Topographic and compositional influences on disturbance patterns in a northern Maine old-growth landscape

Abstract

Disturbance patterns are strongly coupled with forest composition and structure, and patterns change through time in response to shifts in climate, anthropogenic impacts and other factors. Knowledge of the natural disturbance patterns for establishing baseline conditions for a forest type or ecosystem facilitates change detection for other elements of the biophysical system important to management and conservation. Dendrochronological reconstructions from old-growth forest remnants throughout northeastern North America document average decadal rates of disturbance of 5%–<10% over the last 150–300 years. Relatively frequent, low severity disturbance characterized by small gaps representing canopy openings made by 1–3 trees prevail in these forests dominated by varying mixtures of late-successional tree species. Few studies, though, have explicitly characterized differences related to composition or topographic setting in old-growth landscapes. We addressed this by comparing the temporal and spatial disturbance patterns reconstructed from tree rings at two spatial resolutions (0.5 ha and 200 m 2). Sites were selected to assess the influence of topography (slope) and cover type in stands where red spruce ( Picea rubens Sarg) and balsam fir ( Abies balsamea L. Mill) were key components. Low rates of disturbance (average <10% per decade) and small gap sizes (≤30 m 2) prevailed in all stands during the decades from 1850–1980. Episodic pulses of disturbance, of nearly moderate intensity in some stands, opened ca. 20–30% of the canopy area and were associated with wind events and/or insect outbreaks that differentially affected stands. We found no significant difference in the average temporal rates of disturbance related to cover type or topography in 0.5-ha plots. However, the influence of these factors was evident in comparisons of gap areas estimated for 200-m 2 plot sections. At this resolution, the largest canopy openings (≥100 m 2) occurred most frequently in slope sites, enabling pulses of canopy accession for Betula alleghaniensis (Britton). Whereas the smallest canopy openings (≤30 m 2) dominated softwood stands, favoring red spruce, balsam fir and other shade-tolerant species throughout the forest. The variable effects of common disturbance agents, regardless of topographic position and/or cover types, points to the important role of biological legacies determining stand structure and composition on subsequent disturbance events and long-term patterns.