The Role of Digital Financial Inclusion and Governance in Shaping Health Spending: Evidence From the Arab League Region

This paper aims to examine the complex relationship between digital financial inclusion, monetary policy transmission, and economic development in 18 Sub-Saharan African countries from 2004 to 2021. The study utilizes panel data and employs a digital financial inclusion index, broad money growth, and real gross domestic product per capita as proxies for digital financial inclusion, monetary policy transmission, and economic development, respectively. The panel autoregressive distributed lag model results uncover a bi-directional causality between economic development and digital financial inclusion, emphasizing the pivotal role of digital financial inclusion in fostering economic development. Additionally, another bi-directional causality between digital financial inclusion and monetary policy transmission highlights their interdependence. Unidirectional causality from monetary policy transmission to economic development is also established. This study emphasizes the crucial role of robust measures in enhancing digital financial inclusion to avert adverse consequences, offers nuanced insights into policy dynamics, particularly regarding inflation mitigation, and enhances monetary policy effectiveness. These findings underscore the importance of policy reform, legislation, and regulatory improvements to promote digital financial inclusion by Sub-Saharan African central banks. Strengthening rural financial infrastructure is crucial for driving digital financial inclusion, sustainable economic development, and reducing regional inequalities.

PurposeThis study examines the role of institutions and governance on the digital financial inclusion and economic growth nexus in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) from 2014 to 2020.Design/methodology/approachThis study adopts the generalised method of moments technique which controls for endogeneity. The authors employed four main variables namely, index of digital financial inclusion, gross domestic product per capita growth, institutions and governance.FindingsThe results suggest a significant positive effect of institutional quality and governance on the digital financial inclusion-economic growth nexus in SSA. Furthermore, the authors find that effect of trade and population growth on economic growth was significantly positive while inflation reduces economic growth in the region.Research limitations/implicationsThis study also ignored the effect of digital financial inclusion on environmental quality. Future researches should focus on addressing these drawbacks and replicating the study in Africa as a whole and other developing countries across the world that are experiencing digital financial inclusion and economic growth challenges. The results from the study imply that a positive relationship between digital financial inclusion and economic growth. It is important to note that the study was carried out on the premise that institutions play a pivotal role in enhancing economic growth in SSA.Practical implicationsThe results confirm the significance of policies that enhances institutional quality and governance which are other avenues the authorities can pursue to enhance economic growth in SSA.Social implicationsThe paper documents the importance of institutions in boosting economic growth which impacts on social life rather than digital financial inclusion only.Originality/valueThe paper makes a contribution through analysing the role of institutions and governance on the digital financial inclusion-economic growth nexus rather than the traditional financial inclusion–economic growth nexus which is common to the majority of the available empirical studies.

With the deep integration of Internet technology and finance, digital finance has become an indispensable part of inclusive finance and an important driving force for the development of inclusive finance. How inclusive finance affects household wealth under the background of digital penetration has become a hot issue. Based on the advantages of digital finance, this paper compares the differences between traditional and digital inclusive finance, and discusses the mechanism and effect of digital inclusive finance in promoting household wealth.Based on the panel data of China Family Panel Studies（CFPS）, this paper finds that digital inclusive finance helps to increase the level of household wealth, and has greater inclusiveness and a stronger leverage effect than traditional finance. This conclusion is further confirmed by 2SLS test with “geographical distance” as the instrumental variable. Different business types of digital inclusive finance have different promotion effects. Monetary fund, electronic payment and other business types have obvious promotion effects on the overall household wealth. Insurance, credit, online investment and electronic credit also have certain positive effects on the overall wealth, but the impact is small. According to the results of heterogeneity test, the effect of digital inclusive finance on household wealth in the central and western regions is stronger than that in the eastern regions; the role of digital inclusive finance in promoting the increase of household wealth depends on the family’s education level and understanding ability, and has a stronger role in promoting the families with high education level and high understanding ability. The degree of digitalization has a significant negative impact on the overall household wealth, which may be related to the phenomenon of “digital exclusion” in digital inclusive finance. Digital exclusion may weaken the role of digital inclusive finance in promoting the growth of household wealth to a certain extent.The research shows that in order to play the positive role of digital inclusive finance in benefiting the real economy and promoting the growth of household wealth, government departments should promote the deep integration of digital finance and traditional finance, give full play to the respective advantages and characteristics of digital finance and traditional finance, and build a complementary and mutually reinforcing financial service system.This study expands the existing research in three aspects: First, based on the background of digital penetration into the financial field, it examines the mechanism and function of digital inclusive finance on household wealth. Second, it compares and tests the differences between digital inclusive finance and traditional inclusive finance in promoting household wealth. Third, it tries to use geographical distance as an instrumental variable to overcome endogeneity and carry out comprehensive heterogeneity analysis.

Khera et al. (2022) provides a novel measurement of digital financial inclusion using a three-stage principal component approach (PCA) for 52 emerging market and developing economies. Based on this new index, they have found that the adoption of digital financial services has been a key driver of financial inclusion, and countries/regions in Africa and Asia and regions have achieved greater progress. They also warn against a digital divide and call for policies to close the gap. The novelty of this new index rests on three characteristics: it is focused; it is comprehensive, and it utilizes the PCA approach. This index focuses on the payment aspects of financial inclusion, and considers the “access” and “usage” aspects of both digital and traditional aspects of financial inclusion. The three-stage PCA approach first extracts the supply-side and demand-side aspects of financial inclusion for both traditional and digital financial services, then extracts the principal components of the access and usage indices for the traditional and digital financial inclusion, respectively, and finally builds up a comprehensive index encompassing all these subcomponents. The constructed index provides a good chance to measure the level of the adoption of digital financial services in a specific country, and hence provides an instrument for evaluating the policy implications of financial inclusion, especially digital financial inclusion. For example, the subindex provides a chance to evaluate the severeness of the digital divide and the risk of financial exclusion. The indices show wide variations in digital financial inclusion across countries, whether it is mainly driven by a reluctance in constructing more digital financial infrastructure due to financial constraints, or a distrust of digital technology will need further investigation. Overall, this index has great potential for deepening our understanding of the relationships between comprehensive financial inclusion, digital financial inclusion as well as traditional financial inclusion. In this aspect, Khera et al. (2022) may wish to provide more discussions so that the importance of subindices can be better appreciated. For example, Khera et al.’s Figures 1 and 2 indicate that African countries excel in digital financial inclusion, so it would be insightful to explain which of the access and the usage components are relevant in promoting the development in digital financial inclusion. Another example is Khera et al.’s Figure 3 that contains the interesting finding, namely, for countries with low traditional financial inclusion, the variance of traditional financial inclusion is larger than the variance of countries with high-traditional financial inclusion. This implies that efforts in pursuing digital financial inclusion vary more in countries with low levels of traditional financial inclusion. Some additional empirical evidences may also help to convince readers about the validity of this index. For example, Khera et al.'s (2022) Figure 3 ranks Mongolia as the most advanced country in terms of both comprehensive as well as digital financial inclusion, and their Figure 4 shows that Ghana ranks No. 1 in improvements of digital financial inclusion. Presentations of some statistics about access and usage, and the development in traditional financial inclusion between 2014 and 2017 of these two countries would be helpful. Some robustness checks may also help readers and users to appreciate the importance of this index. For example, one way to construct the index is to apply the PCA approach to all the variables in one stage instead of in three stages. Such a strategy can avoid the prediction errors caused by treating the first-stage and second-stage indices directly as raw data, and can also provide readers with a broader view about the financial inclusion status quo.

PurposeThis paper examines the impact and mechanism of China's digital inclusive finance on rural consumption upgrade. First, the impact of the development of digital inclusive finance on the upgrading of rural household consumption structure is to be theoretically analyzed and empirically tested. Secondly, in terms of heterogeneity analysis, it pays attention to the age heterogeneity of users that digital inclusive finance influencing rural residents' developmental consumption upgrade, which is related to the issue of intergenerational “digital gap”. Thirdly, the mechanism of digital inclusive finance in promoting rural consumption upgrade is to be investigated. Finally, how to promote the role of digital inclusive finance in upgrading the structure of rural consumption to a developmental demand level will be showed.Design/methodology/approachFrom the perspective of the micro-household, this study is conducted by using the instrumental variable (IV) method, with 2SLS model and IV-Tobit model, based on the matched city-level data of Digital Inclusive Financial Index (DIFI) with the Chinese Household Financial Survey (CHFS). “The relief degree of land surface” is an ideal instrumental variable of digital inclusive finance, for including regional altitude difference and terrain factors of regional area, has theoretical influence on the development of digital inclusive finance, and is not affected by other economic variables.FindingsThe conclusions show that the digital inclusive finance plays a significant role in promoting the rural households' developmental consumption, but has no significant effect on the rural households' survival-type consumption and hedonistic consumption. Furthermore, this paper examines the impact and mechanism of China's digital inclusive finance on rural consumption upgrade. First, the impact of the development of digital inclusive finance on the upgrading of rural household consumption structure is to be theoretically analyzed and empirically tested. Secondly, it is discovered that digital inclusive finance is age heterogeneous in promoting the upgrade of consumption structure of rural household, and its effect on the elderly is weaker than that on the young for the intergenerational “digital gap”. Thirdly, these conclusions reveal that the digital inclusive finance does affect the consumption of rural residents through three mechanisms: increasing income and wealth, easing liquidity constraints and facilitating payment methods. Finally, how to promote the role of digital inclusive finance in upgrading the structure of rural consumption to a developmental demand level will be showed.Originality/valueThe current research on the relationship between digital inclusive finance and rural consumption only stays at the level of total rural consumption and has not stressed the structural problems of rural consumption. Can digital inclusive finance promote the upgrade of rural consumption structure? To what level can digital inclusive finance promote the upgrading of rural consumption structure? Therefore, it is of great theoretical value to study the upgrading of rural consumption structure from the micro level. Can the current digital inclusive finance benefit the elderly and help break the vulnerability of the elderly to enjoy finance? In this regard, evidence of heterogeneity remains to be provided.

Corporate innovation can be subdivided, according to its approach and novelty, into exploitative innovation and exploratory innovation, i.e., ambidextrous innovation. Defined as actions to promote financial inclusion through digital financial services, digital financial inclusion brings new opportunities for the implementation of corporate innovation projects and the improvement of corporation value. Based on the annual reports (2012–2020) released by 1604 listed SMEs in China and the index of digital financial inclusion from Peking University, this paper explores the way that digital financial inclusion affects the corporation value of SMEs, with some moderating factors such as the financial flexibility, corporate social responsibility and product market competition in ambidextrous innovation. The study shows, in SMEs: (1) digital financial inclusion has a significant positive impact on exploitative innovation, but has less effect on exploratory innovation with a time lag; (2) ambidextrous innovation plays a partial intermediary role in the effect of digital financial inclusion on corporation value; (3) financial flexibility of the enterprise positively moderates the relationship between digital financial inclusion and corporate value. In the short term, corporate social responsibility negatively moderates the relationship between digital financial inclusion and corporate value; however, in the long term, it does contribute to the growth of corporate value. (4) Product market competition positively moderates the relationship between digital financial inclusion and exploitative innovation, but does not positively moderate the relationship between digital financial inclusion and exploratory innovation.

Over the past four decades of reform and opening up, China's economy has achieved a high average annual growth rate of over 9 per cent, becoming the second largest economy in the world. At the same time, China's financial reform and development has been continuously optimized, and the financial industry has maintained rapid development. With the accelerated integration of new-generation digital technology and inclusive finance, the flourishing development of inclusive finance has added strong momentum to the financial services economy. Based on the relevant research literature on inclusive finance at home and abroad and the characteristics of digital finance, we constructed the evaluation index system of cross-country digital inclusive finance level and the evaluation index system of provincial digital inclusive finance level, and evaluated the development level of digital inclusive finance in 31 provinces (municipalities directly under the central government) in China. On this basis, the impact of digital financial inclusion on economic growth is comprehensively analyzed from two perspectives (temporal and spatial dimensions) and two levels (cross-country and provincial levels), and the empirical evidence is analyzed from the temporal dimension by using traditional econometric analysis methods. The increase in the level of digital inclusive finance in a region has a significant contribution to the region's economic growth, and the mediating effects of credit constraints, entrepreneurship, investment and urban-rural income gap between digital inclusive finance and economic growth are proposed and verified through the decomposition of the direct-indirect effects and heterogeneity of the spatial Durbin model. Policy recommendations are proposed through relevant research results to help China's further economic development.

With the deep integration of digital technology and inclusive finance, digital inclusive finance has provided a new opportunity for agricultural high-quality development through “overtaking on curves”. This article empirically examines the impact of digital inclusive finance on agricultural high-quality development and the dynamic mechanism of land circulation in its transmission process, utilizing panel data from various provinces in China from 2011 to 2021. The research indicates that digital inclusive finance has a significant improvement effect on agricultural high-quality development, and this conclusion remains valid after a series of endogenous treatments and robustness tests. Meanwhile, intelligent manufacturing has a more pronounced role in promoting agricultural high-quality development in China’s eastern regions, regions with sound infrastructure, and regions with high environmental regulation intensity. Further research reveals that digital inclusive finance can promote agricultural high-quality development through the mechanism of promoting land circulation. The research conclusions provide important empirical evidence and policy implications for achieving coordinated development of agricultural economic growth and environmental protection, thereby realizing the beautiful vision of comprehensive rural revitalization.

Digital financial inclusion is critical for achieving higher economic growth, sustainable development, and a more financially inclusive nation. Additionally, digital financial inclusion is vital for stabilizing the Islamic banking industry during the COVID-19 epidemic, leveraging its resistance to financial shocks, and fostering financial inclusiveness. Islamic banks are usually considered because of their significant ability to counter financial crises and their prominent contribution to financial landscape. This study investigated the digital financial inclusion and Islamic banking stability nexus using unbalanced panel data from 65 Islamic banks from six countries from 2010 to 2021. This study uses a GMM approach and a Z score. The finding implies that the default risk of the banks in the analyzed area is reduced due to the increased stability of Islamic banking brought about by the broader application of digital financial inclusion. Digital financial inclusion is more strongly correlated with banks' financial soundness. Access to banking services, made possible by digital financial inclusion, also dramatically improves banking stability and makes banks more resilient. Moreover, incorporating digital financial inclusion into Islamic banking promotes inclusive economic development, which may help the industry weather crises like the present COVID-19 epidemic. This study lays out the policy implications that increasing bank stability, bolstering financial literacy, and combining digital financial inclusion with other strategies to keep banks viable.

How does digital financial inclusion affect households’ CO2? Micro-evidence from an emerging country

The use of digital technology by banks and other financial institutions to facilitate financial inclusion is referred to as digital financial inclusion. This fusion of digital finance and traditional banking methods has the potential to impact banks' operational effectiveness. This study uses the panel effects model to examine the link between digital financial inclusion and bank performance in 30 Chinese provinces from 2012 to 2021. This research uses kernel density estimation to examine the spatial-temporal growth patterns of both variables. The mediator variable in examining how digital financial inclusion affects bank performance is risk-taking. Finally, the paper analyses the regional heterogeneity of the impact. It presents the following conclusions: (1) In China, digital financial inclusion and bank performance have constantly increased, with noticeable regional variances in their development levels. This regional inequality has widened gradually since 2018, yet it has not resulted in polarization. (2) The significant positive correlation between digital inclusive finance and banking performance indicates that banking performance tends to increase with the enhancement of digital inclusive finance. (3) Digital financial inclusion impacts bank performance, with risk-taking as a moderator. The spread of digital financial inclusion services enhances banks' willingness to take risks, enhancing overall efficiency. (4) Digital financial inclusion boosts bank performance in the Northwest, South, North, and East regions while lightly inhibiting it in the Central region. Based on the findings, this study makes bank and government suggestions.

"The development of China's digital financial inclusion" is an important research field that has attracted much attention in recent years. Digital financial inclusion refers to the use of emerging technologies such as the Internet, big data, and artificial intelligence to provide the general public with more convenient, efficient, and low-cost financial services. Digital financial inclusion has become an important means to promote financial inclusion. In recent years, the development of my country's digital financial inclusion has achieved world-renowned achievements. However, there are still many issues and challenges to be resolved. For example, information asymmetry, difficulty in risk control, and imperfect regulatory policies are still the main obstacles to the development of digital financial inclusion. This article will discuss the background, development, problems and challenges, and future development directions of China's digital financial inclusion, aiming to give readers a comprehensive understanding of the development status and future trends of China's digital financial inclusion.

Purpose This study aims to explore how institutional quality links digital financial inclusion to inclusive development in lower-middle-income countries, considering heterogeneities. Design/methodology/approach The study uses dynamic generalized method of moments to analyze a balanced panel data set of 48 lower-middle- income countries (LMICs) from 2004 to 2022, sourced from various databases. It assesses four variables and conducts checks for study robustness. Findings The study reveals a positive link between digital financial inclusion and inclusive development in LMICs, confirming theoretical predictions. Empirically, nations with quality institutions exhibit greater financial and developmental inclusion than those with weak institutions, emphasizing the substantial positive impact of institutional quality on the connection between digital financial inclusion and inclusive development in LMICs. For instance, the interaction effect reveals a substantial increase of 0.123 in inclusive development for every unit increase in digital financial inclusion in the presence of strong institutions. The findings provide robust empirical evidence that the presence of quality institutions is a key catalyst for the benefits of digital finance in inclusive development. Originality/value This study offers significant insights into digital financial inclusion and inclusive development in LMICs. It confirms a positive relationship between digital financial inclusion and inclusive development, highlighting the pivotal role of institutional quality in amplifying these benefits. Strong institutions benefit deprived individuals, families, communities and businesses, enabling full access to digital financial inclusion benefits. This facilitates engagement in development processes, aiding LMICs in achieving Sustainable Development Goals.

The aim of this study is to investigate the digital financial inclusion, bank stability and economic growth nexus in Zimbabwe over the period 2014 to 2022. The results of the Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) estimation model reveals that digital financial inclusion and bank stability significantly affects economic growth in Zimbabwe. The findings also reveals a positive relationship between bank competition and digital financial inclusion and also between bank stability and digital financial inclusion suggesting that digital financial inclusion enhances the soundness of individual banks in Zimbabwe through competition. On the other hand, the study found an inverse relationship between digital financial inclusion and corruption; bank stability and inflation; and also between bank competition and bank stability in support of the competition-fragility view. From the policy perspective, the government should implement policies that eradicate corruption and barriers into the financial system to deepen bank competition which is good for bank stability. Banks should create strategic alliances with Fintech Companies in order to boost digital financial inclusion which is a recipe for bank competition and soundness through stability. Future researchers can cross compare countries conditions using panel data rather than time series data as in this study.

Digital financial inclusion is a fundamental component in alleviating poverty and enhancing prosperity. A comprehensive financial system lays the foundation for a basis of robust and resilient households, enhancing the welfare of low-income groups. This research examines the determinants of digital financial inclusion among low-income families in Malaysia, specifically focusing on digital literacy, financial literacy, trust, infrastructure and financial service providers. Total of one thousand one hundred seventy-one respondents with income below the national poverty line were surveyed. The Partial Least Squares-Structural Equation Modelling (PLS-SEM) and the Multigroup Analysis (MGA) techniques were employed. This study separated the total sample into two groups, Peninsular Malaysia and East Malaysia. The results demonstrate that trust, digital literacy and infrastructure are positively and significantly related to digital financial inclusion for all the groups. The role of financial service providers is only supported for the complete sample set and Peninsular Malaysia. Surprisingly, this study found no association between financial literacy and digital financial inclusion. In addition, the MGA results further evidence significant differences between Peninsular Malaysia and East Malaysia in achieving digital financial inclusion. Peninsular Malaysia shows stronger digital literacy and infrastructure, while East Malaysia demonstrates more potents effects of financial service providers and trust in boosting digital financial inclusion. These findings provide practitioners valuable insights into fostering a digitally inclusive financial society. This research includes strengthening consumer protection regulations on digital financial services to address cyber threats, implementing digital literacy campaigns to enhance awareness, and ensuring affordable and reliable internet access. These policy recommendations highlight the importance of formulating and designing tailored strategies to enhance digital financial inclusion among low-income households in Malaysia.