.004).ConclusionsLymphocytes of EC patients are characterized by an increased basal level of DNA damage as well as deficiency in DNA repair. DNA repair is less efficient in PBLs of EC patients with a family history of cancer compared to patients with sporadic cancer.

Slight hypercalcemia is not associated with positive responses in the Comet Assay in male rat liver

Nucleotide excision repair is a well-conserved DNA repair pathway that removes bulky and/or helix-distorting DNA lesions, such as UV-induced cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers and pyrimidine (6-4) pyrimidone photoproducts. Transcription-coupled repair (TCR) is a subpathway of nucleotide excision repair that is dedicated to rapid removal of DNA lesions in the transcribed strand of actively transcribed genes. In eukaryotic cells, TCR is triggered by RNA polymerase II (RNAP II). Rad26, a DNA-dependent ATPase, Rpb9, a nonessential subunit of RNAP II, and Sen1, a 5' to 3' RNA/DNA and DNA helicase, have been shown to facilitate TCR in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. In contrast, a number of factors have also been found to repress TCR in the yeast. These TCR repressors include Rpb4, another nonessential subunit of RNAP II, Spt4/5, a transcription elongation factor complex, and the RNAP II-associated factor 1 complex (PAFc). It appears that the eukaryotic TCR process involves intricate interplays of RNAP II with TCR facilitators and repressors. In this minireview, we summarize recent advances in TCR in S. cerevisiae.

Chronic exposure to high (20,000 ppm) concentrations of tert-butyl alcohol (TBA) in drinking water, equivalent to ~2100 mg/kg bodyweight per day, is associated with slight increases in the incidence of thyroid follicular cell adenomas and carcinomas in mice, with no other indications of carcinogenicity. In a recent toxicological review of TBA, the U.S. EPA determined that the genotoxic potential of TBA was inconclusive, largely based on non-standard studies such as in vitro comet assays. As such, the potential role of genotoxicity in the mode of action of thyroid tumors and therefore human relevance was considered uncertain. To address the potential role of genotoxicity in TBA-associated thyroid tumor formation, CD-1 mice were exposed up to a maximum tolerated dose of 1500 mg/kg-day via oral gavage for two consecutive days and DNA damage was assessed with the comet assay in the thyroid. Blood TBA levels were analyzed by headspace GC-MS to confirm systemic tissue exposure. At study termination, no significant increases (DNA breakage) or decreases (DNA crosslinks) in %DNA tail were observed in TBA exposed mice. In contrast, oral gavage of the positive control ethyl methanesulfonate significantly increased %DNA tail in the thyroid. These findings are consistent with most genotoxicity studies on TBA and provide mechanistic support for non-linear, threshold toxicity criteria for TBA. While the mode of action for the thyroid tumors remains unclear, linear low dose extrapolation methods for TBA appear more a matter of policy than science.