The stability of vertical distribution profiles of insects in air layers near the ground

Abstract

The vertical distribution of insect orders, families, and species captured over 10 elevations from the ground to 15 m over 4 years in a potato agro-ecosystem differed considerably within and between taxa. Regression slopes representing these aerial profiles remained similar over the 4 years of the study for orders Thysanoptera, Neuroptera, and Psocoptera, changed considerably for Hemiptera, Homoptera and Ephemeroptera, and were statistically non-homogeneous for Coleoptera, Hymenoptera, Diptera, Lepidoptera, Trichoptera, and Plecoptera. The slopes of the aerial profiles for families remained similar over the years for Carabidae and Elateridae, changed for Staphylinidae, Meloidae, and Scarabeidae, but were statistically non-homogeneous for Coccinellidae, Miridae, and Aphididae. The slopes of the aerial profiles for insect species were similar across years for Coccinella septempunctata L., Melanotus similis (Kirby), and Anatis mali Say, changed for Pyrrhalta luteola (Mull.), Ctenicera pulchra LeConte, Ctenicera tarsalis Melsheimer, Coccinella trifasciata perplexa Muls., Lygus lineolaris (P. de B.), Ctenicera appropinquans Randall, Apis mellifera L., and Adalia bipunctata (L.), but were significantly non-homogeneous only for Hippodamia convergens G.-M. Although most profiles obtained for insect orders in this study were remarkably similar to those reported in the literature, the level of between-year variation at our study site suggests that there is considerable overlap between profiles at all taxon levels. Vertical aerial profiles cannot be considered sufficiently characteristic of the species, family, or order across years for use as indicators of change in biodiversity. The impact of these results on insect monitoring are discussed.