Thoracoscopic Versus Transaxillary Approach to First Rib Resection in Thoracic Outlet Syndrome

Abstract

This study assessed the feasibility of fully endoscopic thoracoscopic first rib resection (FRR) in the treatment of neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome by comparing early outcomes of the thoracoscopic technique against the traditional transaxillary FRR. Between 2009 and 2016, 60 consecutive FRRs were performed on 47 patients with neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome (13 bilateral procedures). The first 30 procedures were performed using the traditional transaxillary technique, and the novel thoracoscopic technique was used in the next 30 operations with the same indications for operative repair. All data were collected retrospectively by independent investigators. The main issues were operation time, learning curve, hospital length of stay, complications, and clinical follow-up status at 3 months. The groups were similar at baseline. The mean operation time was 83 ± 27 minutes in the thoracoscopic group and 48 ± 12 minutes in the transaxillary group (p < 0.001). The first thoracoscopic procedures were 2 hours long, after which, a steady 1-hour procedure time was achieved. Differences regarding the hospital stay or the need for postoperative pain medication were not significant. Two-thirds reported good or excellent recovery at follow-up in both groups. There were no immediate complications. Plexus neuralgia developed in 1 patient 3 weeks after the thoracoscopic operation, and 3 patients were diagnosed with superficial wound infection after the transaxillary procedure. This study showed that FRR for neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome can be done safely with a fully endoscopic approach. However, the technique requires experience with thoracoscopic surgery, and there is a learning curve to the procedure.